Syrian refugees: through the looking glass

By Ollie CollardSyrianRefugeeCamp-USSD

The UK is expected to take in up to 500 of the most vulnerable Syrian refugees – predominantly women and children – over the next year, as civil war continues to devastate the country.

The government’s announcement comes after a recent intensification in anti-immigration rhetoric and the commencement of Syrian peace talks in Geneva, where diplomats face the difficult task of guiding the two warring sides out of the minefield of conflict and onto some common ground.

If the backlash of public opinion in the USA and the UK helped to draw back the ominous helping hand that hovered above Syria at the start of September, then this time, the activism of a few dedicated campaigners has swayed a cavilling Home Department to empty its pockets.

A letter published in the Independent on 18th January called on the Prime Minister to take part in the international UN effort to provide asylum to 30,000 Syrian refugees. 25 signatories, including representatives of Amnesty International UK, Oxfam, Muslim Aid and the Refugee Council, pointed out the double standard of expecting impoverished border-nations like Lebanon to take people in, while refusing to do so here.

Public opinion has probably curtailed efforts to drag David Cameron and Home Secretary Theresa May away from the braying right wing of their party into a token moral stance.

A recent YouGov poll suggested that 47% of Britons were opposed to admitting Syrian refugees, although 39% were open to the proposal.

YouGov: 47% of Britons opposed to admitting Syria refugees

To some extent, the issue has split down partisan lines with opposition flooding in from supporters of UKIP and the Conservatives and agreement from those backing the Liberal Democrats, Labour and the Green Party. Cameron and May have probably helped to shift the parameters of immigration discourse to the right through appeals to would-be UKIP defectors over Bulgarian and Romanian immigration.

A series of targets and promises to lower net immigration have produced a somewhat compromised Tory position, while Labour has been pressing for admission of Syrian refugees. Shadow Home Secretary Yvette Cooper remarked that it would be “shameful” for the UK to ignore the crisis.

Cooper may well have been part of the retinue of MPs and activists calling for us to provide sanctuary, but her assessment of the situation is something of an auxesis.

Though often quicker to find the moral high ground over Syria than the Conservatives, Labour have been equally quick to claim a bloated moral authority too.

In September, Douglas Alexander suggested that the Labour-triggered parliamentary vote regarding a possible intervention helped to avert a military strike.

In some ways, Labour are as much a part of the problem as a part of the solution. Ed Miliband and his party consistently fail to articulate a coherent alternative to the coalition’s fiscal policy, as British political parties elide into one another.

Facing objections to Syrian refugees, partly because of their different culture and largely because of their cost to the state, we are painfully reminded that our political system offers us a unilateral socio-economic vision of insular austerity. This vision provides the parameters for political debate in contemporary British politics.

Syria has been a self-interested venture for the west from the start; a kind of distorting mirror wherein we hope to vainly contemplate our best selves.

What kind of a people, what kind of a party, what kind of a nation, does what we do in Syria show us to be? At worst, what can we get out of Syria?

Self-scrutiny is all very well of course but what is notable in these formulations is that what is good for the Syrian people is not the first consideration. This was exemplified by Barack Obama’s ‘red line’ theatrics last September; the great orator puffing up his chest, using the case for Syrian intervention to promote his country’s, his party’s and his own nobility.

While we primp and posture, there are people who are living and dying behind that mirror in a ceaseless flux of reported atrocity. The Guardian estimates that there are have been over two million refugees displaced by the war so far, most of them innocent people immured in the violence of two morally questionable forces.

If this particular concession is a miniscule triumph for basic decency, it is clearly not enough. Compare our piecemeal commitment with that of Germany, who will offer refuge to 10,000 displaced Syrians.

That we should be caught up in economic debate about immigration, while helpless people are at risk of continued violence and exploitation, betrays the self-interestedness of a country which has followed its transatlantic partner into the Middle East as a prospector.

Photograph: US State Department