Drink, by all means — but not (to) that

By Bilal Junejo

On Boxing Day last year — tempus fugit! — the BBC brought out a report entitled “Whisper it — alcohol-free wine has arrived in France”. Whilst I did better by raising only an eyebrow, it occurs to me that those who are less addicted to teetotalism might genuinely struggle — and might indeed have already done — to emulate my dry example. Even I had never thought I would live to witness anyone reporting (as the BBC has managed so nonchalantly to do) that.

In the vineyards of Bordeaux, the unspeakable has become the drinkable. Wine without alcohol has arrived. The heresy of yesterday is now — thanks to science and economic crisis — the opportunity of today. Wine estates which would have torched their grapes rather than submit to such ignominy, are now openly contemplating the booze-free bottle. And developers are moving ahead fast, creating wines that are deliberately designed to get the best from the de-alcoholisation process.

BBC

I do not think it is necessary for mr to bore you with a reproduction of the report’s remainder, when I could just as easily put to better use the space that has been lavished upon me in the columns of this excellent paper by giving you my observations concerning what we have both read now. It seems to me that if there are more things in heaven and earth than can be dreamt of in anyone’s philosophy, even the Bard, notwithstanding his own undisputed greatness, might have wondered whether it was only a coincidence that I, a mere mortal, should have read the British Broadcasting Corporation’s report only a week prior to alighting upon another equally unexpected one in respect of a related subject in the archives of The Daily Telegraph. Appearing on the eleventh page of the issue which came out on 2 January 1933 (i.e. the first month of the new year, in which we shall also be contemplating it) — and entitled most curiously “US jury may test beer — is it intoxicating or not?” — this report from The Daily Telegraph’s correspondent in New York informs its impatient reader that:

The question, ‘Does beer intoxicate?’ is now being discussed throughout the country. It may be officially answered this week, if the proposal of Senator Dill to try the beverage on ‘a jury of tasters’ is accepted. Opponents of the plan declare that such a test would hold the Senate up to world ridicule.
They also object on the ground that it would be difficult to determine whether the beer tasters were drunk or sober. But one Senator suggested that, if the beer-filled men could say, ‘The wind ceaseth’ without stuttering, they were undoubtedly sober.

BORAH’S WARNING
Senator Borah warned his colleagues that they were liable to criminal prosecution if the jurymen become intoxicated. The plan has aroused considerable merriment, although upon its outcome may depend the fate of beer in the present session of Congress. If the test should prove beyond question that beer containing 4 per cent. of alcohol by volume does not intoxicate, the Senate would probably accept the proposal, already approved by the House of Representatives, to legalise the consumption of beer immediately, pending consideration of the more serious plan to throw out Prohibition altogether.

The daily telegraph

If you ever come across anything that makes you want to laugh (and you find you enjoy your convulsions), it might not be a good idea to try to ascertain what it was precisely about that thing which made you do so, as all analyses are supposed to embody only the utmost solemnity (which does not sit well with the ability of anyone or anything to be funny, much less ridiculous). Here, what it might be better to mull over, would be the variation in response to the same incubus. The BBC’s report makes it clear that if “the heresy of yesterday is now … the opportunity of today”, it is “thanks to science and economic crisis”.

In 1933, when The Daily Telegraph’s report came out in the first week of the new year, the United States of America (along with the rest of the world) was still reeling from the worst effects of the Great Depression. Mr Franklin Delano Roosevelt, who had been elected to the presidency only two months earlier on the basis of his promise to usher in what everyone now remembers as his famously successful ‘New Deal’ for the American people, was but another two months away from becoming the last president of the United States to be inaugurated on 4th March, rather than on 20th January (courtesy of the Twentieth Amendment). But what was the most notable thing that happened after Mr Roosevelt had been sworn in? It was that Prohibition, which had begun in January 1920 after enabling legislation known as the Volstead Act had been enacted to execute the (in)famous Eighteenth Amendment, was ended by ratification of the Twenty-First Amendment in December 1933. In other words, there was no question that ‘booze’ (notwithstanding my dislike of the word) had to make a comeback if the task was to make America great again. Nearly (or only?) a hundred years later, with a fellow teetotaller (vis-à-vis yours truly) set to return to the White House, ambitious compatriots of the Marquis de Lafayette are delighted to have discovered a way of battling their economic ills by deciding to go increasingly dry. One wonders what Senators Borah and Dill make of that from their heavenly abode (and indeed of President Macron’s France in general). There is so much here of which to make whatever anyone will — but never forget, no matter what you conclude, how interesting each and every one of us has a right, and not infrequently the power, to be!

As someone for whom the juice of an orange alone is sufficient to teach how menacing the perils of addiction can be, I could not care less as to what becomes of alcohol. But my detractors must also know that I am a great believer in liberty, especially of the individual kind — and there is no better proof I can offer of my good intentions than to sign off with the declaration that “I disapprove of what they [drink], but I will defend to the death their right to [drink] it.”

Image credit: Matthieu Joannon via Unsplash