Churchill on our fivers: a controversial change?
“I have nothing to offer but blood, toil, tears and sweat,” said Sir Winston Churchill on becoming Prime Minister on 10 May 1940. Now, one of Britain’s most well-known statesmen of all time is set to offer the British public his stern, dogged expression on their currency. Under current plans, in 2016 the Bank of England will begin to issue £5 notes with Churchill’s face on it, replacing Elizabeth Fry, the remarkable 19th Century prison reformer and philanthropist. Sharing the new fiver will be a view of Westminster from London’s South Bank, with Big Ben’s clock showing 3 o’clock – the approximate time at which he declared that famous quote in his inaugural speech, which will be printed beneath his portrait.
This has tickled controversy. All the figures on our banknotes are decidedly apolitical, and Churchill does not quite fit the bill. But doesn’t he deserve a place in our currency canon? For the majority of Brits, Churchill is one of the greatest leaders of all time. He even famously placed first in a 2002 BBC poll to judge the ‘100 Greatest Britons’. What better reason for his face to adorn our cash?
In terms of star power, he is more than enough of a contender to join his dosh-dwelling compatriots. Churchill is one of the most quoted orators and writers of all time, and few children will go through a school education’s worth of history lessons without at least having heard of him. As Prime Minister, in charge of a cross-party coalition and at the very forefront of the Allied war effort in the Second World War, he is widely credited with leading Britain to victory. He had a long, illustrious career in the Conservative and Liberal political parties and was a respected historian too. After all, the plans were made – by the outgoing Governor of the Bank of England Mervyn King – at the behest of popular requests and consensus in his organisation.
But is popularity enough to merit this decision? Churchill’s name enjoys something of a personality cult – one which is not shared by everyone. It has become unfashionable to criticise him, as it has at one time or another for figures like Mother Teresa, Abe Lincoln or Lenin. A little history behind the tales of his war leadership begins to debunk his heroic image.
A ‘man of the people’ he was not: even whilst his soldiers fought and died overseas and his citizens toiled on the home front, Churchill was known to enjoy fine food and drink in his bunker beneath the Treasury. “The best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter,” he once said. Sending troops against miners in the Tonypandy riots one hundred years ago left him bitterly resented in Wales.
He was a committed European, favouring unity and friendship in post-war relations, yet many pundits point out that if alive today he would sooner be cosying up to UKIP or the BNP than the Conservative or Liberal parties to which he had belonged. To say he was not keen on independence for Indians, who now make up the largest ethnic minority in the UK at 2.5% of the population, is an understatement. He was no friend to Ireland’s republicans, either.
Even when ideological shots are taken out of the equation, he made mistakes in his most famous calling as a war leader. The Gallipoli campaign to Turkey in the First World War was a disaster worth over 220,000 Allied casualties, and is widely credited to him. Churchill was strongly in favour of using tear gas against the Iraqis in their 1920 revolt, and had similar feelings about using even more extreme chemical weapons against the Germans.
Yet I can’t help but feel that, if it weren’t for Winston Churchill, might I not be enjoying the freedom to even write about this today? Ultimately, the real problem with his appearance on the five pound note is that it is a very political addition to a very non-political canon of faces. The only other politician to have featured was the Duke of Wellington, who graced the same banknote for twenty years. He too is revered for his military importance before anything else; this suggests that leaders with a level of non-political significance make it. So we might not, as some have fretted, have to see Thatcher on the tenner any time soon.
It is far safer to feature figures like Charles Darwin, Adam Smith and Elizabeth Fry. Yes, Winston Churchill is ingrained in the British psyche. But regardless of how you judge them, politicians are divisive. We should stick with cross-party heroes on our banknotes.

