Green with envy: Bennett’s debate jealousy
Last Monday, [by the time this goes to print] the Green Party threatened a legal challenge against TV broadcasters after the announcement of a proposal for next year’s televised electoral debates.
The proposal – jointly outlined by the BBC, Channel 4, ITV and Sky – would see UKIP leader Nigel Farage included in one of several debates, along with the three main party leaders.
Behind the plan to open up the debates, some have sensed a relaxation of the two-party system’s already ailing grip on British public life.
Nonetheless, critics of the plan have been quick to point out that by objective criteria, the Greens have as much right to enjoy the oxygen of televisual publicity as their more right-wing counterparts and indeed, Nick Clegg’s party.
The Green MP Caroline Lucas has sat in Parliament for the last four years, and if it lacks the polling impetus of its right wing counterpart, the party still enjoys similar figures to the beleaguered Liberal Democrats. Indeed, they outperformed the latter in this year’s European elections, both in the number of MEPs returned and in overall share of the vote.
Another important factor for consideration is the Greens’ nationwide appeal. Unlike UKIP, they have gained traction in Scotland and found support in Wales.
The debates will give participants the chance to give their arguments a thorough airing ahead of next year’s general election. From a liberal standpoint then, excluding one party and choosing to include another might be said to debase the free marketplace of ideas.
Speaking to the Guardian, Natalie Bennett said that ‘the public want a serious debate in which they hear the full range of views, including a party that stands up against Ukip on immigration.’ This sense that the Greens might act as a countervailing force against the excesses of UKIP is possibly one of the reasons why David Cameron has uncharacteristically decided to throw his weight behind the environmental party.
If UKIP are gnashing at the heels of the Tories, then in some ways the Greens themselves are beginning to champ behind Farage and his flunkies. It would be rash to conclude that the genuine indignation of the protest vote – so efficiently courted by UKIP in recent years – cannot yet be availed by the Greens.
Commentators have pointed out that the Greens lack the sleek media machine of the UKIP camp, but what is less commonly accepted is the encumbrances that inhere in the Green message.
UKIP have managed to convince many voters that anti-immigration policies and leaving the EU are a panacea for the strife of austerity Britain. Conversely, if environmentalism is winning all of the scientific arguments and an ever increasing number of supporters, the Greens have yet to convince people of the merits of policies which go against the grain of domestic politics in recent years.
Even if the debates do get knocked into a more inclusive format, this will only be the start of the Green’s challenge to explain the full implications of what is a radical vision for governing Britain.
Illustration: Uel McCreary

