A game of two halves: Erik ten Hag should be sacked by Manchester United

By Ben Reidel and Daniel Evans

In a new feature included in every print edition, two writers take part in a head-to-head debate surrounding a key issue in the world of sport. This week, we gave two contributors, Ben Reidel and Daniel Evans, whether they agreed or disagreed with the statement: Erik ten Hag should be sacked by Manchester United.

Yes (Ben Reidel, Sport Contributor):

Erik ten Hag’s tenure at Manchester United has been gloriously dramatic. Packed with in-house controversy, outbursts against the media and the occasional satisfactory performance, Manchester United’s last two seasons have provided consistent entertainment to neutrals, and a perpetual risk of cardiac arrest for those associated with the club. While he saved his job at the eleventh hour last season with a shock FA Cup victory, the honeymoon period has not lasted long, and United have again started this season poorly.

The Dutchman’s spell has been marred by both footballing issues and his personal attitude. His tactical vision for his side as “the best counter-attacking team in the world” has been poorly implemented, leaving his team looking unoiled and structurally frail, especially in midfield, in the face of stern opposition. Signings have been below par, with an assortment of big money players proving unsuitable for the team’s setup. Squad-building and tactical pragmatism are arguably the two most important attributes of a successful coach, and ten Hag has not reliably exhibited either.

His tendency to resort to denial of fault in the face of criticism or adversity portrays him as shockingly insecure, and such a dismissive attitude can be deeply harmful to a club in as much turmoil as United are.

His most strikingly negative characteristic, however, is his hubristic and petulant approach to his public appearances. A correct offside decision given against his team in a narrow loss at Arsenal last September became a consistent excuse for his team’s league position, despite their 13 other defeats throughout the campaign. After scraping through the FA Cup semi-finals on penalties against Championship side Coventry City after nearly losing the game from a 3-0 lead at half-time, ten Hag called the media’s criticism of his team “embarrassing”, even though his players responded to winning by apologising to the travelling fans.

His tendency to resort to denial of fault in the face of criticism or adversity portrays him as shockingly insecure, and such a dismissive attitude can be deeply harmful to a club in as much turmoil as United are. They are yet to fully recover from Sir Alex Ferguson’s departure and require someone with maturity and tactical nous to lead a large-scale overhaul of the club’s rotten foundations. That is not Erik ten Hag, and his era, therefore, must come to an end.

No (Daniel Evans, Sport Contributor):

“Getting rid of the boss won’t solve United’s problems. It’s the majority of the United team who should get the sack. The club have signed a number of players who should all have done a decent job for the side. But with a couple of notable exceptions, none of them have done the business”.

So wrote Jimmy Greaves in 1987. Ferguson did not win a league title until his fifth full season and in that time guided United to 11th, 13th and 6th place finishes. In 1990 they even ended the season five points from the relegation zone. Greaves’ words are familiar ones and should be a lesson to those calling for the head of the current boss. 

This is only ten Hag’s third full season, and he should be given the chance that history has repeatedly proven can pay dividends. 

Is Erik ten Hag the next Ferguson? The answer to that question is most definitely not. Does that mean he should be sacked after just 2 full seasons, one of which saw his side finish third? The answer to that question should be obvious to any level-headed reader. Since taking the reins, the Dutchman has overseen a club in turmoil both on and off the pitch. Disinterested and parasitic owners. A vulture-like English press. High profile players who’s bloated egos have necessitated strong action. Even so, he has brought through exciting young talents like Alejandro Garnacho and the excellent Kobbie Mainoo. He has also won two pieces of silverware; the 22/23 league cup and the 23/24 FA cup comfortably against all conquering title winners Manchester City. 

It is impossible to ignore that recent results and performances have been well below par. Last season’s eighth place finish was unacceptable. To continue to employ a manager after such ‘embarrassing’ and ‘inconsistent’ performances is inconceivable. Except these were words once used by Gary Neville’s in his analysis of Arsenal three years ago. Arsenal stuck by their manager. He was backed and allowed to remodel the club in his own image and the results of this trust are clear. This is only ten Hag’s third full season, and he should be given the chance that history has repeatedly proven can pay dividends. 

Image: Abdelkrim Abdali via Wikimedia Commons