Letters to the Editor

On rail fines

To the Editors,

Why does it feel like I need to obtain a masters degree in public transport just to understand the absurdity of the UK’s railway network? From persistent delays to rocketing ticket costs, it seems Britain’s railways keep thinking of new ways to make my inner train enthusiast wince. 

This month, a 22-year old engineering graduate was threatened with a court order from Northern Rail for using an invalid ticket. His crime? Using his railcard to purchase a £3.65 “anytime single” ticket to Manchester, except that “anytime” ticket wasn’t actually an “anytime” ticket, because railcards are not valid for discounts on peak fares under £12, before 10am, outside July and August. An absurd debacle, given the passenger had only paid £1.85 less than he should have. 

Northern responded by saying that everyone has “a duty” to buy the correct ticket and 96% of customers “do just that”. I understand how fare evasion is a nuisance for the rail operators, but I doubt the engineering graduate was trying to scam Northern out of a fare through malice. Besides, this response ignores a wider problem with Britain’s railways that could be so easily fixed – this country’s fare system is ridiculously complex. 

The nationalisation of the railways could not come soon enough

At a time when we should encourage people to travel on trains instead of cars, the current fare system is greatly off-putting for passengers to navigate, not helped by the poor value these tickets often represent. Current attempts to reform fares have not entirely been successful either – LNER’s simple fares trial was criticised after it removed “super off-peak” fare options, making certain journeys over £100 more expensive than they were previously. Not great for readers heading to London anytime soon. 

The nationalisation of the railways could not come soon enough with Labour’s plans to establish Great British Rail, but why not use this opportunity to reform the fare system and untangle this ludicrous web of terms and conditions? In the Netherlands where I recently lived, rail fares are blissfully simple and trains form an integral part of people’s lives. The Dutch use fixed prices for single and return journeys between cities regardless of the time of day, with subscriptions offering discounts for regular travellers. 

If even one British rail operator implemented a similar fare system (and fix the railcard rules in the process), it would go a long way in encouraging passengers to ride the train again. 

By Waseem Mohamed 


A sink is a sink is a sink. Not a bin.

To the Editors,

A toddler’s playground of choice, the kitchen is equivalent to a mad scientist’s lair. A paradise of mastermind pioneering, each invention possesses traits comparable to those of a skilled illusionist. The deceptive nature of each genuinely purposeful appliance from the essential kettle to the humble potato masher represents their genius innovator’s mind, that turned raw material and laws of chemistry into an everyday essential. Even the simple whisk can be dated back to ancient civilisation, with the Egyptians weaving branches and twigs together to mix food. 

Having said this, I am sure that the fabulous Thomas Ahearn, inventor of the electric stove in 1882, did not assume that his stellar creation would share space with the, quite frankly, most useless bit of plastic – the sink bucket. I am referring to a sink-shaped bucket that sits within a sink and performs all the same jobs as said host sink. I find myself questioning whether its intended purpose is of any use whatsoever. 

What are universal kitchen users doing with their sinks other than the washing up?

This annoyance of a device is commonly indented to save water, as not all the water in your sink drains. However, is this not a function that the sink and plug can perform? The bucket is an insult to the plug which has practically been unchanged since its invention in the Middles Ages. It took James Dyson 5,127 prototypes to get the Dyson right, it took one attempt to get the plug right, and some households feel they have the status to question its purpose. 

Another baffling explanation is its ability to remove washing up clogging the sink to be placed elsewhere when requiring the basin for other tasks. The countertop is an invaluable space, why clog it with an unnecessary item! What are universal kitchen users doing with their sinks other than the washing up? 

Another apparent painful purpose of this British innovation is to collect detritus from plates so washing up water can remain clear. I now assume I’m using my bin wrong, and to add to this the coveted food bin becomes redundant. In a final bid to repair its reputation, the sink bucket claims to be a noise-cancelling machine, stopping the bashing of crockery on mental. I challenge anyone to make no noise using this contraption. The drowned silverware in fact screeches symphonies, pouring water out after isn’t exactly silent, and the screams following spilling soapy water all over the kitchen floor are not to be described as quiet. As far as saving graces go, there are none. I could not find the original inventor of the sink bucket, and I hope they have succumbed to the embarrassment they should feel at creating such a useless apparatus and gone into hiding. 

By Amelie Lambie-Proctor


What makes a good debate?

To the Editors,

I was planning on comparing all of the debating societies in Durham, but at £40 I thought the Durham Union was too much effort. Indeed, at £5 for membership (plus the cost of the pint) I thought Lager and Debate Society (LADS) was also too much. The Durham Union was banned from the SU Freshers’ Fair this year by the Students’ Union for failing to take action against racism, yet despite the Union’s claims that freedom of speech is being suppressed, Durham still has a thriving culture of debate. 

Much more accessible are the many free societies offering discussions to stimulate the interested mind. The more accessible (free) Discussion and Debate Society (DADS) offers round table discussions you can just rock up to – followed by the pub. Philosophy Society offers talks – also followed by the pub. There are the political party societies where you can get your ear chewed off by ideologues – which also tend to start and finish in the pub. For dedicated topic discussions there’s everything from Arctic Society to Israel-Palestine Resolution Society. And if all else fails, you can go to the pub with your mates and just have your own discussion, as most people do. 

What makes a good debate? The Union opts for classic British parliamentary style, but this does not allow most people to take part, and as an audience member you’re often left frustrated when the Proposition/Opposition fail to make or rebut an obvious point. 

Other societies opt for a more casual, no-preparation-needed strategy. DADS spend an hour every Wednesday in a round-circle chatting about a pre-decided question and everyone can contribute as little or as much as they wish. LADS pick two questions, one serious and one fun, and go for a more relaxed ‘chat to the people around you’ style. Both DADS and LADS complained that during the SU fair they had to repeatedly emphasise that they were not the Durham Union to the many freshers who felt combative debate would not welcome them. 

Durham still has a thriving culture of debate

By now the biggest issue for the aptly named debating societies should be obvious – they are overwhelmingly male. I asked Sam – a discussion moderator at DADS – about the challenge in preventing loud (overwhelmingly male) voices from drowning out the quieter spoken and often more insightful voices. He said that “a healthy discussion requires a diversity of beliefs and perspectives. But these can often be drowned out and quieter voices discouraged from speaking when a minority of loud, obnoxious, or especially polemical speakers dominate the room. This does sometimes mean stopping people short, or giving polite guidance to people afterwards. Although not always, people do improve.” 

Undoubtedly these societies help build confidence, but they need to work hard to not screen out those who lack confidence. Provocative debate titles from the Durham Union like “This house believes Palestine leadership is the greatest barrier to peace” are sure to put some people off, especially when open alternatives like “What is the greatest barrier to peace in the Middle-East?” are possible. Open-ended questions, which societies like DADS favour, are more conducive to constructive discussion, don’t pit people against each other as much, and still allow for disagreement. 

While some societies (Labour, LibDems, Conservatives) offer obviously partisan discussion, others aim for unbiased discussions. I’ll take this opportunity to suggest a debate topic: “Is there such thing as unbiased discussion?” At the end of each year DADS do a “Why DADS?” discussion, where they look at why they don’t have the same friction or accusations of right-wing leaning as the Durham Union. I asked him why it doesn’t descend into a political action group, or an echo chamber over the course of the year. According to Sam, it is because “people come here to change their minds, not win”

By Aiken Furlong


Regarding ‘the scarcity of tea’

To the Editors,

Some amusing, and possibly perennial, light was shed of yore on the English appetite for drinking tea by the contents of a very short report which appeared on page 3 of the 1st October 1917 issue of The Times. Entitled ‘The scarcity of tea’, the report stated that

“In view of the scarcity of tea, Lord Rhondda has been approached on the subject of Church tea meetings by the Rev. J. H. Shakespeare, of Highgate, who made a specific inquiry as to whether a tea meeting would be allowed at half-past 6 or 7 in the evening. A reply has been received from the chief officer of the Tea Section of the Ministry of Food in the following terms:— “While the holding of the tea meetings to which you refer involve no breach of any regulation issued by this Ministry, in view of the limited supplies of tea at present available it is incumbent on everyone to be as economical as possible in the use of tea. So far as possible, and where practical, coffee or cocoa, or both, should be substituted for tea.”

The Ministry of Food had a whole tea section

Note that this happened three years into the war — the point being that even six (or rather eight) and thirty months of unremitting warfare had proved insufficient to diminish the importance of tea in the daily lives of (almost) all English people. Note also that the Ministry of Food had a whole Tea Section; and if this Section had a chief officer, it means that there must have been other officers as well (for one can only be chief officer in a relative sense), leading to the inescapable conclusion that the Section in question must have been one of some significance. The report which we are considering would have scarcely appeared in The Times (at a time when the newspaper was everyone’s principal source of information, and the constraints of war would have already made paper scarce), had the editor not considered the subject matter thereof to be of national importance.

It could only have been advised that poor old coffee and cocoa be substituted for tea because they were more plentifully available than, increasingly, was tea. They could only have been plentifully available because they were consumed less than was the sacred beverage called tea.

Truly, when it comes to us humans, age cannot wither, nor custom stale, our infinite variety!

By Bilal Haider Junejo 

Image: Suzy Hazelwood via Pexels