Is American politics broken?

By Oliver Gratton

This summer the world witnessed one of the most bizarre episodes in recent US history. The debt ceiling crisis, though not juicy sounding enough to attract as much attention as it deserved, was an exceedingly dangerous moment for a world on the brink of financial collapse. What was even more striking was that the crisis was not unavoidable and was, indeed, deliberately engineered for political advantage by a newly invigorated and populist American right-wing. This debacle was just the latest symptom of a political system in crisis as the Republican Party has turned from a responsible, if misguided party of government, into a populist and churlish party of opposition.

Along with Denmark, the United States is one of the very few countries to have a legal limit on how much its government may borrow. The raising of the debt-ceiling is normally just a formality; politicians are rarely callous enough to risk the US’s good name in the pursuit of factional advantage. This summer, however, Republican lawmakers in the House of Representatives decided to use the vote on the raising of the debt ceiling to force Obama’s hand in carrying out widespread spending cuts. Allegedly this was out of concern for the budget deficit, though their refusal to even contemplate raising taxes tells the story of a party ideologically committed to slashing federal spending programmes whatever the cost to the country.

Had the ceiling not been raised, the government would have been unable to pay off its creditors or meet its other spending commitments. This would almost certainly have led to a lowering of the US’s credit rating by independent agencies. The impact on an already fragile world economy would have been devastating. US treasury bonds are widely used as collateral around the world and the resulting panic in world financial markets would have greatly driven up the cost of borrowing for countries, businesses and consumers. In addition, we would have witnessed the nightmare scenario of Federal wages and social security cheques going unpaid. A failure to negotiate a deal on the debt ceiling would, in the words of Austen Goolsbee, Chairman of the President’s Council of Economic advisors, have precipitated “a worse financial economic crisis than anything we saw in 2008”.

What made this worse was that this crisis was entirely artificial. The most urgent problem facing America is stagnant growth and rampant unemployment. When we worry about deficits, we worry about them because of how they affect our costs of borrowing. When deficits are high, financial markets worry about a country’s ability to pay back future debt and this worry increases that country’s cost of borrowing.

What was striking about the US as opposed to other countries such as Spain, Greece or even Britain was that the interest it had to pay on its treasury bonds was comparatively very low and staying that way . US borrowing was emphatically not becoming more expensive, markets were not sending panic signals about the US government’s budget deficit. A strong fiscal consolidation of the form forced upon the country by the Republicans, one which will almost certainly further depress a weak economy, was and remains wholly unnecessary. In the long term, the net effect of decreased growth is almost certain to make the government deficit higher not lower.

Over the month long debacle, US politicians came under a lot of fire for being overly partisan rather than reaching for the centre ground. On the Democratic side at least, this was unfair and was a consequence of the usual assumption by the media that both sides in an argument are equally at fault. In an effort to reach out to Republicans for a deal, Obama was willing to go out on a limb and betray much of what his base holds dear. Throughout his presidency, Obama’s inability to see the intransigence of his opponent has frustrated his Liberal base and, by any objective standard, the eventual deal that was reached was a monumental victory for the Right. The Budget Control Act, the eventual “compromise” deal passed by Congress, about 12 hours before the government would have stopped being able to borrow, raised the ceiling in exchange for $917 billion of spending cuts.

Not only economically unwise, sapping even more demand out of the economy, it was and is also patently unfair. A Democratic President signed into law a bill that slashes government spending on the poorest and most vulnerable, while reversing none of the Bush-era tax cuts for the wealthy. We are now in an absurd situation where people like Warren Buffet are publically calling for higher taxes on the ultra-wealthy while the Republicans, who are beginning to make Cameron’s Conservatives look like the Che Guevara brigade, dismiss any such proposals as “class warfare”.

Though the President’s lacklustre and seemingly spineless performance this summer is a source of great frustration to progressives, it is hard not to sympathise with the challenges he faces. Political discourse in America is being dragged ever further to the right by an unholy alliance of big business, bible bashers and small-minded xenophobes.

Yes, we’re talking about the Tea Party, a group which prides itself on being unwilling to compromise and whose destabilising influence is coming close to making the system unworkable. Unlike Britain’s Westminster System, the checks and balances inherent in American politics necessitate that the two main parties cooperate in order to avoid governmental gridlock. This is even truer as divided government, where one party controls Congress and the other controls the Presidency, is becoming the norm rather than the exception. The Republicans single-minded obsession with pursuing their ideological goals at any cost is derailing the system of government their representatives have pledged to uphold.

Sadly, it does not look like the prospect of returning to power after the 2012 elections is about to make them change track. At a debate in Iowa in August, the five main Republican presidential contenders each pledged to reject a debt deal which proposed a 10:1 ratio of spending cuts to tax increases. That the candidates feel forced to denounce a deal, which would be far better that anything they could realistically get on the table, is an indication of how far from the centre the GOP has strayed.

The good news for progressives is that this intransigence is likely to get Obama re-elected. The bad news is that, unless the Republican Party becomes more reasonable, it is hard to see how America can deal with any of its long term problems which, yes, include its structural deficit. In these times of economic and political uncertainty, the world needs a well governed America. It’s time for America’s crazy right to grow up and stop holding the rest of the country to ransom.