Superfluous Superheroes
By James Oliver
From 1951 until 2000, there were roughly thirty films that can be classified as  “superhero movies”. Between that time and the end of 2012 (assuming Roland Emmerich was just kidding around back in ’09 and the planet makes it that far) there will have been nearly sixty. So, in less than a quarter of the time, we have enjoyed (or endured?) double the heroes. The platform has transformed from a relatively bit-part player into a highly successful industry; and it has taken just slightly longer than a decade. With great power comes great responsibility but rather than boost the industry to new heights, superheroes have been a detriment to cinemas.
With each new superhero movie, Hollywood begins another lap on a track of relentless repetition. Studio superiors continuously trawl the depths of comic book lore, scrambling for more with dollar signs gleaming in their eyes. Look at the facts, the original Superman, in 1978, made $300m. Tim Burton’s Batman made $411m in the 80’s. Today, adjusting for inflation, these figures neatly flank the $1bn mark. In recent times, The Dark Knight made over $1bn and all three Spiderman films came tantalisingly close to that worshipped but elusive figure.
Superheroes have always been synonymous with colossal sums of money and will likely continue to be so. Endless sub-par sequelizing and prequelizing of franchises big (Spiderman 3, X-Men Origins: Wolverine) and small (Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer, Hellboy 2) has proved extremely fruitful for those who count cash to induce slumber each night. Sadly, for those of us who haven’t yet graduated from sheep leaping a fence, the fruit has turned sour.
The quality of these films abjectly fails to justify their ubiquity. With so many new releases, audiences are being persistently subjected to tested but tired templates that evoke a similar response time after time. The “origin story” invariably kicks things off, with our newborn protagonist finally fulfilling his or her innate heroic potential. In the inevitable sequel, we will likely face an internal struggle over whether or not our central character wishes to remain The Hero. There needs to be a booster of creativity and innovation, if we are to honour the work on which these films are based.
Encouragingly, films such as Kick Ass have been a breath of fresh air. The 2010 flick provided viewers with a well managed balance of violence, comedy and some emotive sequences thrown in to satisfy even the most cynical of paying customers. This year, a lesser-known Australian film (track it down!) Griff the Invisible took a contrasting, subtle approach. The result was a film devoid of banality and insincerity, instead focusing on emotional and provocative narrative. Both of these films have done something the typical superhero movie does not, use the superhero genre as a vessel for a statement. Why is this done so infrequently?
Not every superhero film can be The Dark Knight. However, this does not mean the studios shouldn’t strive to reach that level. Why should they – or we – be satisfied with mediocrity? I’d like to make a suggestion for the bosses of the big studios. Why not take more time considering and adapting your precious back-catalogue of revered, altruistic luminaries? A little less Elektra, a lot more Kick-Ass, please. Dim the lights on the dollars and shift the focus to the face of your audience. Aim higher and you might just produce something that makes you money and enchants. Would that require a superhuman effort?

