Sanctioning North Korea is the best bad solution

By Max Malone

North Korea has spent most of its history under sanctions. From the 1950s the USA and South Korea limited their economic engagement with North Korea. Much others followed in the aftermath of North Korean acts of belligerence in the 1980s, such as the Rangoon and Flight 858 bombings. While sanctions loosened briefly in the 1990s, the nuclear escalation since 2006 has brought them to their most severe.

The United Nations currently prohibits its members from buying North Korean textiles and minerals vital to its economy, and bans the sale of fuel, weapons, luxury goods and any material that could be used in weapons development to North Korea as well as all money transfers in and out of the country. These are some of the most extensive sanctions the UN have ever applied.

However, this doesn’t mean they are working. On the contrary, if the point of the sanctions was to stop North Korean development of nuclear weapons and deter them from using their intelligence services to murder people abroad then they have failed. Pyongyang has successfully tested long range nuclear missiles and has not stopped trying to assassinate high profile defectors, including Kim Jong-Un’s half-brother in 2017.

The ineffectiveness of sanctions poses two questions: firstly why are they not working and secondly is there a better way to restrict North Korea?

In order for sanctions to work they must put pressure on the elites of the state to act differently. This is not currently happening. Sanctions are broken with complex smuggling and through non-enforcement agreements with China and Russia. Foreign currency keeps flowing into the country to fund the nuclear program. This is acquired through the international black market.

High quality crystal meth, fake US dollars, sophisticated cybercrimes and North Korean slave labourers are prime sources of hard currency. These are shipped abroad through multiple front companies and their embassies throughout Asia. North Korean slave labourers have been found as far away as Poland showing the breadth of the operation keeping money flowing back to Pyongyang.

Attempts to entice Kim Jong-Un to end his nuclear program through negotiations have been unfruitful

In cases where sanctions have successfully brought about domestic change, such as Apartheid South Africa, the sanctioned state has to be cut off from the global economy by all states with whom it could trade or use as smuggling conduits. This is not happening to North Korea. Its hackers can still rob the world, it can still sneak goods out through China or swap ships in international waters and most importantly China still is unconcerned with properly enforcingsanctionstoblocktrade. In short, the cash still flows and North Korea is not cut off.

The most challenging thing is that there is no better solution than sanctions. Military means would be foolhardy. China would block any direct use of force at the UN security council, and with nuclear weapons and other WMDs in the picture it would be a particularly bloody fool’s errand.

Attempts to entice Kim Jong-Un to end his nuclear program through negotiations have been unfruitful. Historically, such diplomacy has involved a slight loosening of sanctions and lowering of tensions until, like clockwork, another nuclear test is discovered and talks collapse, only to be revived when it is time for the cycle to repeat itself.

Given that negotiation alone goes nowhere and force is a non- option, sanctions are the only way to drive the regime to negotiate in good faith to denuclearise and stop their clandestine murders abroad. Sanctions have delayed nuclear developments within the country and have caused the regime enough trouble to make them consider negotiations, even in bad faith. Yet such restrictions themselves are undermined by the parallel interests of the states that have to enforce them.

Ultimately North Korea will not give up nuclear weapons as they guarantee the Kim family’s security and the international community will not dare invade a nuclear-armed state. The regime will hold on so long as the economy holds up and the economy will hold up until China makes the decision to properly enforce sanctions.

Image: US Department of State via Wikimedia Commons

Support Palatinate