The LA Fires, what next?

By Daniel Evans

2024 saw severe flooding across California as a foot of rain was dumped onto the state. This led to power outages, mudslides and significant plant growth. These plants, though initially a welcome sight, have spent the year steadily drying out in exceptionally long drought conditions. Vast swaths of ground were turned into a tinder box and the Santa Ana Winds roaring in from the Great Basin threatened to turn a spark into an inferno. So began the seven LA fires of January 2025. Fires that have killed upwards of 27 people, displaced tens of thousands more and destroyed over 13,000 buildings. Estimates for damages range between $130 billion – $150 billion and the smoke hanging over the city poses a continuing health risk to its population. Insurance companies have accelerated their withdrawal, and it has been suggested that the planned mass deportations promised by President Trump will drive up the costs of reconstruction.

Questions should be asked about government handling of this crisis. How was an urban fire on this scale able to spread so fast? Could these fires have been managed more effectively? What can be done to improve responses to the next inferno? Controlling urban development, improving standards of construction and rebuilding destroyed neighbourhoods with a better understanding of risks are logical next steps. President Trump has slammed both the Federal and State government response, calling Democratic governor Gavin Newsome ‘incompetent’. He has blamed the scale of the disaster on Newsome’s refusal to sign a ‘water restoration document’ and the decision to protect ‘useless fish’ in the north of the state. No such document appears to exist and water that has supposedly been diverted to protect the California Smelt would not have helped to fill LA’s reservoirs which were not at significantly low levels on January 7th . The fact that the Santa Ynez reservoir was out of action is significant, but this was for maintenance, not to protect species hundreds of miles away. Perhaps stripping funding from federal agencies, scrapping a slew of environmental regulations and politicising disaster relief are more effective ways to proceed? Trump is planning to visit the state after his inauguration, so it remains to be seen what kind action will be taken at the Federal level over the course of his second term.

One issue that has been consistently raised is that of LA Fire Department funding. City Mayor Karen Bass has been criticised for cuts of around 2.7% to the department, with fire chief Kristin Crowley stating that they had ‘severely’ affected operational ability. On paper, these cuts appear poorly thought out, however recent claims have often ignored real terms increases to the budget. According to the LA Times, it has in fact grown 7% due to $53 million of wage increases and $58 million in equipment purchases coming into effect after the budget’s release. City administrative official Matt Szabo claimed that ‘budget reductions did not reduce the number of firefighters who responded’ and stated that the service could ‘deploy whatever resources’ were necessary with costs being covered afterwards. Reports of low fire hydrant pressure have been called ‘deeply troubling’ by Governor Newsome; however, Jesse Keenan of Tulane University has pointed out that no hydrant system on earth is designed for a forest scale conflagration. The scale of the crisis cannot be blamed on funding alone. Irresponsible urban planning has played a significant role along with the simple fact that the scale of the problem is growing exponentially past the point of control.

One issue that has been consistently raised is that of LA Fire Department funding. City Mayor Karen Bass has been criticised for cuts of around 2.7% to the department

Climate change makes wildfires larger, more intense and harder to manage. Since the 1970s, the amount of California burned has increased five-fold and in 2022 a megadrought worse than has been seen any time in the last 1200 years scorched the south of the state. 2024 was the first year to pass 1.5 degrees of warming from pre-industrial levels and planet warming gas in the atmosphere rose faster than ever previously recorded. The Palisades and Eaton fires are the second and fourth most destructive in the California’s history, however we may look back on them as some of the smallest of this century.

The LA fires are a wake-up call, or they should be. Some, like the Executive Director of the Sienna Club Ben Jealous view the incoming Republican administration as a ‘wholly owned subsidiary’ of the fossil fuel industry, reflecting a deep pessimism among progressives for the coming term. Trump stands on a platform that rejects climate science, and he has already triggered a withdrawal from the Paris Climate Agreement. The state can improve its reaction, but to cheerfully ignore the root cause is to invite catastrophe with open arms.

Image Credit: BulkyOS via Wikimedia Commons