Coalition chaos in Austria: what happens now?
By Daniel Evans
One month on from the 2024 legislative elections, the far-right Freedom Party of Austria (FPÖ) remain unable to form a government.
The party described by Dr Walter Manoschek as the “indirect successors” of the Austrian Nazis won a historic victory in September. For the first time gaining the largest share of the vote with 28.8%. Historic though this result is, late rallying by the centre right Austrian People’s Party (ÖVP) secured 26.3%. Both the Social Democratic Party of Austria (SPÖ) and The New Austria and Liberal Forum (NEOS) also saw their shares remain stable at 21.1% and 9.1% respectively. It is therefore important to acknowledge that this result does not represent the collective will of the Austrian electorate.
Having been founded in the 1950s by former members of the Nazi Party, the FPÖ are not a new force in Austrian politics.
In 1999 they achieved 27% of the vote under their charismatic leader Jörg Haider. The subsequent coalition was so controversial it saw 14 EU nations more or less cut diplomatic ties. Actions perhaps unsurprising considering Haider spoke in admiringly about the “strength of character” possessed by members of the Waffen SS. Haider also insisted that Nazi concentration camps were merely labour camps, a claim that is manifestly false. The FPÖ entered coalition once more in 2017 with 26% of the vote under leader Heinz-Christian Strache.
On neither occasion would their time in power last long. In 2017, ‘the Ibiza affair’ saw a video appearing to show Strache bargaining business contracts for positive coverage with the supposed niece of Russian oligarch Igor Makarov. This scandal saw the coalition break down and resulted in a snap election.
Such incidents were by no means isolated to the FPÖ however. Similar scandals have plagued the ruling ÖVP since 2019. Chancellor Sebastian Kurz and multiple others have been forced to resign after paying for positive opinion polls, with Kurz also indicted for making false statements to a parliamentary enquiry. There was also alleged involvement from major media outlets which has only further sank the party and Austrian politics into a mire of distrust and sleaze.
The SPÖ have also stagnated under leader Andreas Babler. A self-described Marxist, many of his policy positions are left of the prevailing Austrian mood and infighting within the social democrats prevent them from mounting a proper challenge or offering a desirable option for many voters.
Unlike their opponents the FPÖ have flourished in this environment and new leader Herbet Kickl has effectively taken advantage of the instability and fragmentation. The self-styled ‘people’s chancellor’ (a term once used to describe Hitler), Kickl follows in Haider’s footsteps in more ways than one. This post 2019 rise has also been fuelled by inflation and widespread anti-immigration sentiment. Kickl’s promises of creating a ‘fortress Austria’ where ‘political Islam’ is banned, and re-migration is enacted have resonated strongly with certain voters and has propelled his party into a position of strength that it has not enjoyed before. The FPÖ has also adopted a strongly pro-Russia stance; In 2016 a co-operation agreement was signed with President Vladimir Putin and in 2023 its MPs marched from Parliament before a speech by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.
Why then has it been unable to form a government? One of the simplest answers is the FPÖ leader Kickl himself. The ÖVP have not ruled out forming a coalition but have firmly rejected the possibility of Kickl assuming the chancellorship. A coalition with the Liberals, Social democrats or greens also seems unlikely; they are much further away ideological than the ÖVP and have also ruled out the possibility of enabling a Kickl chancellorship. A post he is apparently unwilling to concede.
The opposing parties are caught in something of a Catch-22
The opposing parties are caught in something of a Catch-22. To enter a coalition with Kickl is to risk being tied to a party with a poor track record walking the corridors of power. Such an alliance would also lose voters who detest the FPÖ. On the other hand, by forming their own grand coalition, they would risk further fuelling far-right claims that the mainstream system is conspiring against the will of the people. The FPÖ does not possess anything nearing a plurality, so governing alone would be more or less impossible. The result has been a month long dead-lock that shows few signs of letting up. At least for now, the lines have been drawn and each side appears to be waiting for the other to blink.
Events in Austria appears to have followed a wider European trend of far-right induced political instability. In the Netherlands it took six months for a government to be formed in the wake of Geert Wilders’ victory in November 2023. In France it took the combined efforts of almost the entire political community to halt Marine La Pen’s National Rally and negotiations have been fraught in the aftermath. In Germany Olaf Sholz’s ruling social democrats are beset by a sustained challenge from Alternative für Deutschland. Recent European Parliamentary elections also saw an increase for right-wing and far-right parties, increases particularly fuelled by gains in France and Germany.
It is likely that Austria will witness a prolonged Dutch-style negotiation followed by an uneasy agreement. In many ways, it serves the Austrian opposition to see the FPÖ in government. Uniting in the way that French politics has would risk further instability and could prove the anti-mainstream conspiracy. The FPÖ itself now must compromise on some of its bold promises if it wishes to govern. It will be interesting to see if it can survive such compromises.
Image credit: C.Stadler/Bawg/Wikimedia Commons

