Restrictive Spanish abortion bill: “authentic womanhood” or reinforcing patriarchy
By Francesca Moll
In Ireland, in Texas, in Ohio and now in Spain, the fight against women’s bodily autonomy continues. Why are we doing nothing about this here in England? In recent years, we have witnessed a wave of conservative anti-abortion laws worldwide.

At the moment in Spain a woman can have an abortion up to fourteen weeks without having to give a reason, a law enacted by the socialist government in 2010. But the Justice Minister, Alberto RuĂz GallardĂłn, has introduced new legislation which seeks to restrict abortion to cases of rape, risk to mental or physical health of the mother or serious foetal deformation.
All of these conditions are disturbingly vaguely worded – for example, the bill insists that foetal deformities must be “rare” or make the foetus unviable, terms that are open to a great deal of interpretation. Perhaps most distressingly of all, the new legislation would insist that rape victims report the crime to the police and potentially undergo a medical examination.
Even then abortion would only be permitted up to twelve weeks. These are clearly astoundingly insensitive conditions to impose on someone who has recently undergone a traumatic experience which they may not be ready to report to the police, or which could put them at risk if they did.
But why should we even care? Well, let’s just get this straight. Making sure women have access to safe, legal and easily accessible abortion is not the same debate as the moral rights and wrongs of the issue. The fact is abortion restriction does not prevent abortion happening. It just makes it unsafe.
Moreover, it is quite simply wrong for male-dominated organisations such as the Catholic Church or the Spanish government, who this legislation is never going to affect so personally, to impose their view of the issue on women already struggling to negotiate the moral minefield of an unwanted pregnancy. And it goes wider than the individual woman.
Forced births are the surest way to keep women as a group economically, socially and politically marginalised. Unwanted pregnancies force women to drop out of education, interrupt their careers and delay going back to work. Quite simply, women cannot achieve parity with men in the workplace or achieve their full potential unless they can control when they have children.
Another particularly disturbing facet of the debate around these new abortion laws is that GallardĂłn feels he is protecting “authentic womanhood” – that is, motherhood – with these laws. Ultimately the abortion law debate is deeply rooted in how the different sides of the debate envision the future for women’s status in their societies.
These laws are in no way supported by all elements of Spanish society. Gallardón is facing stiff opposition in the Spanish parliament from government figures such as Patricia Hernandez who accuses him of attempting to pass “a law against women, against the freedom of women”.
Increasingly the government is resorting to dubious tactics such as organising the first stage of approval for the bill 23 December so people would be too distracted by Christmas engagements to protest. These laws, if passed, would be tainted by undemocratic tactics on the part of government and threaten the human rights of half the Spanish population. And this is disturbingly close to home.
So why don’t we care more about it in England? Who knows, this could end up affecting us more than we imagine.  In England, it has recently come to light in an investigation by the Daily Telegraph that certain “Crisis Pregnancy Centres”, which advise women facing unwanted pregnancies, have been scaring women away from contemplating termination with unfounded myths such as it increasing the risk of cancer, making them infertile or even making them more likely to become child sex abusers.
This trend extends beyond Spain, and if we don’t take action soon, it’s likely it’ll only worsen. There’s an international campaign of solidarity with those protesting against the abortion laws in Spain, which has been gathering momentum across Scotland, Belgium and France. In England it’s called My Belly is Mine.
At the moment, Durham University Feminism Society is the only university feminism society associate itself with the campaign, but we’re working to get others on board. If this article has made you want to take action at all, please, look us up and get involved. This is important, and it’s something we should be getting angry about.
Photograph: Steve Rainwater on Flickr
