The ‘Cinderella Law’ belongs in fairytales
By Sandy Thin
A lot has changed since 1933: the death penalty still existed in Britain; there was no NHS and any suggestion of legalising gay marriage would have ended a Member of Parliament’s career. It was a different time and the law reflected that. However, 80 years on we find that one of the laws most affected by social setting and opinion remains unchanged.
Following a recent campaign by UK charity ‘Action for Children’, the government is considering introducing a new law on emotional cruelty to children. Known as the ‘Cinderella Law’, this will aim to combat child neglect among other issues of “emotional abuse”. Although change to this legislation is necessary, significant problems exist in the changes proposed by the NSPCC.
The 1933 Children and Young Persons Act accounts for “child neglect”, but only in cases of physical rather than emotional or psychological damage. While the twenty first-century recognises that the damage caused by emotional abuse can be as significant as physical, the NSPCC definition of what constitutes “emotional abuse” is simply too vague to be brought into British law.
This extensive definition of emotional abuse put forward by the NSPCC covers both ends of the parental spectrum: it accounts for adults who are over-protective and adults who are not attentive enough; adults that have unrealistic expectations of their children and adults that are too liberal with their children. In all this, it seems the NSPCC are simultaneously providing very strict and very blurred instructions as to how to be a parent and, in doing so, somewhat miss the point of what it means to be a parent.
According to this definition, “making fun” of a child should be considered to be “emotional abuse” and should be punished as such. While there is obviously a point at which “making fun” can become something more serious and detrimental for a child, it can often provide the basis for filial affection. If this definition was used in a legal setting, we might find ourselves edging closer to a ‘nanny state’, the sort of nanny that not only does everything for the child but actively discourages it from doing things that may benefit its development.
The danger at the heart of this issue is really that the state may begin to remove freedom and creativity from parenting. Britain’s increasing multiculturalism means it is impossible to say that there is a ‘right way’ to raise your children. While many may criticise the Amy Chua approach to parenting, described in Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother, for its fierce and unrelenting nature, this criticism comes from a Western perspective and regardless, it is not uncommon to find ‘tiger mothers’ in white middle-class British families. To disagree with this sort of parenting is perfectly acceptable but to make it illegal is to dismiss what is a way of life for many people.
Further problems arise in how such things could possibly be monitored: are we to install surveillance in every home in the country, or would all enforcement be based purely on the testimony of the child? Assuming the former would be too Orwellian even for the modern world of GCHQ, the sanctions and enforcement of these laws would be somewhat farcical.
The failure of the Cinderella Law is rooted in overshot expectations. In seeking to prevent neglect or cruelty to children the ruling strays into realms of the unjust. It is unjust that any parent could be held accountable in court for the vague accusation that they were “making fun” of their child; it is unjust that parents should be dissuaded from encouraging excellence in their children and it is unrealistic to expect courts to distinguish with wording so ambiguous as that set out by the NSPCC. Changes must be made to the laws and legislation on emotional abuse and parenting, but the Cinderella Law is not the answer.
Instead the government should seek to help rather than punish new and struggling parents with state-funded parental preparation groups or schemes of this ilk, rather than outlawing any form of parenting that strays from the NSPCC’s vision of basic blandness.
Photograph: DeviantArt

