Can pro-natalist policies be feminist? Intention is everything
By Emily Gray
The Hungarian President, Katalin Novak, a promoter of pro-natalist policies who has sought to curb abortion access, recently made a controversial appearance at a women’s rights conference in Rwanda. Not only did she attend the conference, Novak was one of the opening speakers, creating confusion amongst attendees. Delegates attending the Women Deliver conference have since tweeted their shock at the presence of the renowned pro-life politician at the event.
The CEO of ‘Women Deliver’ has responded by highlighting the importance of partnering with those who ‘we don’t agree with on so many things’. Indeed, despite the outrage her presence has prompted, she was met with applause when she told the audience “I am the first woman president of my country.” and stated that increasing the fertility rate is Hungary’s goal for gender equality. However, the so-called ‘pro-family’ values which Novak claims promote gender equality have been criticised as directly at odds with what feminists stand for.
Last year, the Hungarian government implemented several policies that seemed feminist on the surface, such as housing subsidies for single mothers, and proposing that women with more than four children be exempt from income tax for life. However, below the surface these policies symbolise something far more sinister. The birth rate in Hungary is among the lowest in Europe, and these policies that seemingly ‘support’ mothers, as well as the relatively recent restriction of abortion access, have been described as encouraging women to be ‘baby-making machines’.
One would question whether there is a way for pro-natalist policies to be feminist in sentiment
With this in mind, one would question whether there is a way for pro-natalist policies to still be feminist in sentiment. As discussed, some governments are issuing policies that grant mothers, especially single mothers, more economic independence as well as greater opportunities to reintegrate into the workplace after childbirth, with some politicians proposing feminism as ‘the new natalism’.
When asking whether pro-natalist policies can be feminist, the challenge lies in ensuring these policies do not inadvertently perpetuate traditional gender roles or negatively impact women’s autonomy and choices. These policies that we have discussed in Hungary seem to be crossing the line into encouraging pro-natalism for the country’s future wellbeing, rather than promoting pro-natalism for women’s own benefit.
The Hungarian government has admitted that it has implemented these policies to increase its own birth-rate, as it is avoiding immigration as a means of boosting population growth. For pro-natalist policies to be feminist, one must also consider life outside of these policies that incentivises reproduction, ensuring that there are comprehensive reproductive rights including access to reproductive healthcare, family planning services, and contraceptives. Women must have the freedom to make informed choices about their reproductive health. For this to be possible, there must be a sufficient number of politicians who back these policies, not only to campaign for feminist ideals, but to avoid women being suddenly stripped of their rights to contraception and abortion.
Women must have the freedom to make informed choices about their reproductive health
Alongside this, there should be inclusive pro-natalist policymaking by involving women in the development and implementation of pro-natalist policies to ensure their perspectives and needs are considered. Although the policies, or incentives, Hungary has introduced support women financially and with their careers, it is imperative that they are implemented with the right intentions, so that women feel they have the same opportunities as men postpartum, and can make their own informed decisions, knowing that the choice to have children will not detrimentally impact them later in life.
It is also important to educate people, not only women, on gender stereotypes that may discourage women from pursuing careers or education due to societal expectations around motherhood.
By incorporating feminist principles, pro-natalist policies can strike a balance between promoting population growth and respecting women’s rights and autonomy. The aim should be to create an environment where women can make informed choices about their reproductive decisions while enjoying equal opportunities and support for both career and family life.
Image: Paul Kamade via Flickr
