Gallant fired: What’s next?

By Ben Mendez

In a significant political shakeup, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has recently fired the Israeli Defence Minister, Yoav Gallant, citing an ‘erosion of trust’ between the two. This decision has caused mass protests in the region with citizens angry at Mr Netanyahu’s increasingly dogmatic stance on the ongoing war with Hamas. With Mr Gallant gone, questions have been raised about the future of the Israeli military strategy and Netanyahu’s approach to both domestic and international challenges.

Born in Israel to a family with roots to the early Zionist movement, Mr Gallant joined the Isreal Defence Force (IDF) in 1977 becoming commander of the Southern Command in 2005. During his tenure he had a leading role in both the 2006 Lebanon conflict and the First Gaza War, securing the release Galid Shalit- an Israeli soldier held captive by Hamas. 

After retiring from the military, Mr Gallant transitioned into Israeli politics, joining the Likud party in 2015.  Mr Gallant has held numerous high-profile roles within the government, including Minister of Construction and Minister of Education before being appointed Minister of Defence in 2022.

As Defence minister Mr Gallant has faced both domestic support and international criticism. During the ongoing conflict in Gaza, Mr Gallant has been increasingly scrutinised.  His withdrawal of electricity, food, water and fuel has been criticised by multiple human rights organisations and the UN. In a similar vein, his warning that Lebanon could be ‘returned to the stone age’ has stirred up civilian fears in the region. 

As Defence minister Mr Gallant has faced both domestic support and international criticism. During the ongoing conflict in Gaza, Mr Gallant has been increasingly scrutinised

Despite international backlash, many Israeli citizens have been supportive of Gallant as a more moderate member of Mr Netanyahu’s fragile coalition, being the only member to oppose Mr Netanyahu’s judicial reforms in 2022. Mr Gallant has expressed himself to favour a swift end to the war rather than the protracted state it currently finds itself in. Consequentially, Mr Netanyahu’s decision to fire Mr Gallant has sparked outrage among many of the less radical Israeli’s, who took to the streets in mass protest.

To many Mr Gallants firing did not come as a shock. Mr Netanyahu had been at odds with Gallant since his criticism of the judicial reforms in 2022 and the two had frequently disagreed on war strategy.

The silver bullet appeared to be an internal conflict arising as a result of the latest government budget. Mr Gallant had called for a wider expansion of military conscription and conscripted 7000 religious, a response to a bill which would make ultra-Orthodox Haredim Jews exempt from serving. The Rabbis responded by threatening to collapse the coalition by withdrawing support from the budget. Unlike the UK, when a budget fails to pass in the Knesset, the government collapses. Mr Netanyahu, desperate to keep his mandate, had to act swiftly and fire Mr Gallant.

As a replacement, Mr Netanyahu has chosen former Foreign Minister, Isreal Katz. Known as a hardline supporter of Mr Netanyahu, Mr Katz’s appointment is seen by many as a consolidation of political power, and positions Mr Netanyahu as the de-facto Defence Minister. By sacking Mr Gallant, Mr Netanyahu has secured a major political gain

Mr Gallant’s removal is not only politically very significant, but it also has serious implications on the extremity of the military. As soon as Gallant was fired, rumours appeared that Netanyahu was also about to sack the IDF’s commander in chief, Herzl Halevi, weakening the potential opposition to further and more extreme military action.  It is clear that Mr Gallants removal signals a shift towards a more aggressive and militaristic government in Israel. 

Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons/ US Secretary of Defense