US pauses planned Mexico tariffs

By Rory McAlpine

The announcement of a month-long reprieve from President Trump’s planned tariffs marks an unexpected softening of tensions between the US and Mexico, whose relationship since Trump’s inauguration has been characterised by fiery and aggressive rhetoric. President Trump had previously expressed his intention to impose 25% tariffs on all Mexican imports entering the US in response to Mexico’s failure to stem illegal migration and the cross-border drug trade. Justifying the policy, Mr Trump claimed that the Mexican government had an ‘intolerable alliance’ with drug gangs which was allowing the continued trafficking of ‘poisonous fentanyl’ and other drugs over the US border.

These remarks drew condemnation and a strong rebuttal from Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum, who decried President Trumps remarks as ‘slanderous’ and highlighted her recently elected government’s record of seizing 20 million doses of fentanyl, and detaining over 10,000 people tied to drug trafficking. She went on to warn “problems are not solved by imposing tariffs, but by talking,” seen as an appeal for the US to come to the negotiating table. Despite a request for dialogue President Sheinbaum vowed that Mexico would respond if the tariffs were implemented and instructed her own government to draw up ‘Plan B’, a set of tariffs and other retaliatory measures against the US.

Both the US and Mexico play vital roles in each other’s respective economies. Up to a third of Mexico’s gross domestic product is dependent on exporting to the US, while Mexico is the leading foreign market for US exports. Their status as key trading partners meant the threat of an escalating trade war spooked markets who recorded sharp drops in the wake of the announced tariffs and in response to Mexico’s reaction.

Both the US and Mexico play vital roles in each other’s respective economies. Up to a third of Mexico’s gross domestic product is dependent on exporting to the US, while Mexico is the leading foreign market for US exports

However, the threat of further escalation abruptly abated after a phone call between the leaders of the two countries saw them negotiate a one-month delay to the implementation of Mr Trump’s planned tariffs. In a marked change of tone, the conversation, which was described as ‘very respectful’ by Ms Sheinbaum and ‘very friendly’ by Mr Trump, saw both countries pledge to direct greater resources to securing their shared border. This includes 10,000 members of Mexico’s National Guard being deployed to the border to combat drug smuggling and the US to increase efforts to prevent weapons crossing into Mexico. Ms Sheinbaum had previously argued that many cartels received weaponry- such as rocket launchers- that crossed the border from the US. Both countries also expressed a commitment to continue negotiations to work towards a deal that could shelve the threat of tariffs entirely.

In a press conference President Sheinbaum revealed that when Mr Trump asked her during the phone call how long the tariffs should be paused for, she replied: forever. However, she affirmed she viewed the one-month pause as a good deal. This anecdote, although delivered as a joke, highlights the reality that the threat of tariffs has only been delayed not removed. So how likely is Mr Trump to implement tariffs in a month’s time?

Some view Presidents Trump’s tariffs as a ‘sabre-rattling’ tactic designed to encourage Mexico to commit to greater measures to protect the US border. Such action by Mexico would allow Mr Trump to demonstrate his commitment to delivering on his key campaign pledge: to secure the border. As such with Mexico ready to collaborate the tariffs are unlikely to be implemented even when the pause expires. Instead, they may be indefinitely delayed or rescinded.

However, the last few days has demonstrated how quickly Mr Trump’s views towards Mexico can change. Although progress has been made his earlier comments show that the border remains a focal point of President Trumps agenda, and he sees Mexico as primarily the responsible party for allowing drugs and illegal immigrants to cross it. If he views Mexico as not sufficiently cooperative or deems their actions inadequate, he could choose to impose the tariffs.

Ultimately this pause represents a momentary reprieve for Mexico and will allow potential solutions to be explored. However, the threat of tariffs could potentially continue to hang over Mexico if President Trump seeks to use it as a ‘hard bargain’ negotiation tactic to combat what he sees as Mexico’s failure to act over the border issue.

Image credit: WikimediaCommons/EneasMx