Better Dead than Green: Are we doomed? 

By Zara Hossain 

It is inauguration day. Trump signs an executive order leaving the long-standing Paris Agreement in the same week that the California Wildfires continue to rage on. Snowstorms in the east get worse and worse. The Willow oil drilling project cements America’s place as the global superpower, but the hurricanes get worse. The sea keeps rising. The floods get worse. Countries still attend UNFCCC meetings but to no avail. Tensions over migration begin to put states on edge. Animals go extinct. Plants die. The IPCC releases its next report, urging countries to take action before it’s too late. Insurance companies make more money from the fallout. Where do we go from here?

The California wildfires have brought attention to a dangerous trend of environmental turmoil. From the heavy snow in Texas to floods in Pakistan increased hurricanes and desertification at the Equator, no one seems to be paying attention. In the political sphere, IPCC goals and COP meetings continue to be fruitless, with states prioritising national economic growth and security interests. Climate policies are fundamentally unenforceable, so it is entirely in the state’s goodwill to be willing to contribute to saving the planet from irreversible, impending disaster. The historical North-South divide makes states more reluctant towards cooperation to fix a problem to which they did not necessarily contribute significantly. The US departure from the Paris Agreement has brought back a worrying precedent of climate inaction – if one of the biggest emitters in the world doesn’t feel the need to care, why should other countries? Some might point to climate measures that work within the free market framework, like carbon credits, and green technology. Regardless of how these solutions would work in theory, it is simply not fast enough. The complexities of climate change are more than enough for the average person to avert their gaze from the issue – the environment, agriculture, infrastructure, migration, food security, geo-political tensions, national security, and the list goes on.  

The complexities of climate change are more than enough for the average person to avert their gaze from the issue – the environment, agriculture, infrastructure, migration, food security, geo-political tensions, national security, and the list goes on

Here in the UK, we often roll our eyes when we see headlines of Just Stop Oil or Extinction Rebellion pulling media stunts like throwing soup on a painting. ‘They shouldn’t be inconveniencing the average person,’ I often hear people say. I agree with this sentiment; they should be. But they do. They regularly protest outside the HQs of oil companies and lobby against the legislation, but these headlines don’t evoke the anger of inconvenience that gets people to turn against the climate movement. And is a protest even a protest if it’s not disruptive? Considering the state of UK climate policy, are they wrong in demanding more urgent change?

 The UK’s 2050 net zero goals and 68% emissions reduction goals by 2030 are nowhere near achieved – there are no credible plans in place to meet these goals, and the government sends inconsistent messaging on climate change. Storm Eowyn, Darragh, Bert and Ashley in the last year alone have highlighted the urgency of dealing with the fallout of climate change-related natural disasters. Every year we see a headline containing the phrase ‘record temperatures’ during summer, alongside deaths related to fires and heat exhaustion constantly rising. While the situation grows more dire, the population is rightfully more concerned about the immediate issues affecting their living standards, like inflation or housing. Without a human face to climate change, and right-wing populist sentiment diluting green initiating, Adam McKay’s 2021 allegorical film ‘Don’t Look Up’ has ironically fallen victim to the very message it tried to portray – like most movies that seem to have a poignant message, we simply consume and move on, with little evidence of anything having changed since the film was released. 

There’s an elephant in the room which we need to address – our relationship with the environment is fundamentally exploitative and requires a complete overhaul

There’s an elephant in the room which we need to address – our relationship with the environment is fundamentally exploitative and requires a complete overhaul. It is not in the interest of countries and corporations to adopt climate measures, because the exploitation of the environment is what has accumulated all the wealth we own today. While I myself am guilty of buying clothes and ordering goods from ethically questionable sites as much as the next person, we must ask ourselves more critically; “how can I be a better steward?” We will never get to see the extent of exploitation which is behind our everyday purchases. But what we can do is be more aware of what we consume and where it comes from, prioritising the earth’s future over profit. This is just one of the paths that humanity can take. Whether or not we’re doomed is simply a matter of time.

Image credit: California Incident Management Team

https://www.justgiving.com/campaign/palatinate?utm_campaign=lc_frp_share_transaction_charity_coaching_--_page_launched_--_campaign&utm_content=463e110f-8393-4efd-8337-cb4bdccc2a99&utm_medium=email&utm_source=postoffice&utm_term=1698322587440