Letters to the Editors

On Sex and the City

To the Editors,

When we envisage university life, it’s hard not to picture the heaps of work, late-night study sessions, and a sea of students in search of their “bright futures”. But somewhere between our 9am lectures and mid-week hangovers, there’s another module no one hands you on day one: romantic relationships.

I couldn’t help but wonder: is university the time to find your soulmate, or is it just a project in self-discovery?

This is my best Carrie Bradshaw impression. While university has thus far proved to be formative years in shaping my adulthood, no experience has yet triumphed the mind-altering impact of Sex and The City. Following four women in New York in their thirties navigate their dating lives, work-life, and female friendships, the cult-classic ultimately succeeded in changing the narrative around women and their sexuality, and placed femininity, in all its forms, on the main stage.

Typically, every girl can be attributed to one of the female protagonists. While some may identify themselves mostly with Samantha, due to their sexual confidence or emotional detachment, others view themselves as Charlotte, albeit for their more conservative perspectives, sensitivity, or adamance to achieve their individual goals. For me, I would consider myself a Carrie Bradshaw. I never know whether to feel content or frustrated with such a comparison, but this proves the exact reason why this cult-classic is the phenomenal show it is. 

For with each character’s attraction comes their flaws; what we dislike about each of the four women resembles our distaste and recognition of our own flaws. When I observe Carrie’s selfishness, Samantha’s emotional unavailability, Charlotte’s short-sightedness, and Miranda’s harsh judgement, I am forced to ask myself – is this really what I dislike about the protagonists, or myself? Each individual woman represents the different ‘fonts’ of femininity and validates them. The beauty of the show is that, while it stresses to be bold, confident, and independent in a world where female empowerment remains very much over-shadowed, our flaws, inconsideration, and lack of self-awareness are normalised too.

By Erin Donnelly

The real happiest place on Earth

To the Editors,

Whoever made the sweeping statement of a claim that Walt Disney World is the happiest place on earth had clearly never made it to Fairfield Residential Home in North Oxford. I would even encourage Finland, the apparent happiest country in the world, to look at the stellar example set by, in my opinion, the greatest place in the universe any human being could call home. As of May 2024, the world’s superlative older relative, my Grannie, conveniently named Annie, moved into Fairfield following a hip operation. This move has been the definition of every cloud has a silver lining, so thank you Grannie for taking one for the team! Words cannot do justice to the haven that is Fairfield, and I can only hope my choices from the Oxford lexicon will begin to communicate its brilliance. I fear even such a prestigious guidebook lacks tools to shepherd an appropriate paragraph. 

Walking into Fairfield is like getting a hug from your favourite person. As you meander through the traffic of Zimmer frames and overtake superiorly paced wheelchairs, the beautiful consequences of not having to worry about your heating bill hits you. Luxury for students and decreased circulation souls alike. Picasso-like artwork made by the residences, family pictures of staff and seasonal decorations line the walls to create a homely feel – it is magic! Conveniently for those of us who succumb to the bliss of a nap, Fairfield is one big bed! A sleep-enabling environment, you will never be judged for nodding off at the dinner table. 

I can confidently say that Fairfield is the ultimate place to held hostage if kidnapped. Complete with hairdresser, doctors’ visits, and home cooked meals three times a day, you would hope search efforts for your finding would be suspended. Reminiscent of an immaculately planned day at primary school, the optional activity list for the day is multifaceted. From carol singing to jazz days, there is always something to do, and the best part is, someone else has organised all!

I can confidently say that Fairfield is the ultimate place to held hostage if kidnapped

Now this may seem paradoxical for a habitat for those whose wisdom surpasses their sprinting ability. However, without a doubt the greatest place in this residential care home is the smoking area. To understand the level of quality, in Durham terms this is equivalent to Jimmy’s outdoor space. An escape for both staff and residences, my Grannie and I have spent hours there – connecting in both talk and silence. From an outsider’s perspective they encourage their residents to have fun, and instill a sense of humanity into them that I think can be stripped away as one ages and is often communicated to as though they are literally a school child. 

The staff team are wholly responsible for this atmosphere and are adored by my Grannie. So much so, even as her only grandchild, I fear my reign as favourite may be ending.   I cannot thank them enough for making my Grannie feel at home. Grannie Annie can sleep in until midday, have food brought to her in bed, and have friends up in her room; she is comparable to a teenager, and brilliantly the staff are the always the patient, interested loving parent, who will be there no matter what.

With endlessly biscuits and tea (and sometimes prosecco) on tap, I have to apologise to Mr Disney. Even as a fellow dyslexic, I’m going to have to reject the claim that forced fun and spoiled children could even be placed in the same category of greatness as the Nirvana for geriatrics (and apparently their younger kin!) that is Fairfield.

By Amelie Lambie-Proctor

What makes a good debate?

To the Editors,

I was planning on comparing all of the debating societies in Durham, but at £40 I thought the Durham Union was too much effort. Indeed, at £5 for membership (plus the cost of the pint) I thought Lager and Debate Society (LADS) was also too much. The Durham Union was banned from the SU Freshers’ Fair this year by the Students’ Union for failing to take action against racism, yet despite the Union’s claims that freedom of speech is being suppressed, Durham still has a thriving culture of debate. 

Much more accessible are the many free societies offering discussions to stimulate the interested mind. The more accessible (free) Discussion and Debate Society (DADS) offers round table discussions you can just rock up to – followed by the pub. Philosophy Society offers talks – also followed by the pub. There are the political party societies where you can get your ear chewed off by ideologues – which also tend to start and finish in the pub. For dedicated topic discussions there’s everything from Arctic Society to Israel-Palestine Resolution Society. And if all else fails, you can go to the pub with your mates and just have your own discussion, as most people do. 

What makes a good debate? The Union opts for classic British parliamentary style, but this does not allow most people to take part, and as an audience member you’re often left frustrated when the Proposition/Opposition fail to make or rebut an obvious point. 

Open-ended questions, which societies like DADS favour, are more conducive to constructive discussion, don’t pit people against each other as much, and still allow for disagreement

Other societies opt for a more casual, no-preparation-needed strategy. DADS spend an hour every Wednesday in a round-circle chatting about a pre-decided question and everyone can contribute as little or as much as they wish. LADS pick two questions, one serious and one fun, and go for a more relaxed ‘chat to the people around you’ style. Both DADS and LADS complained that during the SU fair they had to repeatedly emphasise that they were not the Durham Union to the many freshers who felt combative debate would not welcome them. 

By now the biggest issue for the aptly named debating societies should be obvious – they are overwhelmingly male. I asked Sam – a discussion moderator at DADS – about the challenge in preventing loud (overwhelmingly male) voices from drowning out the quieter spoken and often more insightful voices. He said that “a healthy discussion requires a diversity of beliefs and perspectives. But these can often be drowned out and quieter voices discouraged from speaking when a minority of loud, obnoxious, or especially polemical speakers dominate the room. This does sometimes mean stopping people short, or giving polite guidance to people afterwards. Although not always, people do improve.” 

Undoubtedly these societies help build confidence, but they need to work hard to not screen out those who lack confidence. Provocative debate titles from the Durham Union like “This house believes Palestine leadership is the greatest barrier to peace” are sure to put some people off, especially when open alternatives like “What is the greatest barrier to peace in the Middle-East?” are possible. Open-ended questions, which societies like DADS favour, are more conducive to constructive discussion, don’t pit people against each other as much, and still allow for disagreement. 

While some societies (Labour, LibDems, Conservatives) offer obviously partisan discussion, others aim for unbiased discussions. I’ll take this opportunity to suggest a debate topic: “Is there such thing as unbiased discussion?” At the end of each year DADS do a “Why DADS?” discussion, where they look at why they don’t have the same friction or accusations of right-wing leaning as the Durham Union. I asked him why it doesn’t descend into a political action group, or an echo chamber over the course of the year. According to Sam, it is because “people come here to change their minds, not win”.

By Aiken Furlong

On Pierre Laval and the death penalty

To the Editors,

Considering all the debate that is raging in this country with regard to the wisdom of trying to legalise what has rather euphemistically been called ‘assisted dying’, it might be of some interest to your readers to learn of what I can only describe as a grotesquely amusing instance, from a possibly bygone age, of a particular state ordering that a particular individual might only be allowed to die if they were ‘assisted’ in breathing their last.

In 1945, after the end of the Second World War, a Frenchman called Pierre Laval — who had served as prime minister as well as foreign minister in the 1930s, but then gone on to become one of the foremost ‘collaborators’ with Nazi Germany under the so-called Vichy regime (which, established by Marshal Philippe Pétain after the conclusion of an armistice with Berlin in 1940 and the direct occupation of northern France by German forces, nominally administered the ‘unoccupied’ part of southern France and the French colonies until 1944) — was executed as a traitor by the Fourth Republic. 

This might not sound like a very dramatic end for someone deemed by his compatriots to have left no stone unturned in betraying them — but it might be wondered whether the same could also be said of the manner in which he met that end, a surprisingly calm account of which was given in The Times the very next day (16 October 1945, on page 4). Intriguingly entitled ‘Execution of Laval — attempt at suicide foiled’, the report from Paris disclosed to an English audience that “Pierre Laval, arch-traitor and former Prime Minister of France, was shot at midday today. His end was melodramatic. Laval sought to cheat the course of justice in prison by taking poison. The attempt failed, and he met his fate before a firing squad. He died with calm and courage.

“At 8.30 this morning M. Mornet, prosecutor at the trial, entered Laval’s cell formally to communicate the decision that the petition for mercy had been rejected. Before he could be stopped Laval swallowed a small phial of cyanide of potassium and collapsed. Doctors were summoned, and for two hours worked to save his life (my emphasis). After he had been restored a bulletin was signed by three doctors stating that Laval was fit to make the usual declaration provided for under Article 377 of the criminal code, and that there were no medical reasons why he should not be executed.” Less than two hours later, after the doctors had worked for two hours to ‘save his life’,

Pierre Laval met his end before the firing squad. The moral of the story, I fear, is that unassisted dying is too good for some people. Their lives must end as publicly as they were lived. Anyone who declines to endure their hours on earth in a ‘just’ manner — even when the company they keep delights to believe in capital punishment — ought not to expect not to have an exception made of their final. Justice, after all, must always be seen to be done — n’est-ce pas?

By Bilal Haider Junejo 

Image: Suzy Hazelwood via Pexels