Why devolution should matter to students
The Scottish Government’s decision to charge English students the full £9000 annual fees has reopened the ongoing debate over the real political difference for those on the other side of the border.
Students in England and Wales currently pay £3225 a year for tuition, something which will change drastically with the introduction of the controversial £9000 cap in a year’s time. This hefty charge for further education seems to be something grimly accepted by English students; for the most part, they don’t like it, but it doesn’t look like it’s going away anytime soon.
For Scottish students, however, it’s a different story. Free university there is the norm; that is, at least, if you live on the right side of the border.
The Scottish government insist that the distinction is based upon ‘ordinary domicile’ as opposed to nationality. However, stories such as that of Johnny Whiting, the student from Berwick-Upon-Tweed, just two miles from the border, and excluded from the free education enjoyed by his neighbours on the grounds of his nationality, raise uncomfortable questions in many minds.
English students are bemused and a little affronted by the apparently hostile attitude of the Scottish government towards them, especially considering that students from other parts of the E.U are eligible for free education. Scottish students claim pride in a system that offers free tuition for all. But at what cost?
This issue highlights the uncomfortable relationship between Scottish nationals and those who some still see as their English oppressors. Scottish efforts to retain control of some aspects of their jurisdiction are at the root of the abrupt differences in the rules just a step over the border. Full devolution is always an issue on the table; despite a 2008 YouGov poll indicating that as few as 25% of scots were in favour of full independence, recent calls for another referendum have recently been made by Scottish Conservative MP Jackson Carlaw.
For many students devolution may seem a trivial political issue, particularly when we are constantly confronted with ethical dilemmas about the spending of huge amounts of public money on the Olympics, wars in the Middle East and MPs’ duckhouses. However, the tuition fees controversy should prompt many to reconsider their attitude. The Scotland Bill currently progressing through the House of Lords devolves further powers to Edinburgh, including what Scottish Secretary Michael Moore described as ‘the largest transfer of fiscal powers from Central Government since the creation of the United Kingdom’. This is no small change. Westminster must consider the extent to which the tuition fees controversy is part of a far greater national problem; the added strain upon the public purse caused by the money going north. Some estimates claim that average spending per Scottish citizen is almost £2000 greater than that on their English counterparts.
Legal experts have warned that challenges to the proposals at the European Court of Human Rights are unlikely to be successful. The Scottish Government maintains that their rulings are ‘lawful’ and do not contravene human rights laws. Whether or not the legal challenges are upheld, this is an opportunity for English, Welsh and Northern Irish students to consider the effects that devolution may be having upon their education.

