Is it time to scrap the League Cup?
By Rob White
The start of the Carabao Cup this season tells a simple story: the competition is no longer taken seriously. Of the first-round fixtures that took place recently, teams made an average of around 6.5 changes from their previous starting XI, reinforcing the notion of the competition being a ‘Mickey Mouse’ cup.
Most changes were made by Championship clubs with an average of 8.33 changes, then League One sides with an average of 6.17 alterations, followed by League Two teams at 5.42. This led to twelve Championship clubs being beaten by lower league sides in the recent round of fixtures. Yet there is little concern about no longer being in the competition from many of those clubs eliminated.
In reality, the cup has suffered from a lack of interest for some time. The question arises, what should be done with the League Cup?
There are some arguments for keeping the competition. The revenue it provides for smaller clubs and the chance it gives them to potentially play at Wembley and qualify for European football are all positives from the EFL Cup. There have been some success stories from outside the “big six” in this regard, with Birmingham and Swansea winning the trophy in 2011 and 2013 respectively.
As well as this, the tournament also provides an opportunity for managers of big sides to give young players experience in competitive senior football, with the likes of Trent Alexander-Arnold and Harvey Elliott both having made their debuts in the competition.
Yet it is precisely these changes which give the League Cup a poor reputation. The chopping and changing of the starting XI of most sides belittles the tournament, giving it the devalued reputation it currently holds.
In reality, the cup has suffered from a lack of interest for some time
There are options to combat this. For instance, the creation of a maximum alteration rule, which has been used in the EFL Trophy in the past, can force teams to limit the number of changes they make from their previous game. However, this move would appear forced in its attempt to return status to the League Cup, rather than the tournament being more respected in its own right. Indeed, it is unlikely that there would be a huge addition of fans coming out to watch their team even if this rule were to come into play.
The reality is that the number of fans of smaller teams who are devastated by their club’s elimination from the tournament is minimal, especially when considering that the competition has been won by one of the “big six” on the last nine occasions.
Whilst it has been a similar story with the recent winners of the FA Cup, the League Cup does not have the same history as the FA Cup. The latter is the oldest existing football competition in the world and the tournament being open to non-league sides as well means there are more opportunities for fairy-tale cup runs and giant killings. The absence of this sense of tradition with the League Cup proves it to be a drastically inferior cup competition.
The prospect of European football, with the winners qualifying for the European Conference League, should be considered something special. However with the lack of lower league sides having success in the tournament, this prize is often seen as a burden. The extra games on a Thursday night and the negative effect this could have on league form mean that the reward of playing in Europe is underappreciated by many due to fixture congestion.
It is also the fixture congestion coming from the Carabao Cup itself that is another key factor making a third major domestic tournament unjustifiable. Most of the major European leagues no longer have a league cup because of the lack of interest and the saturation of fixtures, which gives them an advantage both for club and country, due to less injuries and fewer tired bodies.
The reward of playing in Europe is underappreciated by many due to fixture congestion
Indeed, this argument of congestion was used in September 2019 by the Ligue de Football Professionnel, the governing body of French professional football, when it decided to scrap the Coupe de la Ligue, the French equivalent of the League Cup.
The competition had been open to teams from the top three divisions of French football, but to reduce fixture congestion, the LFP voted to suspend the tournament indefinitely and continue with just one domestic cup competition, the Coupe de France. This proposal allows for a decision to be made, taking into account fan and club reaction to multiple seasons without the tournament, whether that decision is ultimately to scrap the competition or to reintroduce it.
A similar move could work well in England. If approved, it would not close the door permanently on the competition and it would allow for an analysis of how domestic football fairs without a second cup competition. With struggling attendances for games, unwanted injuries and a chance to aid the national team and rejuvenate the FA Cup, this approach is the best way to address the increasingly redundant League Cup.
Image: Joe Harston

