Durham’s unacknowledged race problem

native american oldmantravels

By Francesca Moll

Recently I’ve seen a lot of things around campus which have convinced me of a disturbing reality which I feel is very important to discuss: the fact that Durham has a racism problem, especially when it comes to themed costumes and events.

In my time at university, I’ve seen people dressed as Mexicans, I’ve seen asianface, and I’ve even caught a glimpse of blackface. There is a real unwillingness to discuss the issues, and a lack of awareness that can seem deliberately put on at times.

I remember vividly explaining structural racism to one of the organisers of a problematic event and having him interrupt me to ask whether that meant fake tan (also part of the event) was racist. For the record, fake tan isn’t everyone’s cup of tea but it doesn’t spray on cultural insensitivity and privilege.

But what I’d really like to talk about is a culturally insensitive trend that I believe, from its widespread normalisation and frequency, is more a result of genuine lack of knowledge. This is non-Natives dressing up as Native Americans, and “Wild West” themes.

So what’s the issue? To be honest, it should be enough that Native people are telling us not to. Cherokee blogger and academic Dr Adrienne Keene’s excellent website, Native Appropriations (http://nativeappropriations.com), has no fewer than 8 pieces condemning Native American Halloween costumes.

I cannot recommend enough that everyone read them enough. She has the experience of living as a Native American which makes her comments much more relevant than mine.

However, I would like to take this opportunity to reiterate what Native people are saying in the hope that constant repetition will make it more likely to get through.

The first issue is that these costumes are an incredibly stereotyping, inaccurate representation of Native culture. Deejay NDN, of ground-breaking Canadian DJ act A Tribe Called Red, which challenges stereotyping by mixing First Nations traditional music with influences from EDM, hip hop and dubstep, sums up the issue well:

“It’s robbing the First Nations of their nationhoods and nationality. It’s making us all “Indian” instead of recognizing me as an Anishnabe or Ojibway. I’m NOT an “Indian”. I’m of the Anishnabe Nation.”

To put this in context, a generic ‘Indian’ costume is rather like having a generic ‘European’ one. Hundreds of Native cultures span the continent of North America, whose traditional economies vary from farming to fishing to hunting buffalo, whose social organisation could be loosely matriarchal or quasi-imperialistic, and whose traditional artwork and clothing varies immensely. By ignoring this, we ignore the sovereignty of individual Native nations.

The closest thing these costumes resemble is the traditional dress of the Lakota, the people of the plains who traditionally wore spectacular eagle feather war bonnets. But this actually makes these costumes more offensive, for war bonnets were only worn by those most respected in the tribe, and each feather had to be earned for a great deed.

This makes wearing a feather headdress, and one featuring multi-coloured plastic feathers at that, rather like wearing replica medals of a dead veteran made out of chocolate coins.

Behind the costumes’ stereotyping of a generic “Indian” identity and disrespect for their culture, I believe, is this idea that Native Americans no longer exist and can be safely reduced to a costume, entertainment, without consequences. This is particularly horrible as it denies the identity of 5.2 million people. To quote Deejay NDN again:

“[It] gives the impression that Natives are something from the past. Not here today. If you were to think of an “Indian” you certainly aren’t going to think of me, tattooed in a hoodie with a Sens cap on.”

Not only are Native Americans emphatically still here, many face terrible problems such as reservation poverty, alcoholism and domestic violence. The 400-year legacy of brutal and unjust treatment from the US government is considered something in the past and it is seldom discussed how this colonial attitude persists into the twentieth century and even up to the present day.

All of this basically makes dressing up in fake Native American garb quite as offensive as blackface, and yet it is still socially acceptable. I honestly think, or at least hope, that this is simply because many of us haven’t given much thought to the issues. Because when you think about it, the centuries of near genocide that Native people experienced are a pretty depressing thing to reference when you’re having fun.

I’m not naïve. Probably some people will still persist in doing racially problematic things after they have heard about the issues. As I have said, this isn’t unusual in Durham. But hopefully with more widespread knowledge about this issue we can separate the uninformed from the genuinely malicious and begin the harder task of challenging our wider racism problem.

Photograph: OldManTravels