Durham Students’ Union rejects motion calling for no-fees higher education

DSU Tom Page

By Oliver Hamlet

Last week, Durham Student’s Union rejected a motion calling for higher education to be free for students, with the Students’ Union president himself opposing the motion and arguing that free access to universities placed too high a cost on the taxpayer. This indicates our president’s unfortunate ignorance as to the effects of university fees, given that a new report illustrates that, far from merely tangibly impoverishing graduates, the higher tuition fees have had little impact on government finances. It suggests once again the unfortunate incompetence of Student Unions in actually representing the interests of their students, coming just a month after the National Union of Students defeated a motion aiming to condemn Islamic State.

The report states that the level of likely write-off costs on tuition loans has surpassed forty five percent of the £10 billion in loans provided each year and is fast approaching the disastrous 48.6% mark, at which point the government begins to lose more money that when the loans were at the lower figure of £3,000 per year. Hence government ministers’ rhetoric- that it would enable universities to become truly world-class, and that it would save the taxpayer millions of pounds per year- has proved to be utterly empty. Lumping students with higher loans will not lead to lower pressure on the taxpayer, since a far smaller proportion of the loans are likely to be paid off.

So much for supposed government savings. How about the benefits to universities and students of extra tuition payments? The report argues that far from introducing more diverse learning models, the 2012 reforms, which followed the 2011 higher education white paper, “have resulted in zero price variation, little expansion of new offers for students and minimal innovation in teaching and learning.” Universities are, in fact, turning to increasing student numbers at the expense of more personal teaching and a better quality of life; indeed on 6th November, Palatinate reported that some Durham students were being denied ‘basic consumer rights’, regarding new accommodation blocks installed in Stockton campus. This is despite Durham having been rated the best university for quality of student life last year.

But the issues threatening future graduates are the most alarming. The Institute of Fiscal studies calculates that students will graduate with an average of £44,035 of student debt, compared to £24,754 of debt if the reforms had not been introduced. They estimate that 73% of graduates will not repay their debt in full, compared to just 25% under the old system. What this means is that graduates will go into their forties and fifties with mounds of debt yet to overcome. In this age of credit where people buy before they earn, such debt is likely to have a hugely pernicious effect on people trying to get a mortgage for a house or take out a loan for a new car. Importantly, this doesn’t just impact on poorer graduates, who at any rate can have their debts wiped after only thirty years, but middle-class earners who have to face higher interest rates on the loans.

This government’s ramping-up off tuition fees, for all the talk of raising the quality of universities and saving the taxpayer money, has been an unmitigated failure. As the report states, the government ‘currently gets the worst of both worlds’- the government has been forced to continue funding the system to the same extent, but graduate indebtedness and insecurity will also rocket up. In the words of Rachel Wenstone, the NUS vice president for higher education and apparently one of the few sane voices in the Union, “Forcing debt on to students as a way of funding universities is an experiment that has well and truly failed. We need a new deal for higher education funding for the next generation of students.”

Photograph: Tom Page