How long does Mikel Arteta have?

By Daniel Evans

Touchline antics, an intense personality and bizarre excuses for defeat have made Mikel Arteta a polarising figure. Even so, he took over an Arsenal team hovering in midtable and has built one of the strongest sides in Europe. Season on season he has improved his points return and players like Bukayo Saka and Martin Odegaard have flourished under his guidance.

Arteta has also overseen sweeping cultural changes at Arsenal, fostering a closer connection with the fans and a work ethic among the team not seen since the early 2000s. This has been achieved with significant investment, but Arsenal’s net spend is lower than the likes of Tottenham since 2019, who currently languish just above the relegation zone. The summer 2024 window also saw Arsenal turn a profit with numerous outgoings. Not bad at all for a manager still in his first job.

What do Arsenal have to show for all this improvement? One FA cup and two community shields is a poultry return over five years, and this has raised questions in some quarters over just how much longer Arteta should remain at the helm.

The 2024/25 season has thus far been a frustrating one for the Gunners. The squad has been plagued with injuries almost from the outset and numerous key decisions have gone against them. Odegaard, Saka and Saliba either have or will be out for significant periods and the loss of key players like Ben White and Takehiro Tomiyasu have repeatedly unbalanced the starting eleven. Arsenal possesses one of the smallest squads in the league and they do not have close to the depth required to absorb these losses. Such absences have necessitated calling on the academy for the likes of Miles Lewis-Skelly and Ethan Nwaneri. Both of whom look like exciting talents, however no sooner had Nwaneri shown promise, he too was ruled out through injury.

The football has been tepid at times and performances in recent months utterly toothless, but Arsenal is a strong side that is exceptionally hard to beat

Even in the face of these problems Arsenal’s form is remarkably similar to that of last season. In both instances, the team have earned 43 points after 21 games. The defence, which has been far leakier, is still second best in the league. Despite possessing no significant threat leading the line, the club still ranks fifth for goals scored and third for wins. The point is not that Arsenal have been anything close to their best, but these stats are illustrative of the foundation that Arteta has built. The football has been tepid at times and performances in recent months utterly toothless, but Arsenal is a strong side that is exceptionally hard to beat.

A narrow defeat to “the worst team maybe in the history of Manchester United” in the FA cup is a bitter pill to swallow. Especially considering a stack of missed chances. Newcastle also played Arsenal off the pitch in the home leg of the league cup semi-final meaning options for silverware have dwindled significantly.

A first champions league remains doubtful, and the league title has fast slipped away. Even so, it is unlikely the Arsenal board will turn on its manager. Unusually, Arsenal have decided to take the long view in recent years, sticking by Arteta and showing a degree of patience that few other clubs have. It is clear that Arsenal’s problems this season would not be fixed by sacking him. If anything, such an action would exacerbate them. There is no clear replacement and fixes, namely signing a striker, are fairly obvious ones.

This has been a season to forget. Failure to capitalise on a temporarily faltering Manchester City and poor Liverpool form is painful for an Arsenal fanbase desperate for silverware. The long wait for major honours appears to have been extended and management of a paper-thin squad has been poor by almost every metric. Questions should be asked but blame simply cannot be fixed on one figure. The board is unlikely to lose patience, but certain fans might well do. Choppy seas are to be expected, and Arteta will be given the time to steer a course through them. As he should be.

Image: Ank kumar via Wikimedia Commons