The Potential UK Coalition Governments

Coalition

By Matthew Beebee

With the General Election creeping closer and closer, the only thing that looks certain is that there will be no clear winner. The UK looks to be heading for another hung parliament on May 8th, and the high probability of another coalition.

Constitutional procedure dictates that the serving Prime Minister’s party – in this case David Cameron’s Conservatives – have the first chance to form a coalition after the election, but both main parties will more than likely be in a position to form a coalition. However, there is a very broad range of potential coalitions that could be formed, each which would steer the UK in very different ways to the others.

Labour/SNP

This is perhaps the most talked about potential coalition after the election. Ironically, this talk is more from the opposition to such an arrangement; the Conservatives in particular have spent much of the campaign talking about the ‘economic chaos’ of a Labour/SNP deal and the ‘frightening’ prospect of Labour working with a party determined to ultimately break up the UK. Labour have ruled out a formal coalition but the SNP seem prepared to support Labour on a ‘confidence-and-supply’ arrangement; effectively the SNP would support a Labour minority government in getting its budget and legislation through. Labour are very hesitant to talk up any post-election deal with the SNP in order to save face in the likelihood of a near electoral wipeout in Scotland to the SNP themselves.

Despite the two parties agreeing broadly philosophically on a lot of issues– commitment to social justice and social equality – as well as on policies such as scrapping the bedroom tax and raising taxes on the wealthiest, the SNP would still like to see Labour be ‘bolder’ by loosening its commitment to deficit reduction, pushing Labour in a more leftist direction. There remain key areas of disagreement, particularly over the SNP commitment to scrapping Trident nuclear defence and the future of Scotland. The SNP are calling for full fiscal autonomy while Labour claims this would leave a significant black hole in the Scottish budget. There is also the lingering question of a future Scottish independence referendum. The issues of national defence and constitutional politics will be key for any Labour/SNP deal, not necessarily national economic policy.

Labour/Lib Dem

Despite the Lib Dems being critical of Labour’s economic plan, on issues such as improving opportunity in education, increasing tax on the rich and social policy there is much in common between the two parties. As a result, a coalition between these two parties would see a less dramatic approach to deficit reduction – with a focus on tax increases as well as modest spending cuts, while heavily focusing on public investment in key public services. The Lib Dems would argue they would add ‘brains’ to the Labour Party who would ‘borrow too much’ in government on their own. However. senior Labour figures have previously ruled out a coalition with the Lib Dems due to their decision to enter coalition with the Conservatives in 2010, with Ed Balls saying he would not do a deal with the Lib Dems while Nick Clegg was leader. The biggest block to this coalition is whether Labour is the biggest party in terms of seats – the Lib Dems have said they would enter coalition with the party holding the biggest mandate i.e. that with the most seats. However, given the Lib Dems look set to lose a decent chunk of their 2010 seats, a ‘Lab-Lib’ coalition is mathematically problematic; the two parties combined could potentially only form a minority government.

Conservative/Lib Dem

Similarly, the Lib Dems have said they would be happy to work with the Tories again in a continuation of the 2010-2015 government. The argument from both parties would be to let them ‘continue the job we have started’. However, there is reservation in both parties; the Tories believe they were hamstrung by the Lib Dems in the last government, and the Lib Dems believe they didn’t get enough credit for their contributions last time around. There are two big divisions between the parties. The £10bn spending cuts to the welfare budget that the Tories are planning is seen as too ‘extreme’ by the Lib Dems, who argue they would add a ‘heart’ to a Conservative government by limiting these cuts. The Lib Dems are unashamedly pro-European while the Tories are offering a referendum on membership of a reformed EU which the Lib Dems vehemently oppose.

These are two policy areas that became increasingly fraught over the course of the previous parliament and would only be exacerbated in the next government. But again, a big issue that the Lib Dems face is their own seat numbers – ironically polls are suggesting a high number of Lib Dem seats in the south of England may go to the Conservatives. Ultimately though, this does look like the Conservatives’ most likely chance of government – unless they remarkably achieve a majority or decide to rule as a largest-party minority – and so would perhaps be prepared to make concession to the Lib Dems in order to remain in office and continue their objective of clearing the UK’s budget deficit.

Labour/‘the left’

Given the very fragmented nature of British politics currently, two-party coalition may not be enough. What we may face is a multi-party coalition. A Labour-led multi-party coalition could consist of any combination of ‘left-wing’ parties from across the UK: Lib Dems and the Greens in England, SNP in Scotland, Plaid Cymru in Wales or the Northern Irish Social Democratic and Labour Party. With the exception of the SNP and the Lib Dems, the other parties will collectively only have around 6-8 MPs – which isn’t a great deal to contribute towards a majority.

What further complicates matters is the Lib Dems have refused to enter a coalition with the SNP, as they see it as ‘undemocratic’ to work with in the ‘national interest’ with a party committed to breaking up the Union. The only real uniting force of all these nominally-leftist parties is their commitment to spend money on the NHS and a broad ‘anti-Tory’ platform (the Lib Dems aside, perhaps). Beyond that, there is little room for broad agreement and Labour – as the leading party – would face a tough time juggling the demands of many parties, opening up accusations Labour were bowing to the demands of very marginal parties simply to be in office. Working with nationalist parties from Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland would also raise considerable questions over the future of the UK under this coalition, even if elements of the Labour left have sympathy with the anti-austerity politics of the nationalists. The disparity between all these parties on key policies such as deficit reduction, defence and constitutional matters would be too big a hurdle to overcome.

Conservative/UKIP/DUP

For the Conservatives, their multiparty coalition would include fewer parties than a possible Labour combination but is no less complicated. The coalition between the Conservatives, UKIP and the Northern Irish Democratic Unionist Party has been pejoratively called ‘Blukip’ by the Lib Dems. While certain sections of the Tory electorate and parliamentary party may support the social conservatism and Euroscepticism of UKIP and the DUP, the Tory leadership is slightly more liberal on social matters – gay marriage especially – and is more pragmatic on its Euroscepticism. The Tories would be open to accusations of ‘pandering to the right’ and may be forced to bring forward their 2017 in/out referendum on a reformed EU, bringing potential economic uncertainty.

UKIP would be prepared to do a deal with the Tories while the DUP, for their part, have also offered potential alliance with Labour as long as Northern Irish funding is secured. Both the DUP and UKIP will be relatively minor players following the election in terms of seats. This requires the Tories to have a seat majority close to the threshold of a majority party to justify utilising this coalition to tip them over the line, especially with the Lib Dems – a potentially more significant Tory coalition partner – categorically ruling out working with UKIP and the DUP. The Tories having a majority of seats close to the majority threshold is something polls are not predicting, making a ‘Blukip’ coalition a very difficult task.

Photograph: Wikipedia