Is unrequited love always a bad thing?

w. b. yeats- A. Currell (600x400)

By Steph Horrocks

Imagine proposing to someone four times over a ten year period and being rejected every time. This was the unfortunate situation for one of Ireland’s greatest poets, W. B. Yeats. His first meeting with Maud Gonne in the January of 1889 was what he later called the beginning of “the troubling of [his] life”. She was a statuesque, outspoken heiress with firm Irish nationalist beliefs who had enjoyed one of his poems and sought him out to strike up a friendship. Their relationship developed over time from that of acquaintances to that of the artist and his muse.

It’s obvious that Yeats was ridiculously in love with her, hence the four proposals (and the four rejections). This heartache was made all the worse by Maud’s decision to marry someone else in 1903, Major John MacBride, although the marriage ended in separation amidst rumours of domestic abuse. At one point, Yeats even proposed to Maud’s daughter Iseult. This move fell flat on its face when she rejected him too. Yeats was finally married in 1917 to Georgie Hyde-Lees, with whom he had two children. Despite their differing feelings for each other, Yeats and Maud remained very close friends until the poet’s death in 1939.

Is Yeats’s unrequited love a sad affair? Perhaps. Loving someone who doesn’t love you back is not an ideal situation. However, maybe it was for the best that Yeats and Maud never got together. As a pair, they were reminiscent of Marvell’s lovers in ‘The Definition of Love’: two parallel lines, perfectly in tune with one another – yet their love was never consummated. Maud certainly thought this was a good thing. She argued that ‘poets should never marry’ and that if they had married, Yeats might never have written such brilliant works of literature and she wouldn’t have been as involved in Irish activism. The world, in short, would be less bright today. Instead, Yeats had to content himself with the pain his love caused him by turning it into works of art. His mood towards his muse ranged from poem to poem – occasionally he was bitter (‘No Second Troy’), other times he was melancholic (‘When You Are Old’).

In ‘A Drinking Song’, Yeats sets a wistful yet calm tone. From an English student’s point of view, I could say many things about this poem. It’s a lyric poem, six lines in length with an interlaced rhyming scheme. In addition, it’s written in the first person and is addressing someone. There are references to mouths and eyes, and there’s a caesura in the middle of the last line that slows down the last words of the poem. But what does it all mean, really?

Imagine proposing to someone four times over a ten year period and being rejected every time

It’s a simple, soft poem that is overlooked in comparison to Yeats’s other great works that tackle the Easter Rising or Irish folklore. Yeats isn’t trying to do anything fancy with the rhyme scheme or metre because his feelings aren’t complex: he loves someone, and that’s that. The ‘someone’ is ambiguous; who is he talking about when he says ‘I’ or ‘you’? It could be about anyone, or from anyone’s point of view. That being said, Yeats presumably has someone particular in mind – and this someone did not share his feelings.

In ‘A Drinking Song’, Yeats seems to have touched upon something new: unrequited love is still love, and such love can still bring happiness alongside the pain. Maybe the final sigh is one of contentment, not of sadness.

Maybe to some, unrequited love can be good. Sometimes, the other person may be so fantastic that just being with them is enough. It doesn’t really matter that you’re not together or even that they’re blissfully unaware of your feelings. Like a good wine, they fill you up with this inexplicable warmness and make everything sort of buzz and glow. In today’s media love is presented as a storm, full of drama and action until it all blows over and everyone is content. It doesn’t have to be like that. Love can feel like a cold winter’s day, the sun on your face making you forget about the stinging wind. Sometimes, it’s enough just to sit with the one you love, because the adoration folded in you makes you feel twice as light. On the rare occasion, unrequited love can be better for you than requited love.

If you love someone who doesn’t love you back this Valentine’s Day, don’t be too upset. Be thankful they’re giving you excellent writing material.

A Drinking Song by W. B. Yeats (1916)

Wine comes in at the mouth

And love comes in at the eye;

That’s all we shall know for truth

Before we grow old and die.

I lift the glass to my mouth,

I look at you, and I sigh.

Image by A. Currell via Flickr