The United States of America vs DOGE
By Zara Hossain
The ‘Muskovites,’ all under 26 and with an unwavering loyalty to Elon Musk, have had access to the treasury’s federal payment system, including access to USAID’s expenses. USAID is the biggest aid provider in the world, providing food, medical care, and infrastructure programs around the world which aid development and poverty reduction. USAID also provides aid for resilience building against climate
change, which is reliant on state assistance. Over 100 countries are the recipients of aid from the United States. The US spends $40bn a year on foreign aid, less than 1% of its federal budget.
The shutdown has led to thousands of layoffs globally and chaos at the USAID headquarters as DOGE took control of the scene. The move actively undermined the US labour force and deprived people around the world of life-saving aid. Hires and contractors have been left without support overseas, their lives put at risk by this hasty decision. USAID staffers in Congo received no support in leaving zones of conflict and have consequently filed a lawsuit for violating the US constitution. DOGE illegally accessed USAID emails and communications, with employees citing that they were locked out of their accounts. This will send shockwaves to humanitarian crisis responses across the world – US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said staff were insubordinate which stopped them from carrying out a review of programs, but state they received confusing instructions from DOGE and had little time to adjust to circumstances. The shutdown of USAID has been riddled with unsubstantiated claims about the organisation, such as accusations of fraud, migrants in luxury hotels, money laundering, transgender mice, condom exports to Gaza and anti-DOGE protests funded by NGOs. Elon Musk has called USAID a ‘criminal organisation’. President Trump has asserted it is a waste of taxpayer money, and that it is an organisation run by ‘radical left lunatics’. This has led to a worrying increase in conspiracy theories and misinformation around the issue – this presents a worrying precedent for the future of information and the rhetoric is spread about groups such as migrants and trans people, fostering further polarisation.
This presents a worrying precedent for the future of information and the rhetoric is spread about groups such as migrants and trans people, fostering further polarisation
Despite the shut-down, the Foreign Assistance Act (1961) prevents Mr Trump from abolishing the institution altogether without challenge from Congress. A federal judge ordered the freeze of Mr Trump’s plan and temporarily restored funding of USAID and conducted a review of which programs should be kept after the chaos that ensued among staff domestically and abroad. Fourteen states and anonymous USAID employees are already suing Mr Trump for DOGE’s unconstitutional overreach of power over the Executive Branch. They argue that Mr Trump has violated the Appointments Clause and the separation of powers in the US Constitution. The appointment clause gives the president power to appoint federal officers with the Senate’s consent. A lack of appointment, authorisation from Congress or clearly defined duties enshrined in law has led to domestic outrage over DOGE’s unfettered power and comically villainous pursuits with the billionaire being dubbed an ‘agent of chaos’. Though USAID could certainly use reform, the idea that it should be banned altogether or that it is criminal or fraudulent is far from the truth, and DOGE’s unrestrained power signals a dangerous descent into tyranny at the hands of unelected individuals.
The withdrawal of aid will have drastic consequences on international stability. Mr Trump’s bold hard power approach to pursue an ‘America First policy’ and the upheaval of the state department sets a worrying precedent for the future of diplomacy as American citizens seem to be facing the brunt of the negative consequences of Mr Trump’s executive orders. The organisation was a key vessel to exert soft power around the world and contribute to global stability and development. USAID is not the only agency affected with The Department of Education, Centre of Medicare and Medicaid, and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau also on the chopping board. Whether or not we are witnessing the end of US hegemony is only a matter of time.
Image credit: Airman 1st Class Nicholas Byers via Wikimedia Commons

