Taiwan and Ukraine: thank God for the bomb
By Max Malone
The speaker for the US house of representatives, Nancy Pelosi has recently visited Taiwan for the protestation and sabre-rattling of the Beijing government. However, this is pure theatre; there will be no hot war, no international crisis, nothing more than flavour of the month talking points in the persistent hostile relationship between China, Taiwan, and the United States. Safety is assured under the threat of the Mushroom Cloud.
Any invasion from the mainland would provoke a naval battle of a scale unseen since the Second World War
For those who are unaware, the Communist government of mainland China and the Democratic government ruling in Taiwan have been in a stand-off since the end of the civil war in 1949. Both have historically maintained that they are the one and only legitimate government of China. While there have been times of conciliation, some in Taiwan wishing to abandon the mantle of Chinese leadership entirely, the relationship between the two is based on the lingering enmity of war and a desire to become the sole government of all China at the other’s expense.
Consistently, whenever a foreign leader diplomatically visits Taiwan, Beijing sees this as an insult to its legitimacy and responds dramatically. As you would imagine, the more senior the visitor the greater the stink made.
For the past half century, the Communists have been restricted from crushing the weaker, poorer, and less numerous nationalists by the seventh fleet of the US Navy. The American government has a long-standing policy of guaranteeing the independence of Taiwan. Any invasion from the mainland would provoke a naval battle of a scale unseen since the Second World War between two nuclear powers, inevitably resulting in an apocalypse.
Returning to the threats that prompted this article, upon the death of the American President, an attack on the second successor would assure an American response. Even with ‘most Americans’ unconcerned with East Asian affairs and struggling to find Taiwan on a map, the international image of America is based on keeping its people safe abroad. Any action against someone as important as Pelosi would tie the hands of the President, leading to the aforesaid naval battle and its atomic consequences.
This threat of mutual destruction is what keeps the peace, as the Cold War logic goes: ‘The Chinese love their children too’. The consistent pattern of conflict is that one side antagonises the other, the antagonised blusters, tests missiles, moves their soldiers, and yet nothing really changes. In Russian, there is even a phrase for this: a ‘Chinese warning.’ Based on Beijing’s habit of issuing hollow final warnings to the Americans over their interaction in Taiwan, this phrase indicates consequences that will never come.
Compare Taiwan to Ukraine: a nation caught in a rain of violence due to the lack of a ‘Nuclear Umbrella.’ Ukraine is also facing a belligerent neighbour wishing to wipe it from the map, but lacks the security America guarantees. Ultimately, what determines a heated international dispute or fire of war is nuclear weapons. This is something known to Russia, Ukraine, and Mainland China. Beijing pursued nuclear weapons after fighting America in the Korean war, narrowly avoiding atomic bombing in that conflict, using nuclear arms to deter direct violence ever since. Ukraine became one of the few nations to give up nuclear weapons after signing a treaty at the collapse of the USSR, transferring nuclear missiles to Russia in exchange for the promise that Russia would respect Ukraine’s borders.
The recent actions of Russia and China are worrying
The irony of that final sentence aside, the difference between Beijing and Moscow is the likelihood of their aggression, quite literally, blowing up in their face. Both authoritarian regimes share a hypocritical anti-Western high horse and an absence of respect for the territorial integrity of their neighbours. However, only China’s targets are directly guaranteed by nuclear weapons. Thus, Taiwan is at peace and Ukraine is not.
Nonetheless, the recent actions of Russia and China are worrying. Powerful players on the world’s stage flirting with violent expansion casts shadows over our current world order; an order with the founding assumption that states’ borders shall not be changed through force.
Ultimately, in a dangerous world besieged by bad neighbours, peace can only be kept through strength. So, thank god for the atomic bomb, saving millions of lives by being able to end them in an instant.
Image: United States Air Force via Wikimedia Commons

