County Hospital student housing development suffers setback

countyhospital_cut

By Tom Fenton

Durham University has objected to multi-million pound plans to transform a former mental hospital into student accommodation.

The ÂŁ17 million scheme, which would provide housing for an estimated 440 students in the former County Hospital, off North Road, Durham City, has also come under fire from local residents.

However, Harvey Dowdy, Deputy Director of Estates and Buildings told Palatinate: “The University supports the principle of using the long-neglected site for purpose-built accommodation, provided that it is of the appropriate quality with sufficient space and is to be managed in such a way that it minimises any disruption to other residents.

“The University opposes the development in its current form because the proposals do not provide sufficient social space or social learning space, nor are there any gym or music practice facilities.

“Moreover, the room sizes are too small and the plans show just one common room, which we do not feel to be sufficient for the scale of the proposed development.”

In a letter to Durham County Council seen by Palatinate, Mrs Dowdy also added: “For the avoidance of doubt, the University is able to confirm that we do not intend to take any space within the development either by way of a lease or by Nominations Agreement.

“We…oppose the development in its current form.”

Crossgate Community Partnership (CCP) has also filed an eleven-page objection to the plans.

The charity, whose objectives are “to promote the conservation and improvement of the physical and natural environment of Crossgate” and “build and maintain a strong, safe, healthy, and balanced community”, have asked that planning permission “be refused”.

CCP has given Stuart Timmiss, Durham County Council’s head of planning, ten reasons to refuse planning permission, including that the area is “already overloaded by private landlords profiting from the student market” and that the proposed development would be “ugly and overbearing”.

CCP are concerned about the environmental impact, stating that the development would result in the “removal of or damage to at least 50% of the mature trees on the site”.

They further stress: “No further student accommodation should be approved for this area”.

The City of Durham Trust has also condemned the scheme, stating that it would add to the “ghetto-isation” of the area and called on the council to reconsider both it and another £20 million plan at the former New College Durham site, in Neville’s Cross, which will create housing for another 400 students.

One household, in a letter seen by the paper, complained: “The developer has signally failed to take into account…the needs and wishes of local residents”.

Another wrote in a letter to the Durham County Council Planning Development that the plan for a seven-storey modern block was “distressing” and “contravenes the City of Durham Plan Saved Policy H 13 which does not permit new development which will have a significant adverse effect on the character and appearance of residential areas or the amenities to of residents within them”.

She said: “Residents would welcome a development of the former County Hospital site which encourages a broader local economy and provides desperately needed residential housing for couples, families, the elderly, which restores balance to our community, and adds sympathetic buildings of charm and character, creditable to the prominence of the site and its closeness to the Viaduct and to the World Heritage core.

“The new buildings should in no way reflect badly on the original handsome former hospital building nor dwarf the small-scale nature of the surrounding streets.”

In addition, the resident wrote: “The saturation of student accommodation has created a mono-culture affecting the economy of the area.

“In the summer the area becomes a ghost town and the local economy is even more severely affected. Many small enterprises cannot survive.

“This is contrary to the emerging County Durham Local Plan which seeks to address the problem of balanced communities.”

Sandra Mason, director of Signet Planning, acting as planning advisor for the project, said: “The design team are reviewing the detailed comments now provided by the university in regards to the accommodation and it is likely that amendments to address these, where possible, will be submitted to the [council], prior to the application being determined”.

It has been estimated that work on the building, which is not listed but is located within the Durham conservation area, would take eighteen months to complete and create around 177 full-time jobs.

The 1850s-built main building, which housed inpatient services for the Tees, Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust until the completion of the purpose-built ÂŁ17.9 million Lanchester Road Hospital in January 2010, would be turned into 47 en-suite studios.

A new block in what is currently an internal courtyard would include 26 studios and a seven-level structure would see 367 bedrooms and a student hub built. The site, designed predominantly for postgraduate students, would be staffed 24 hours a day.

A final decision is expected within months.

Photograph Courtesy of the Durham Times