The budget and Conservatism

By Max Malone

In some online circles there is a quote humorously misattributed to the father of British conservatism Edmund Burke: “The lower taxes the more conservatism there is.” This derisive broken English put in the mouth of their opposition expresses the bitter disappointment that many Conservatives hold for the government’s latest budge

The ideological strands within the Tory party are numerous and complex. This government has advertised itself as the return to neoliberalism, sometimes called Thatcherism. This is the belief that the state should remove itself from the lives of individuals and allow the free market to fill the void, typically through cutting taxes and spending. While it is hyperbolically presented that they believe this to be a panacea, it is not unfair to accuse neoliberals of responding to most problems with a tax cut. This differs from Conservatism, which is based around governing pragmatically in order to balance the needs of the day with preserving the effective institutions and traditions of the past for the benefit of future generations.

Returning to the budget, the difference between the neoliberals in cabinet and the Conservatives throughout the party is stark. The ostensible reasoning behind this budget is the cost of living crisis. The government claimed that cuts to National Insurance and the five percent reduction in the top rate of income tax would free up much needed money in household budgets.

The latter policy lasted all of ten days, as the government faced pressure to ‘u-turn’ on the scrapping of the 45% upper tax limit. Nevertheless, the enduring elements of the mini-budget remain representative of a government committed to lower taxes.

This flies in the face of Conservative pragmatism. Those most affected by inflation aren’t those who make £150,000 or more a year. Additionally, the argument that we can grow our way out of inflation by cutting taxes to free up money for private investment holds little water. In the face of inflation, disposable income will be invested into assets with value outgrowing inflation like housing. The demand for this will be fanned by the cut in stamp duty, resulting in ballooning house prices and a spiralling cost of living. This insults modern Conservative tradition, particularly former Prime Minister Harold MacMillan’s notion of property owning democracy, by pricing many out of home ownership.

Furthermore, the cut to National Insurance appears to reject what Tories, most recently Kemi Badenoch in the leadership election, historically billed themselves on – tough choices and practicalities. Given the ever-increasing cost of caring for an ageing population, the previous government’s rise in National Insurance could be billed as a bitter necessity. Thus, to cut taxes is to acknowledge that it is the government’s policy to borrow in order to cover the cost, spitting in the face of Conservatism’s core bargain between past, present and future by expecting the future to pay for the present’s needs.

This embrace of neoliberalism may seriously jeopardise the seats gained from the most recent Tory landslide in 2019. Discarding the Conservative priority of national unity and its policy of ‘levelling up’ suggests that the new cabinet is not interested in governing within the mandate acquired in 2019.

A budget that relaxes financial regulation on the City and rejects regional investment outside the South-East further economically divides North and South risking the eventural loss of the ‘Red-Wall’ seats.

Thus, the recent budget leaves Conservatives within the Tory party cold. With their principles rejected and their electoral future looking bleak is it any wonder that the Truss government’s first meaningful action has been so ill-recieved in Conservative circles?

With the hindsight of ten days, it would seem that much of the party is not in fact comfortable with this return to neoliberalism. Whilst prominent members of Truss’s cabinet continue to hope to one day see the permanent slashing of taxes, neither the party’s backbenchers, nor the country appears to support such radical policy.

Image: Steve Daniels via Flickr