Germany’s new government: a progressive era begins

By Joe Rossiter

Olaf Scholz became Germany’s chancellor last month after his SPD brokered a coalition agreement with the Greens and the liberal FDP. After Angela Merkel’s 16-year premiership, the accession of her former deputy could be taken as the endurance of her defining gradualism, yet Scholz will surely lead Germany’s most progressive government in a generation.

As journalist Jeremy Cliffe points out, the title of the coalition deal, Mehr Fortschritt wagen, “dare more progress”, is a clear echo of Willy Brandt’s Mehr Demokratie wagen, “dare more democracy”. Brandt’s government of the early 1970s greatly extended civil liberties and boosted democratic participation, as well as strengthening the welfare state; the coalition deal agreed last week promises to match the ambition of Scholz’s SPD predecessor.

The new government’s headline policies herald a social transformation in Germany after the Merkel-era caution with regard to proactive governance. This tone has been set from the top, with the Greens’ former chancellor candidate Annalena Baerbock becoming the country’s first female foreign minister; she is joined in government by the first federal minister of Turkish descent, Cem Özdemir, the son of guest workers from Turkey.

Scholz will surely lead Germany’s most progressive government in a generation

In terms of policy, the new government plans to legalise cannabis, lower the voting age to 16 and will abolish a piece of legislation from the Nazi era which makes it illegal to ‘advertise’ abortion services. The law on gay men giving blood will be liberalised and it will be easier for trans individuals to have their accurate gender reflected on government documents. This is a marked shift from Merkel’s conservative instincts: where she preferred to lead from the back, allowing public opinion to consolidate before acting, it looks as though Scholz’s government will spearhead reform.

Continuing this ambition, the coalition plans to significantly loosen citizenship requirements. Where Germanness was almost solely inherited, it will now be possible after just three years of residence in some cases.

Environment policy looks to be another area where the new government will look to act substantively. The Green party co-leader Robert Habeck has been charged with leading a new ‘super ministry’ combining climate, energy and the economy. So far, he has not shied away from acknowledging the “gigantic” challenge Germany faces to hit its carbon dioxide emissions targets, with the liberal finance minister Christian Lindner announcing €60bn of investment in climate policies last month.

The coalition deal included a commitment to remove coal from the national energy supply “ideally” by 2030. This is a controversial area for Germany, with questions remaining about how the transition to cleaner energy will be completed: the country’s remaining three nuclear power stations are set to close by the end of the year. While the Greens will push for heavy investment in this area, it will have to be reconciled with the FDP’s insistence on restricted borrowing and ideological aversion to tax rises.

It cannot be said that Olaf Scholz is simply continuity Merkel

Where there seems to be clear consensus is on foreign policy. Baerbock has signalled much tougher stances on autocracies in Belarus and Russia, suggesting that the Nord Stream 2 pipeline could be halted if the latter invades Ukraine. This is a clear shift from Merkel-era policy, where the attitude towards Russia was dovish, particularly in the face of a volatile Trump administration in America.

A whole section of the coalition agreement was devoted to the rule of law, with support for the use of EU mechanisms to combat infringements of democracy. This will mean more pressure on the increasingly authoritarian governments of countries such as Poland and Hungary, as Germany’s influence within the EU means this cannot be taken as an empty threat.

On Brexit, the deal committed to preserving the Northern Ireland Protocol and supports retaliatory action if Britain does not fulfil its pledges contained in the Withdrawal Agreement.

With a huge programme to deliver the question of whether Scholz’s government can make good on its promises is an important one. Jeremy Cliffe points out that the last two governments fulfilled around 80% of their coalition agreements, so the prospect of the deal becoming reality are high. The traffic light government look to be transforming German society; whether or not the term pans out as planned, it cannot be said that Olaf Scholz is simply continuity Merkel.

Illustration: Verity Laycock

Support Palatinate