What’s next for Scottish Labour?
It is now almost two months since the Scottish people delivered the ‘no’ verdict in the referendum on Scottish independence, and yet it seems even clearer now than it did then that this was not a victory for Scottish Labour. Labour MSPs had been invisible on the campaign. Your average Scot would not have been able to name the then-leader and deputy-leader, Johann Lamont and Anas Sarwar, whilst Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon seemed to be present in every village, town and city across the country, fighting for what they believed in. Labour voters switched to the ‘yes’ side in their troves and despite the narrow victory for the Better Together campaign, the 19th September marked a low-point for the Labour Party in Scotland.
Johann Lamont’s resignation came as little surprise after 3 underwhelming years in charge, with an approval rating that peaked at 6%. The failure to bring a ‘no’ vote in Labour strongholds such as Glasgow and North Lanarkshire cannot solely be attributed to a failure in the leadership of the party, but its lack of presence surely played an important part.
The question now must be whether the future holds any hope for Scottish Labour. The leadership election will take place on 13th December, with Jim Murphy looking like the forerunner at the moment, ahead of Sarah Boyack and Neil Findlay. This could prove a vital decision for the party, having lost the last two Scottish Parliament elections to the SNP, and with only a year and a half until the next ballots. Murphy is the sort of figure that could inject a charisma and character into the party, which it has been desperately missing of late, but he is unpopular with many Scots. Having served as an MP in Westminster since 1997, many see him as a career politician, following power, and only now returning to Scotland when it seems he is in with a shot of the ‘big job’.
And perhaps this sense of career politicians is the greatest failure of the Labour Party in Scotland. If you were to list the best three politicians in Holyrood, the answer for many would be Alex Salmond, Nicola Sturgeon and John Swinney – all SNP. The problem for Labour is that many, if not most, of their Scottish candidates see Westminster as the more attractive objective. There is no shortage of good Labour politicians from Scotland – Gordon Brown, Alastair Darling, Douglas Alexander, and Jim Murphy himself, have all held high positions in UK politics over the last ten years – but all of them as MPs not MSPs.
Though the same cannot be said of Boyack or Findlay, they may simply have a bit too much of the ‘Lamont’ about them – they are not big, well-known figures in Scotland outside of political circles and may well struggle to engage with the masses enough to defeat the SNP in 2015. Ultimately, it does seem that Jim Murphy is the best man for the job, but it will not be an easy one: he will have to battle to win back the support of thousands of disillusioned Scottish voters. And the party will have no choice but to revive from a basic level – young Labour politicians in Scotland must be driven by a desire for change rather than a desire for power, and only then will they regain the trust, support and respect of the Scottish electorate.
Illustration: Uel McCreary

