University responds to demands for radical change

By Tom Fenton10007459_783541558377375_5797449766145874078_n

The University has given a number of responses to proposals printed in the last edition of Palatinate.

The proposals, issued by Durham Students for University Reform, were made as the group described relations between the Vice-Chancellor and “numerous groups within the University community” as “deteriorating”.

The proposals and corresponding responses from the University are as follows:

 

Proposals 1 and 9:

 

Current consultations with students and staff to be extended throughout the year with a wider agenda concerning each stage of the Vice-Chancellor recruitment process and issues of University policy, facilities and governance.

The long- and short-lists of candidates to be made public in the current and all future Vice-Chancellor recruitment processes. Candidates present on the ballot paper to include submissions by both the Senate and the DSU, and to consist of 50% women.

Clare Curran, Director of Human Resources, told Palatinate: “Our Professional Search Consultancy Perrett Laver has advised that candidates now prefer confidentiality.

“It would not be normal to share the names of those who are long-listed.  However for short-listed candidates until we know who they are and we or Perrett Laver are able to discuss their application with them we won’t know how open they wish their candidature to be, we cannot confirm whether names will be released at this stage.

Regarding quotas for women on the lists, Curran replied: “Durham University prides itself on being a diverse international community which provides equality of opportunity for all.

“We aim to create an environment to maximise the benefit of our diverse community, enabling all staff and students to achieve their full potential and help us to attract and retain some of the most talented and motivated staff from around the world.

“We have committed to a gender balance for all recruitment processes.”

 

Proposal 10:

 

Direct elections by  all students and staff for the position of Vice-Chancellor. The position to have a fixed term before standing for re-election.

Curran told Palatinate: “Staff and students have been sharing their thoughts on the type of skills and expertise they feel are required for the role of Vice-Chancellor, at a series of consultation meetings.

“They were also asked to provide any names that they would like to be considered as part of the search.”

 

Proposal 2:

 

Have a target of a 2/3 state school intake of undergraduates.

Dr Michael Gilmore, Academic Registrar, told Palatinate: “Durham is a highly selecting institution, with demanding degree programmes and a high ratio of very qualified applicants per place.

“The University works hard to generate applications from students from under-represented groups who might not otherwise apply to us and to identify those with the greatest merit and potential amongst all our applicants.

“Durham has an access agreement with the Office for Fair Access (OFFA), an independent public body that helps safeguard and promote fair access to higher education. Through the agreement we commit to a range of fair access activity such as the Supported Progression Scheme and the Sutton Trust summer school, which encourage applications from under-represented groups.

“The proportion of state school entrants in 2013 increased by 4.2% on the previous year, and the fair access activity contributed significantly to this improvement.”

 

Proposal 3:

 

Fix international and postgraduate student tuition fees.

Professor Tim Clark, Dean and Deputy to the Pro-Vice-Chancellor (Education) told Palatinate: “The University’s Scholarship, Fees and Awards Advisory Group will be meeting for the first time this academic year in November; the issue of fixed fees for international students will be discussed then.

“The President of the Students’ Union will represent the student viewpoint at this meeting.

“Any recommendations arising from the meeting will be presented to the University’s Executive Committee for consideration.”

 

Proposal 4:

 

Pay all Durham University staff at least the Living Wage.

An anonymous University spokesperson would only tell Palatinate: “The University has agreed to review its position on the living wage, taking into account the range of benefits available to our staff.”

Proposal 5:

 

“University-wide commitment to cultural change regarding rape, sexual abuse, assault and harassment accommponed with a policy with clear sanctions for perpetrators, centralised systems for reporting, pastoral care and support for victim-survivors, and training for staff to support and empower victim-survivors.”

Sam Dale, Deputy Academic Registrar at Durham University said: “We have a matrix model of support across the University bringing together staff from the Colleges and central teams who are able to support students with a full range of issues in a compassionate way.

“Staff receive internal and external training and the support network they provide is easily accessible and well communicated to students.

“The University takes all reported incidents very seriously. We deal with extremely sensitive and difficult issues in relation to sexual assault and there are a range of policies in place to ensure these are managed carefully.

“Many of these cases require partnership working with external agencies such as the police.

“Our counsellors are highly qualified and provide effective support for survivors of sexual abuse.

“In addition to this, the counselling team bring in external specialised counsellors on weekly bases who can provide long term therapy for those directly affected by sexual abuse or by the abuse of those close to them.”

 

Proposal 6:

 

The cancellation of the University’s G4S contract due to its track record of human rights violations in its global operations, “including in Palestine, South Africa and Guantanamo Bay.”

An anonymous University spokesperson told Palatinate: “G4S is contracted to provide the University’s access control system.

“This contract has been in place for a number of years and will be tendered in 2015. We will take environmental, social and ethical considerations into account when we let the new contract.”

 

Proposal 7:

 

“Durham University to divest from fossil fuel companies”

Professor Ray Hudson, Acting Vice-Chancellor at Durham University said: “Durham University is committed to reducing its environmental impact and improving the local environment.

“We have no plans to withdraw from investing in or engaging in research financed by fossil fuel companies.

“The issue of carbon emissions is hugely complex and significant for the future of our planet, but we recognise that there are no viable alternatives to fossil fuels yet available at the scale required for the predominant forms of current energy use, i.e. heat and transport.

“In addition, fossil fuels underpin modern food production methods, through the use of fertilisers, and the chemical and process industries which produce a vast array of plastic and pharmaceutical products.

“We will continue to engage with the fossil fuel and other industries in carrying out research on alternative, sustainable geoenergy resources such as geothermal and CCS.”

 

Proposal 8:

 

Improve engagement with residents.

Professor Graham Towl, Pro-Vice-Chancellor and Deputy Warden said: “Durham University convened a meeting over the summer with other universities and the National Organisation of Residents Associations to address some of the national issues.

“Additionally there is a regular attendance at the Durham City Liaison Group.

“Thirdly, just the other week there was a productive and constructive meeting held at the University with representatives from local residents groups.

“Another such meeting will be in diaries for this side of Christmas. Throughout these meetings we have very much appreciated the level of student engagement in partnership with our excellent Students’ Union.”

 

Executive members from University College Feminists, which signed the document, criticised the Universiy’s response: “The University may have a support network to deal with sexual assault, but there is a lack of awareness of its existence within the student body.

“Also, it appears that the University is concerned with dealing with the effects of assault as opposed to its prevention.

“Furthermore, how do they propose to deal with incidents that go unreported and victim-survivors who don’t actively seek help which is the vast majority?”

Students from It Happens Here Durham, which also signed the document, agreed. One student, Elizabete Smildzena, told Palatinate: “All of these  efforts focus on the aftermath, there is no focus on prevention.

“Although some victims-survivors have had a good experience, many victim-survivors tell us support they received was absent or inadequate, so currently its a college lottery- specific response to disclosure training needs to be given to all staff, in departments and colleges.

“Because of this, we need a specific sexual violence policy that recognises the specific nature and causes of sexual violence, with a strong commitment to cultural change and eliminating rape culture and victim blaming.

“We hope to work collaboratively with the University to share skills and improve the outcomes.”

Joseph Male from People and Planet,  which signed the document, was also critical of the University’s response. He told Palatinate: “The idea that carbon emissions is hugely complex is a fallacy. Carbon dioxide produced by burning fossil fuels results in the heating of the atmosphere.

“A rise of more than 2˚C in global temperatures is enough to put the world beyond the acceptable limits as outlined by scientists. Fossil fuel companies already have proven reserves of five times the amount needed to take us past this limit.

“The current share price in the fossil fuel industry is based on the idea that all the reserves held by fossil fuel companies will be burnt.

“This situation is of course not viable given the severely detrimental impact it will have on the environment.

“This disparity between the safely useable reserves and the proven reserves results in fossil fuel companies being not as safe a long-term investment as they are held up to be.

“The suggestion that there are no viable alternatives will remain a self-fulfilling prophecy until the money that is needed to develop these alternatives is invested in them.

“The growth of the divestment movement globally shows that increasing numbers of investors, including Glasgow University, are taking the moral imperative to act on climate change.

“Given the inviability of fossil fuels as an investment strategy and with the scientific facts stacked against them, does it not make sense for any forward-thinking institution to divest?”

Harry Cross and Sofia Hewson, Co-chairs of Durham Students for University Reform, said in a statement to Palatinate: “We are glad the University has been willing to respond to some of the issues raised.

“There is a clear willingness to consider the University’s policies on several issues (Living Wage, international student fees and contracts with G4S) which is largely the result of sustained campaigns by student groups and trade unions.

“We strongly hope that this translates into concrete policy changes.

“Like many of those supporting our project, we feel that the deeper underlying issues we wished to highlight have not been addressed.

“There is no openness to structural reform of the University’s governing bodies and an unwillingness to give students, staff or workers a say.

“The extent to which staff and students have been consulted in the Vice-Chancellor’s recruitment process has been limited and the University has not responded to these criticisms.

“Residents and maintenance staff were not consulted at all (except through trade unions).

“These issues can be resolved by wider consultation between the University and these groups as well as effective, coordinated campaigning by these groups.”

The pair also told Palatinate they were pleased with the response: “We have had an overwhelmingly positive response to our proposals published in the Palatinate.

“Our petition was successfully launched, new clubs signed up and both our e-mails and that of the Palatinate have been flooded with messages of support from students and staff.

“With the aim of opening a wider discussion around the proposals, JCR, MCR and SCR Presidents as well as college principals were forwarded individual copies of the proposals.

“This was particularly fruitful in yielding messages of support. At this point, some individuals do not feel comfortable publicly associating themselves with the campaign.

“This is the regrettable legacy of the toxic working environment created under the previous Vice-Chancellor in which individuals are afraid to publicly criticise the University’s management.

“We are prepared for a sustained positive campaign lasting into next year when the new Vice-Chancellor will be pressured to support democratic and ethical reforms of the University as proposed by our campaign.

“We therefore encourage all those who identify with the proposals to contact us and find out how they can support our campaign.”

The group’s Facebook page has garnered – on the day of print – 56 likes, although many are executive members of the organisation.

Its Change.org petition page has 91 signatories.

 

Photograph: Durham Students for University Reform