Shelagh Fogarty: my life and career
By Lucy Atkinson
Content warning: this article contains mentions of sexual assault and rape which some readers may find upsetting.
I’m sitting down (over the phone) with Shelagh Fogarty: broadcaster, journalist, writer, and proud Durham alumna. Known for her incisive commentary on current events and her fearless approach to tackling difficult subjects, Shelagh has become a prominent voice in British media. Today, we discuss her journey through journalism, her podcast The Followers exploring the chilling realities of stalking, and her thoughts on the growing issue of misogyny, particularly within modern British society and university environments.
She begins by asking about my degree, sharing an anecdote about her having to conduct an interview during her time at the World Service with a man who could only speak Italian – a language that she did not study!
“We decided that I would ask him questions in English and he would answer in Italian,” she explains – “Half-way through the interview I just had this out of body experience!”
I ask Shelagh if she has any fond memories or favourite locations from her time in Durham, and she shares vivid memories of her time at the University, fondly recalling the beautiful walk from the back of the Cathedral, revealing a breathtaking view of the river and trees. She also reflects on her time at Trevelyan College, where she formed lifelong friendships, despite the building not being particularly remarkable at the time.
“Poor Trevs, but I was always enamoured by the colleges on the Bailey.” she says.
During our conversation, the topic turns to the study of languages again, particularly with regards to juggling multiple languages at university. She reflects on her own experience, saying, “The more you know the language, the more you know the language.” She emphasises how immersion and repetition lead to intuitive understanding, recalling a conversation with her fellow LBC host, James O’Brien and likening it to how “a baby learns language.” She explains, “Your brain physically shifts when you are constantly speaking a foreign language,” and describes how understanding of concepts, such as natural phenomena like rain, changes when conceptualised in another language. A listener on O’Brien’s show, who studied linguistics, sparked this reflection, leading Fogarty to share, “It shifts your imagery and understanding of words,” revealing how speaking different languages can shape thought processes in surprising ways.
“Your brain physically shifts when you are constantly speaking a foreign language,”
Shelagh Fogarty
Fogarty recalls her time as an au pair in Spain, where making mistakes became part of the learning process: “The kids would poke fun at me if I got something wrong,” she laughs, noting that this informal feedback was invaluable in developing fluency. She shares a humorous experience from her time after her year abroad. After spending time in Barcelona, she found herself in Liverpool, unable to recall the English word for ‘umbrella’.
“I just couldn’t remember the word,” she laughs, recounting how she fumbled and explained to the waitress by saying, “for the water,” in an attempt to describe it. The exchange resulted in the waitress eventually helping her out, saying “umbrella,” but not without confusion.
Shelagh Fogarty’s path to journalism was shaped by a childhood immersed in current events. “We were a very newsy household,” she recalls, with her father and older brother frequently discussing politics and world events like Margaret Thatcher and the IRA, sparking her early interest. Though she didn’t study journalism at Durham University, her passion for storytelling surfaced when, at seven years old, she penned a story about seeing dolphins at her local swimming baths. The story, though creatively embellished—claiming she was rescued by a dolphin named Flipper—earned her a certificate from the Liverpool Echo and a prize of one pound.
Despite the family’s political discussions, it wasn’t until years later that Fogarty would formally enter the world of journalism, but the foundation was there from a young age. “I always knew I was interested in events, in news,” she reflects, and that early exposure, alongside her first published story, became a key part of her journey. Though the details of the dolphin story may have been fanciful, it gave her a taste for writing and storytelling, propelling her towards the successful career she now enjoys.
“I always knew I was interested in events, in news,”
Shelagh fogarty
Shelagh Fogarty’s journey into journalism is marked by unexpected twists and turns, starting from her school days when she didn’t engage in any formal journalism units. “In school, we probably did journalistic projects and things, but I never did any journalism unit,” she reflects. After leaving university, she found herself uncertain about her future, pondering, “Why isn’t the road clear?” It wasn’t long before she decided, somewhat whimsically, to pursue a career in theatre management, applying for jobs in large theatres across the North West of England.
“I look back and wonder, where did that fancy idea come from?” she muses, acknowledging that her love for language and public speaking was always present. Growing up as the youngest in a large family, she was known for her gift of gab, a talent she later recognized as an obvious precursor to her eventual career in journalism.
A turning point comes when her oldest brother, a journalist himself, sends her an advert for a training scheme from a magazine called The Listener. “It was a kind of Radio Times with articles and reviews,” she describes. After applying and attending two interviews, she secured a spot in the BBC’s news training scheme. “It was a great start because you get training, and we were being paid straight away,” she notes, highlighting the structured beginning to her journalism career.
During her transition from university to her new role, Fogarty temped at BBC Radio Merseyside, where she unexpectedly found herself at the heart of a major news story: the Hillsborough disaster. “I started in October ’89, and Hillsborough happened in April ’89,” she explains. Although she had no formal journalistic training at that point, she was already part of the Radio Merseyside team, initially working in support roles.
The day of the disaster, Fogarty recalls, she was in town when she heard people discussing the tragic events unfolding. “I thought I could hear what was happening, so I went into Radio Merseyside just to find out,” she recounts. What began as a curious visit turned into an all-hands-on-deck situation, with the newsroom bustling with activity. “I didn’t get home until the middle of Monday morning,” she shares.
With her language skills, she was quickly pulled into supportive roles, helping the team manage the influx of information and calls from around the world. “The world was calling Radio Merseyside—literally every country in the world,” she says, underlining the global significance of the story.
Reflecting on this experience, Fogarty underscores the importance of nurturing one’s unique interests and skills. “If you have a specialist topic that you love or are interested in, foster it,” she advises. “It will become something. I guarantee it will become something.” This blend of personal passion and professional development has guided her throughout her journalism career, solidifying her belief that any skill can be valuable in unexpected ways.
Fogarty reflects on her experience covering the aftermath of the Hillsborough disaster, noting, “It taught me a lot.” She acknowledges that being a witness to such a tragedy at a young age shaped her approach to journalism, emphasising the importance of the relationship between a journalist and the people they interview. “They owe you nothing, and you owe them everything,” she asserts, advocating for patience and respect in interactions. Her philosophy underscores the need for empathy in journalism, highlighting that stories involve real lives and emotions.
Moreover, she recounts moments where she had to navigate scepticism from the public, particularly during sensitive events. “I’ve been on picket lines where people really don’t want to talk to journalists because they don’t trust them,” she notes, illustrating the challenge journalists face in building rapport. She believes it’s essential to respect their hesitance and to “convince them otherwise,” demonstrating her commitment to ethical journalism.
Fogarty’s insights extend to her interactions with callers on her radio show. “People often say to me, you’re so patient with the people who call,” she shares, to which she replies, “Why would I be anything but patient?” Her perspective reinforces the idea that creating a space for dialogue is key, especially since callers contribute to her program.
“You’re witnessing people’s lives,”
Shelagh Fogarty
Ultimately, she recognizes that every interview represents a moment in someone’s life, emphasising the responsibility journalists hold. “You’re witnessing people’s lives,” she states. In her journey, she learned the significance of waiting for the right moment and respecting the emotional weight of conversations, making her approach not just about gathering information but also about understanding and sharing stories with care.
Prompted by a mention of Laura Bates’ book, Men Who Hate Women, Shelagh begins by mentioning that the book illuminated the alarming role of the Internet in fostering hatred towards women, making what was once subtle and personal now pervasive and loud. When asked how to confront these harmful ideologies while respecting free speech, Shelagh argues that the Internet magnifies derogatory sentiments, creating an environment where they can spread rapidly.
Drawing on a recent example from Warwick University, Shelagh praises the student paper’s investigative work that exposed a troubling culture of misogyny on campus. It serves as a testament to how journalism can shine a light on hidden issues.
As we discuss the implications of this shift, she recognises the challenge of addressing these pervasive ideas in a digital age. We come to a shared understanding that the use of online spaces poses significant threats, not just to individual lives but to society as a whole, and the urgency to tackle these issues became clear. “I think the only big difference is the proliferation,” she states, “when I first started to cover Andrew Tate on air, Instagram would show me more Andrew Tate videos because of the algorithm- urgent action has to be on the internet companies.”
Shelagh acknowledges the ongoing efforts by governments to regulate online platforms through initiatives like the online safety bill, but highlights that real change requires active participation from individuals. Open discussions about sexuality and consent should be likened to conversations about food and drink—acknowledging that all appetites can be misused, and stressing the importance of clear, honest conversations to equip both boys and girls with the knowledge to navigate these issues safely.
Shelagh suggests protecting young women by creating “buffer zones” against harmful behaviour, insisting that the responsibility lies not with girls but with society to foster understanding and respect, so that society can better prepare individuals to handle dangerous situations when they arise.
She brings attention to a shocking case involving a Glasgow University student named Ellie Wilson, who went public about a disturbing situation on campus. Ellie uncovered that several young men facing trial for serious allegations, including rape, are allowed to continue their studies without any notification to their fellow students, including young women who might share classrooms or living spaces with them.
“I’d like to know that, wouldn’t you?” Shelagh stresses.
She emphasizes, “I should have that choice to decide whether to fraternize with somebody who’s facing trial for rape.” This situation is indicative of a broader systemic issue where the safety of women is compromised, making it critical to address these matters openly.
“There’s all kinds of elements where the cards are very much stacked against girls and women, I think still.” She states, mentioning how the environment today is even more challenging than in previous generations, stating, “It’s probably more tough now in your day than in mine.”
“I should have that choice to decide whether to fraternize with somebody
Shelagh fogarty
who’s facing trial for rape.”
I decide to ask about Shelagh’s opinion on Home Secretary Yvette Cooper’s statements about misogyny being treated as a form of radicalisation: “If we’re using the same language that we do for teenagers who are being radicalised into terror, then yes, investigate it using the same powers.” she states. However, she acknowledges that experts in violence against women have reservations about this approach, and misogyny often manifests in relationships rather than in public settings.
She recalls a poignant call from a mother, Susan Galway, who shared her concerns about her son’s transformation after exposure to harmful ideologies. The boy, once a sweet child, now used derogatory language learned from peers, raising alarms about the pervasive influence of misogyny. “My child transformed before my eyes,” the mother expressed, highlighting the alarming shift in her son’s behaviour and paralleling the radicalisation often
seen in youth drawn into extremist beliefs.
“Misogyny is either unconscious or tolerated by huge swaths of society,” she notes, contrasting it with the zero-tolerance approach often applied to political terrorism. Regarding education’s role in this, she believes we should foster joy and clarity in young people’s lives. “Joy is the answer to everything,” she insists, arguing that when teenagers feel confident and happy, they are less likely to engage in harmful behaviours. Reflecting on her own experiences, she recalls how the narrative surrounding sex often focuses on fear and danger. She emphasises the importance of teaching young people what “the gifts of [sex] are rather than the horror show that it might be.”
Ultimately, Fogarty’s message underscores the necessity for a generational shift in education that empowers young people to understand their own desires and establish joyful, healthy connections- steering them away from the toxic narratives that contribute to this new, modern form of misogyny.
Image credit: YellowPoppyMedia

