The coalition has got its priorities wrong thus far
The coalition government was ‘elected’ at a critical point in time for Britain, with the debt-ridden economy in recession and the public demanding change. But how can we measure the success of the government so far?
The Conservative manifesto for 2010 provides us a good starting point- ‘A country is at its best when the bonds between people are strong and when the sense of national purpose is clear’, whilst the Liberal Democrats emphasised fairness in national life . Whether these bonds and more fairness should be inspired by Disraelian conservatism or a ‘big society’ is unclear, but the evidence is surely in the results, not the methods. The government’s success should be assessed according to meeting these objectives for which they, in a sense, received a democratic mandate.
Certainly the economy has improved in significant respects. Since a rollercoaster of growth and shrinkage in output, GDP growth has reached consistent growth – by New Year, it should reach 1.4% on a year ago. Inflation, which has been consistently above target since 2010, is finally falling back in line and the unemployment rate has shrunk to 7.6%, its lowest level for over three years. So the three key financial indicators imply a strengthening of the economy. The fiscal deficit, a crucial Conservative pledge, has reduced by a third – an underwhelming yet admirable reduction given the economic plight of Europe and America.
What are we to make of these figures? Most likely, the central bank’s monetary stimulus programme has been used offset the government’s austerity package – thus the government is succeeding to the extent that it is allowing growth to rise (albeit unnecessarily slowly) whilst it pushes the fiscal deficit down. Wage rates and productivity remain low, and need to resurge for the benefits to be fully felt, but this seems an inevitable consequence of growth.
Callous reference to economic data is insufficient in assessing government success, however – our cultural landscape is equally indicative thereof. Shamefully bidding to appease eurosceptics and xenophobes, the Conservatives are pledging an in-out referendum at a time when European unity is critical, and the government pledging to toughen immigration regulation to satisfy the ignorant voter.
On environment, Cameron pushes to roll back the green costs on energy, allegedly ordering aides to “get rid of all the green crap” right after the UN published a landmark report on the damages of climate change. Most importantly, in this writer’s opinion, the failure to guide the Arab Spring in a democratic direction has surfaced a weakness in the government to co-operate with foreign leaders in pursuing international interest; the failure to secure the future of Egyptian democracy and to hold the tyrant Al-Assad to account has signified a failure to further democracy at a most opportunistic time. Instead, the government has looked on carelessly as the civil wars in Egypt and Syria amass a bloody death toll. This is not at all irrelevant; our country’s success is surely determined by our actions (or inaction) both home and abroad.
The government has had its work cut out in restructuring a broken economy and a broken society. It still has a way to go in dealing with the causes of various scandals of the decade which have recently come to light – prison cells need still be filled with the bankers of the Libor scandal and the investigators of the hacking scandal. But the Liberal Democrats and Conservatives have complemented each other somewhat in the last three years in pursuing a culture of ‘responsible capitalism.’
The economy is still smaller than it was in 2008, and unemployment still too high, but the government is making headway and has given an admirable example of two ordinarily aggressively opposed parties pursuing bipartisanship to better Great Britain but the pledges of fairness and unity are far from being fulfilled. More pressure has to be placed on political leaders to drive public opinion – in immigration and foreign policy, particularly – rather than rigidly adhere to it. The Cameron-Clegg coalition have so far prioritised addressing the nation’s books over concerns abroad. It is time to realise that the two issues go hand in hand.
Photograph: Offices of Nick Clegg

