Is there a link between milk and acne?

By Ambika Robinson

The global prevalence of people diagnosed with acne increased by almost 15% among people ages 10 to 24 between 1990 and 2021. However, the British Association of Dermatologists has estimated that acne affects 95% of people when considering people who self-manage their acne. The increased diagnosis rates may be due to a number of factors, such as a change in lifestyle, diet, stress, increased exposure to pollution and sun, and an increased likelihood of people seeking treatment.

The increased diagnosis rates may be due to a number of factors, such as a change in lifestyle, diet, stress, increased exposure to pollution and sun, and an increased likelihood of people seeking treatment. 

What is acne?

Acne is a cutaneous (skin-related inflammatory disorder most commonly characterised through various types of skin lesions, such as spots, blackheads and cysts. These lesions all begin in the sebaceous follicles (pilosebaceous units). The main factors causing acne are increased or altered sebum content (influenced by androgens), bacterial pathogens (primarily Propionibacterium acnes), inflammation due to the release of inflammatory mediators into the skin, abnormal keratinisation on the skin surface, and hormonal changes. 

The sebaceous glands produce sebum, an oily substance that lubricates and protects the  skin. Sebaceous glands are found on the skin’s surface all over the body except for the palms of the hands and soles of the feet. Sebaceous glands are particularly sensitive to androgens (sex hormones) whose production spikes during puberty, hence the higher rates of acne during puberty.

The skin microbiome also plays a key role in acne. Cutibacterium acnes (also known as Propionibacterium acnes) is a skin microbiota commonly found in the sebaceous glands. It is an opportunistic pathogen, which means it can live un-dangerously on the skin and will only act as a pathogen when the opportunity presents itself.

Diet and Acne: Dairy in Western Diets

The prevalence of acne has been found to be higher in populations that eat a ‘Western diet’.  Western diets are characterised by hyperglycaemic foods and milk consumption. This diet is supposed to influence sebum, insulin, and androgen levels, all of which enhance acne pathogenesis.

How does milk influence acne?

One study found that women who drank at least two glasses of skim milk per day were 44% more likely to have acne than those who drank less or none. The link between milk consumption and acne is there, but what are the reasons for it? 

Milk contains androgens, steroidal and non-steroidal growth hormones, the proteins whey and casein, and milk-derived amino acids, all of which are intended to stimulate growth and development in calves. Some theorise that when humans drink this milk, these growth factors interact with human processes and confuse the normal signalling patterns.

One study found that women who drank at least two glasses of skim milk per day were 44% more likely to have acne than those who drank less or none

Milk consumption has been found to induce increased androgen, sebum, and insulin production in humans. An increased level of androgens due to milk consumption can result in androgen-stimulated hyperkeratinisation (overproduction of keratin, resulting in thick, tough layers), obstruction of hair follicles and sebaceous glands, and a failure in normal skin cells to turnover (desquamation) to keep pores clear.

One major acne-influence factor whose production is stimulated upon milk consumption is Insulin Growth Factor-1 (IGF-1). IGF-1 is the main regulator of growth hormones and affects almost all the organ systems. It is secreted throughout the human lifespan, but its peak production occurs during puberty. It stimulates the proliferation of epidermal (skin) cells, the production of sebum and the secretion of hormone factors, contributing to increased inflammation and sebum production. It has been proven that androgens, steroidal and non-steroidal growth hormones also stimulate IGF-1,enhancing acne pathogenesis.

While milk itself is low in sugar, the carbohydrates in milk are eventually broken down into glucose, which is why milk is labelled as an insulin secretagogue — that is, it promotes insulin production. The whey and casein found in milk also stimulate insulin production. Some studies suggest that a low- glycaemic diet is an effective acne treatment, as there are lower levels of insulin.

Milk consumption has been found to induce increased androgen, sebum, and insulin production

Whole milk or skimmed milk?

Several studies show a stronger link between acne and skim milk than whole milk. Research suggests that whole milk’s higher fat content may lead to feeling full sooner, which could result in lower overall consumption compared to skim milk. It is the volume of milk that creates an increased risk of acne. The other theory is that the fat-reduction process that milk undergoes to create skimmed milk has additives and different hormones which affect acne. 

So, while there is yet to be a certified link between milk and acne, it is clearly there. Milk has many different components, and while only the main components were covered in this article, the same culprits in the human response activate and trigger acne pathogenesis.

Image: Sedef94 via Wikimedia Commons