Are Tories falling short of the mark?

Cameron1

by Sam Courtney-Guy

Two weeks ago, Ed Miliband shook the British political scene with his speech at the 2013 Labour Party Conference. With earnest charisma and popular policies he took pundits and politicians alike by surprise, dragging his party into a 10-point lead in opinion polls.

At last week’s Conservative Party Conference, David Cameron hit back with his usual slick delivery and rapture from his Tory colleagues.

But did it succeed? What can his speech tell us about Tory strategy now, and will it strike a chord with the British people?

 The main themes of his speech mostly carried on the trend of the Tory message that we have seen in recent times.

 Cameron began with a predictable introductory spiel, in an attempt to connect with the electorate, with such memorably sycophantic quotes as “I want to thank the people who have done the most to get us this far. You. The British people.”

“I want to thank the people who have done the most to get us this far. You. The British people.”

 He did his best to put across a nauseously upbeat party vision, managing to praise his party’s achievements whilst still pandering to public fears: “Didn’t it feel good seeing [Abu Qatada] get on that plane?”

His speech quickly moved onto jingoistic praise for Britain’s role in history, spending a couple of minutes begging the Scots to stay in “our Kingdom – United”, before praising one of the North’s worst enemies in recounting a cute anecdote about his encounter with Lady Thatcher and declaring her “the greatest peace-time Prime Minister our country has ever had.”

He followed with the well-rehearsed Tory double-strike of blaming Labour for Britain’s fiscal mess and messianic revelations that austerity is the only way out of it.

Looking straight into the camera, reading carefully from the teleprompter, the PM loaded his mortar with more familiar shells. Education featured heavily. His speech focused firmly on a ‘toughening up’ message, feeding off the public’s disillusionment with public exam difficulties and ‘Mickey Mouse’ subjects.

He went over same old story with welfare and immigration, too.

But some things have changed in the Tory party message. Interestingly, Cameron’s speech was scattered with evidence that Tories are on the back foot after a slew of appealing policies and ‘on-message’ rhetoric from Labour leader Ed Miliband two weeks ago.

For example, the Tories’ freeze on fuel duty was many times dug up by the PM as an attempt to deflect the heat of Miliband’s popular proposal to freeze energy prices.

It is not just ‘Red Ed’ knocking at his doorstep. It seems that the Tories want to claw back a few votes from UKIP. Given how well Geoffrey Bloom’s recent bigotry made the rounds, this might just help the Tories snatch the more moderate-minded from his former party.

Ultimately, the Labour lead in the polls has fallen to just five points as of latest figures. Whether this is because of the doubt cast on Miliband’s flagship policy – he has since had to admit that the energy price freeze is not a sure thing – or because the Tories struck a chord with voters, it is hard to tell.

CameronBut one thing is for sure: Cameron has by no means swung his party back into pole position.

Yes, the Tory party conference was slickly coordinated to resonate – many voters still cling to austerity as the way out and see the benefit claimants as a horrifying mass of Mick Philpott clones – but his speech lacked substance. Policy was scarce.

This would not be a problem if, until the Labour Party Conference, the Tories hadn’t focused so much on Miliband’s lack of policies. And although strategy was more clearly defined, it limped out of his mouth and Cameron said the same words for so long that even he seemed bored by them.

He won’t win anyone from UKIP with the promise of a referendum as he’s been promising it to them for too long. He won’t win anyone from Labour as he has no stand-out solution to the cost-of-living crisis.

If he was going to win undecided voters he would have done so by now, as the message just hasn’t changed. It would have helped him if the Tories hadn’t been so startled by Miliband’s performance, too.

Photographs: Telegraph