It is right that women have the option of an abortion?

By Francesca MollComment

The abortion debate is one I particularly hate because I feel that, amplified by rhetoric from certain parties, a delicate moral issue is handled with the sensitivity of an industrial sledgehammer. I particularly hate the terms ‘pro-life’ and ‘pro-choice’ as unrepresentative of the positions both parties stand for.

So I’d like to begin by stating a controversial position. I’m pro-life. I also believe a woman has the fundamental human right to choose in something that concerns her body, her economic prospects and which the weight of probability suggests she will have the biggest responsibility for.

Confused?  All I’m suggesting is that pretty much everybody who’s taking part in this debate is ‘pro-life.’ The difference is that one side places emphasis on the mother’s life and her right to personal bodily autonomy, the other on the potential life of the unborn child and its capacity to feel pain. Nobody here is advocating killing for the sake of killing.

This is why I find the anti-abortion lobby’s monopolisation of the term ‘pro-life’ particularly troubling, because to assign it to one side entirely really shuts down debate. It’s an unnecessarily morally loaded term: who’s going to say they’re anti-life?

Donald Spitz is a controversial Christian anti-abortion activist in the United States.
Donald Spitz, a controversial Christian anti-abortion activist in the United States

Feminist critics have pointed out, extremely astutely, I think, that to have the right to monopolise the term ‘pro-life’, you should support policies that are going to provide childcare, good education, and fair job prospects for that child. But a lot of people, particularly in the American context, who have moral objections to legal abortion also dislike welfare policies. To me, that sounds like forcing children into the world and then abrogating responsibility for them. That’s not pro-life. That’s just pro extra births.

Now, I don’t want to overstate the case here, because it’s not just underprivileged women who want abortions. Abortion is something that happens to middle-class women too, women who are married, older women who just don’t feel they are prepared for the emotional effort and financial investment of another child. Caitlin Moran’s chapter on the subject in How to Be a Woman is particularly valuable and thought-provoking in that it explodes many of the tired clichés of this debate.

I also would like to point out that on the other hand, while remaining firmly ‘pro-choice’, I do have some issues with arguments that minimize the value of human life. The idea that a life isn’t going to be worthwhile just  because it’s born into bad social conditions, taken to extremes, can make me a little queasy; how far is it from there to suggest that people born with severe health conditions cannot have a meaningful sort of existence?

But that really brings me on to the crux of my argument. Morally, I don’t like the thought of any potential life being prevented from happening.  I don’t think many people do. But when I picture the thought of an unplanned pregnancy happening to me or someone I know, especially now, when we’ve  got our entire lives ahead of us, all that I feel is unadulterated panic. Personally, I have no idea what I’d do in that situation.

when it comes down to it, I don’t think you can ever really know what you think about abortion until you experience it

When it comes down to it, I don’t think you can ever really know what you think about abortion until you experience it. And that’s another of my issues with the anti-abortion lobby. A lot of its vocal supporters are men, for whom this sort of thing is hardly a possibility. I just think there’s a massive issue with people whose lives are not going to be fundamentally shaped by this dictating policy.

You’ll notice that until now I’ve dodged around the actual question of whether abortion should be legal. That’s because, in a sense, I feel that it’s an entirely separate issue to whether abortion is moral or not. The sorts of debates I’ve outlined above are never going to have one unambiguously correct answer, just general ideas of what is more right than others.  And because we cannot deal in absolutes, it’s so important to leave each case to be judged on an individual, specific basis.  That is why keeping abortion legal, therefore leaving the decision to individuals, is so important, whatever side of the debate you stand on.

Photograph: Took Picture