The lurch rightwards: UKIP’s effects on British politics
Given the interminable economic malady of the Eurozone, stagnant wage earnings, and the growing mistrust of UK politicians, it is little wonder that the UK Independence Party has surged in the polls. Winning the European elections, taking their first seat in Westminster from the Tories and almost a second from Labour, as well as pulling two defectors from the Conservative Party, it is clear to see why the mainstream political parties are worried about their electoral fortunes, and why they have shifted rightwards in politics as a result.
Admittedly, the Conservative party under Cameron have always stood for centre-right economic policies. They stood for reforming (read as reducing) welfare, of some amorphous ‘long term economic plan’ in imposing austerity to reduce the deficit and for some immigration reform. But since UKIP began grabbing vast numbers of traditional Tory voters, Cameron’s policies have swung invariably rightwards.
His desperate attempts to reclaim those voters lost the UKIP have resulted in hastily hashed plans to renegotiate powers back from the EU, especially in order to end free labour movement and scrapping the Human Rights Act, promising an EU referendum if he returns to Downing Street in 2015, and hoping to focus on cutting immigration.
Despite presumably knowing the benefits both of immigration and of EU membership, the prime minister believes the only way to regain his voter base is to pander to UKIP rhetoric, agree with Farage, and state repeatedly that he is the only person that can get the job done. Despite this, rebellious members of his party still feel he’s not doing enough; there is a brewing Tory storm regarding the European arrest warrant, which Theresa May sees as vital but many Conservative MPs seeing as a threat to UK sovereignty. Indeed one of their candidates of the upcoming Rochester and Strood by election, Anna Firth, is in favour of a points based for immigrants within the EU.
Miliband hardly fares better. A socialist at heart he may be, but his hopeless incompetence at voicing the most pertinent issues- neglecting in his conference speech mention of the deficit and immigration, for one- and without the courage of convictions to push for the strong stance that he wants means he is failing to expand his voter base at all, and sees it instead contracting. Rather than speaking out strongly in favour of immigration or the EU (his policies are for vague EU and immigration reforms), he pathetically opts for that uninspiring cliche ‘you can only trust Labour with the NHS’ and thereby focuses his attention somewhere that few else are. In the absence of real leadership, his senior advisers are already pushing rightwards as well, with many calling for a stronger stance on immigration.
Rightward shifts won’t recapture the numbers of voters that Labour and the Tories want. The propaganda supplying UKIP ammunition is at time racist and at others simply nonsensical. Obviously, calling for immigration reform is not inherently xenophobic, but the principles behind Farage’s doing so are (for instance, he said in an interview with LBC that he would not want to live next to Romanians, and that he is intimidated by people speaking a foreign language on trains). When pressed, Farage admits that immigration may be conducive to economic prosperity, his urge then being that other considerations are more important. Given, then, that the average immigrant to the UK puts more into the system than they withdraw, that they create more jobs than they take, and that public service pressures placed on them can be relieved with money from the growth that they help create, one wanders what these considerations could possibly be. And votes that go to UKIP on racist grounds will not be won back, because they want a racist leader with other radical policies more extreme than any mainstream party could adopt.
For those voters that see UKIP’s policies are reasonable, Cameron reproducing Farage’s bile and consequently attempting to regain powers and cut immigration is not only worse for the people of Britain, but is unlikely to win back substantial numbers of votes. Firstly, it is because UKIP’s policies are a pseudo-solution to real issues. Hence, the Tories cutting immigration won’t have the effect of putting more people into jobs, and of raising their living standards, but will have the reverse effect. The only reason UKIP gets away with it is that it is not accountable for its policies; no-one knows if they’ll fail, because they’ll never get to try them, and they will keep pressuring Cameron to get more and more extreme as the policies produce worse and worse results. Moreover, it is because Farage has successful reinforced the characterisation of the mainstream parties as parties of the establishment; corrupt, lying and not willing to get the job done.
Far better, then, for the party leaders to stress that 29 million Romanians and Bulgarians are not imminently about to move into Clacton. They need to emphasise that immigration is good for British economic and social diversity as long as it comes with reasonable conditions, such as knowing the English language. Moreover, the birth lottery should not prevent underprivileged foreigners having the opportunity to prosper somewhere else. They need to urge us all to realise that EU membership is crucial for our trade and for our influential position within Europe and the world. They need to discredit the mischaracterisation of the EU as an institution run by unaccountable bureaucrats in Brussels that tell us what to do. And they need to exclaim that isolation for the Union and from prospective migrants is a step in the wrong direction. Those reasonable people taken in by UKIP propaganda and lies should know that voting for the protest party, or voting for disintegration is not in their best interests.
In British politics, the irrationality that has taken hold, and the convulsion that has resulted in recent months has left political analysts utterly bewildered, and sensible people wondering who there is left to vote for. Party leaders need to get a grip and beat UKIP’s rhetoric, not adopt it.
Photograph: Derek Bennett

