When standing up for beliefs just goes too far
by Olivia Rudgard
With impeccable timing, a classic British political debate over faith, secularism and equal rights erupted just in time for Durham’s Reason Week.
Perhaps politicians were looking to provide some inflammatory headlines in the absence of any real news bar the odd opportunity to point and laugh at the ridiculous spectacle provided by the Republican effort to present the worst in American bigotry, but all they have succeeded in doing is making themselves look very silly.
Richard Dawkins has called religious people silly, Baroness Warsi has pointed the finger at ‘militant atheism’, and David Cameron has tried very hard to reiterate that Britain is a Christian Country without offending anyone. Even the Queen has been wheeled out to claim in her capacity as Defender of (the) Faith that the church is there to protect freedom of religion.
Everyone also got very overexcited about an ex-council minister in Bideford who claimed rather hysterically that his human rights were imperilled by his fellow councillors’ pre-meeting prayers. The High Court ban on worship at council meetings in response to this was then overturned by a ‘fast-tracked’ government law, to the relief of the religious and right wing.
The only thing that everyone in this debate really has in common is their inflammatory and highly disproportionate rhetoric. Richard Dawkins has been reliably boorish and pompous. Because he is so smug, everyone (even some atheists) were delighted when he failed to recite the full title of Darwin’s Origin of the Species when challenged to by the Rev Giles Fraser.
This was hilarious, especially when he reacted by saying ‘Oh God’, but its significance has been massively overstated by the religious camp, who seem to have failed to understand that the Origin of the Species is not a religious text which atheists must learn by rote and blindly follow. However, his purpose in being involved in the debate in the first place was similarly ridiculous; he is seeking to prove that Christians who don’t know much about Christianity are not really Christians at all. Trying to tell other people what they are, regardless of how they define themselves, is obnoxious and patronising.
However, Baroness Warsi, in accusing secularists of totalitarianism, is also way wide of the mark. She seems to have forgotten that she, as a religious person, is perfectly free to openly practise her faith and hold an important position in government, and that she made this speech to the Pope, having been flown to Rome at governmental expense. Our head of state, Prime Minister and half of the House of Lords are practising Christians. Christian rights are not under threat in this country, and comparing Britain to Stalinist Russia is borderline offensive; imagine if she had compared it to Nazi Germany.
What is under threat is Christian privilege to be homophobic, sexist and exclusionary. Some of the more unpleasant reactions to this religious debate have trumpeted the sanctity of marriage and its apparent threat from the ‘gay agenda’. A petition developed by the Coalition for Marriage implores the public ‘Don’t Play Politics with Marriage’, and the Lord Carey has written an extremely reactionary article in the Daily Mail arguing that gay marriage would ‘jeopardise the stability of our country’. A recent spate of failed religious freedom cases, including that of Peter and Hazelmary Bull, the Christians who refused to allow a gay couple to stay at their bed and breakfast has been taken as evidence that society is ‘skewed against religion’. This claim is plainly rubbish.
The atheist opposition to ideas like this does not seek to control religion or limit religious peoples’ freedom of expression, but to protect the equal rights of a large portion of our society. Religious people are free to practise their faith in churches, mosques, temples and synagogues throughout the country. What they are not free to do is to limit the freedoms of others because of their beliefs. Nor is Richard Dawkins justified in attempting to curtail the rights of Christians to define themselves as Christians. Both aspects of the debate have succeeded only in revealing their dogmatic, incendiary sides. I would blame neither humanists nor religious people if this week they were more than a little embarrassed at the behaviour of their representatives.
Is religion under attack? Does Dawkins’ survey prove anything about the state of the church in this country? Tweet us @PalatiComment or share your views below

