The Willow Project: did the Biden administration make the right choice?

By Amelie MacPherson

I’ve known the human race was greedy for a long time. This fact was made abundantly clear to me in Year 5 when I realised my classmate had stolen my favourite pink glitter gel pen that I had left unguarded on my desk at lunchtime. When I asked for it back, all she responded with was ‘finders keepers’. Mind you, at age ten that seemed like the soundest logic in the world, and I had to relinquish my prized possession on the grounds of a phrase. Nowadays, I can see the same logic of ‘finders keepers’ being applied to our environment, with the Willow Project being a topical example.

The Willow Project is a proposal that was recently accepted by the US Government, involving the extraction of petroleum from the North Slope Borough in Alaska’s Western Arctic, an area that has the potential to produce around 600 million barrels of oil over a 30-year period. This would amount to around 9.2 million metric tonnes of carbon pollution a year, which comes to a total of 278 million metric tonnes in total according to the estimates of climate groups. I do not even need to spell out how devastating this will be for the local wildlife and people, as well as the planet at large.

The answer is that there is no easy way to choose between short-term benefits and long-term benefits when you are governing the lives of so many people

This proposal faced considerable public backlash from activists and corporations alike, with Greenpeace putting out a statement describing the air and water pollution this project would cause, as well as the environmental and food security threats to the indigenous communities of the area. Petitions against the Willow Project received signatures from over three million people, and a TikTok hashtag called #willowproject received 293 million views since the proposal was thrown into the social media spotlight, showcasing public upset. The Willow Project was initially accepted by the Trump administration (which is a fact that speaks for itself about the impact of this proposal on the environment) before being paused due to outside environmental concerns. Despite Biden’s commitment to addressing the climate emergency in his Presidential proposals, his administration has chosen to accept the Willow Project. The question is, was it worth it?

The answer is that there is no easy way to choose between short-term benefits and long-term benefits when you are governing the lives of so many people. The proposal is predicted to bring in $17 billion in revenue for national and local governments in the US, as well as economic benefit for Alaskan communities. Having access to more oil is imperative, with petrol prices at a high as a result of the war in Ukraine. The Biden administration is facing the very harsh reality of the fact that without oil people will starve and freeze in their homes, and it would be morally unacceptable to not do anything about this. However, choosing to drill for more oil means planting a ticking carbon time-bomb, and the disregard of previous promises made by the Biden Administration to cut down on oil-drilling.

I believe that the only solution going forward is to transform our idea of nature in accordance with indigenous worldviews and knowledge

Here we are facing a problem that cannot be solved under our current system. I believe that the only solution going forward is to transform our idea of nature in accordance with indigenous worldviews and knowledge. We must stop seeing our environment as something we can dominate and exploit for our benefit, and instead view it as something that we grow alongside and respect. We cannot keep taking and taking, and we need to move to a way of life that does not depend on extractivism.

Now, I am not suggesting we throw away the idea of indoor heating, but instead take small steps towards an economy that runs on green energy rather than oil, and on collaboration rather than destruction. Biden, as the incumbent of the most powerful country in the world, needs to stop authorising proposals such as the Willow Project, and continue his investment in the Green Transition to lead the way towards a greener future.

To me, shifting our mode of production slightly in order to accommodate long-term consequences seems like an obvious choice, but as I said, I learned the consequences of underestimating greed a while ago.

Image: Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement via Flickr