An SNP coalition: opportunity or disaster?
As May 7th draws ever closer, it becomes increasingly obvious that there will be no overall majority in Westminster. It remains unclear, however, what will happen in the days that follow, and thus it is important, perhaps, to look a little more closely at what the other parties that may make up our government actually have to offer.
Many voters in England knew nothing about the SNP beyond their nationalist foundations until a few weeks ago, when Nicola Sturgeon surprised many non-Scots with her passionate and statesmanlike manner in the first of televised leaders’ debates. It was the first time (for much of the British press) that the SNP had been taken seriously, not just as a nationalist protest vote against Scottish Labour and the Tories, but for what they represent for many of the Scots who will vote for them next month: a true political left.
A brief look at the changes brought in by SNP in Scotland, since they took control of Parliament in 2007, will immediately show that there is a lot more to their ambitions than independence. Many of the policies presented by the SNP would be incredibly attractive to Labour supporters in England and the rest of the UK. Free tuition, no prescription charges, an end to Trident, limits to industry bonuses, investment in offshore wind farming. The list goes on, and for all the leftist rhetoric of the Labour party, there is an increasing sense in Scotland that that position has become firmly filled, as more and more previously impenetrable Labour seats look likely to fall to SNP.
According to a recent poll by Lord Ashcroft, even senior Labour MPs such as Scottish Labour leader, Jim Murphy, and Shadow Foreign Secretary and Campaign Strategist, Douglas Alexander, look set to lose their seats to SNP candidates. While Labour continue with the tactical suggestion that Scots who vote SNP will enable another Tory-led government, the fact is that many Scottish voters would not see much of a difference between the two. As Sturgeon quipped in the Opposition Leaders’ debate, ‘it’s the difference between Tory and Tory-lite.’
Fundamentally, however, the SNP remain a nationalist party, with the dominant aim of Scotland leaving the United Kingdom, and for this reason a formal coalition with Labour, such as the Tory-Lib Dem one, would probably be impossible, even if their combined seats were to add up on May 8th. Instead, a likely outcome would be an informal backing of a Labour minority government, on an issue-by-issue basis.
While minority governments are often criticized for being ineffectual in passing legislation (the main reason why the Tories sought to avoid it in 2010), the SNP have previous experience in making it work, between 2007 and 2011 in the Scottish Parliament. An issue-by-issue union of Labour and the SNP may actually provide the outcome that many voters across the UK are looking for from this election, and yet seem unable to find. Over the debates, Sturgeon has endeavoured to ensure voters that, despite being a nationalist party, the SNP seeks equality and better living standards across the UK, not just in Scotland.
And the leadership is important, too. Unlike Nick Clegg, Nicola Sturgeon and Alex Salmond are unlikely to bow down on any policy they don’t agree with, especially outwith the confines of a formal coalition. The issue of broken manifesto promises would surely be reduced – the SNP have no reason to pass anything they don’t agree with, as they would ostensibly all hold opposition backbench positions, propping up Labour only when the policies fit with the SNP’s values and policies.
This is not to say that the SNP would hold the balance of power in Westminster; under this potentiality, it would still be a Labour government, and the legislation presented would be for the most part Labour policy, not SNP. At best, the SNP can only win the 50-odd seats they contend in Scotland, and thus would only have around 7% of seats in the Commons. But they could prove vital in holding Labour to the promises that matter to so many voters in this election: the reduction of tuition fees across the country, the protection of the NHS, the building of 200,000 new homes, and many more. In the weeks that follow, it is important to see the SNP beyond their nationalist beginnings, as the occupants of the political left that Labour should really be filling.
Photograph: Wikipedia

