Can widespread veganism control carbon footprint and climate change?
By Amelie MacPherson
The huge carbon footprint of meat has been known and acknowledged for years, taught in secondary school syllabi, and thrown around as a fact by those who know little else about climate change. The idea of an ecological footprint was initially used in an academic paper in 1992: the first in a string of increasingly damning reports discussing the high greenhouse gas emissions caused by the farming and production of meat. The most recent of these is a comprehensive study by Oxford University that concludes that switching to a vegetarian diet emits under half the carbon dioxide per-person in a day in comparison to a meat-based diet. To help conceptualise this, the study compared the environmental benefit of simply reducing the amount of meat eaten every day by the UK’s biggest carnivores to removing 8 million cars from the roads. When faced with these numbers, the seemingly obvious course of action would be that we should all switch to plant-based diets or something near, perhaps by government regulations and incentives. However, there are a multitude of reasons why this is a transition that cannot, and will not happen, headed by the fact that people simply do not want to.
Like with the majority of solutions to climate change, it is a game of balancing short-term pain with long-term gain
Attempting to enact wide scale change for the benefit of the environment will always involve a series of trade-offs, and in the case of reducing meat-intake, the trade-off is arguably implausible. Firstly, vegetarian and vegan ‘meat’ substitutes are wildly more expensive than meat, as are the vegetables and grains that are staples in a plant-based diet. This change in lifestyle is not affordable for many, and the introduction of government regulations on meat could result in malnourishment. Additionally, a plant-based diet is medically inadvisable for some, as the protein, iron, and vitamins in meat and poultry being essential for growth and bodily health. This results in the ability to eat a plant-based diet being a privilege afforded to the rich and healthy. Like with the majority of solutions to climate change, it is a game of balancing short-term pain with long-term gain, and the scales will always tip in the favour of feeding the starving population of now.
Even if the inequity of enforcing a reduction in meat consumption is set aside, there are plenty of political and economic factors that need to be considered. The greenhouse gas emissions of meats are not equal, with beef coming out on top at 60kg of CO2 emissions per kg, poultry at 6kg CO2e per kg, and farmed fish at 5kg CO2e per kg. Were the UK government to provide meat regulation, they would need to decide which meat to regulate, whether to simply encourage more environmentally friendly forms of production, and how to distinguish between meat and dairy restrictions on the same animal breed. Regulating meat production would set a precedent where the carbon emissions of all other food would need to be scrutinised, from large-scale rice farming operations to locally sourced vegetables.
If there was ever a time for the government to take action against climate change, it is definitely now
Whilst every avenue needs to be explored in the effort to mitigate the impact of climate change, food production and transportation will always emit greenhouse gases, and we need food to live. Following on from this, the question of how much the government should interfere needs to be addressed. Is it the responsibility of the government to regulate the actions of their citizens, or should they leave it up to the individual and the market to dictate meat consumption?
If there was ever a time for the government to take action against climate change, it is definitely now. However, government resources and attention is better spent on policy regulation at the top of the emissions chain, working towards implementing solutions such as the circular economy, renewable energy, and green transportation. There is no easy solution to the wicked problem that is climate change, but health development and global food equity must remain a priority in the structuring of a green framework for the future, or the post-climate change Earth will be only for the rich to inherit.
Image credit: Takver via Wikimedia Commons
