Rosebank is Labour’s renewable energy test
By Avesta Afshari-Mehr
When Labour came to power in 2024, its energy policy appeared refreshingly clear. No new North Sea oil and gas licences, a commitment to renewable power, and a transition away from fossil fuels that, after years of political hesitation, was finally supposed to put Britain on a credible path towards net zero.
Rosebank is now testing just how firm that commitment really is. Located around 80 miles north-west of Shetland, Rosebank is the UK’s largest untapped oil field. Environmental campaigners have spent years fighting plans to develop it, while the offshore industry and its political supporters argue that production would protect jobs, investment and Britain’s energy security.
The closure of the Strait of Hormuz during the US-Israel-Iran war has thrown global energy markets into renewed turmoil. At the same time, households remain painfully aware of the cost-of-living crisis. In such circumstances, domestic oil and gas production becomes an understandably attractive political proposition: why depend on unstable international markets when Britain still has resources beneath its own waters? But that argument risks confusing having fossil fuels with having energy security.
Oil extracted from the North Sea does not simply become cheap petrol for British consumers. Britain operates within an international energy market, meaning domestic production remains exposed to global prices. Rosebank could generate significant economic activity and support jobs, but environmental groups are right to question whether it would meaningfully insulate British households from international price shocks. This distinction matters. If Rosebank can’t guarantee cheaper energy, then Labour must be honest about what approving it would actually represent: a decision to extend Britain’s dependence on fossil fuel production rather than a simple act of national self-sufficiency.
The government’s recent approval of the Jackdaw gas field has already demonstrated how complicated this balancing act has become. Ministers have made the case that the project would support the UK’s gas supply, protect hundreds of jobs and contribute billions to the economy over its expected lifetime. Those benefits are difficult to dismiss, particularly for communities whose livelihoods have long depended on the offshore energy industry, and given that we are still in a cost of living crisis. But if every major fossil-fuel development can be justified by jobs, investment or a geopolitical crisis, when does the transition actually begin?
But if every major fossil-fuel development can be justified by jobs, investment or a geopolitical crisis, when does the transition [away] actually begin?
Labour can reasonably argue that Jackdaw and Rosebank differ legally from issuing entirely new exploration licences. These are existing projects moving through regulatory processes rather than straightforward reversals of the party’s manifesto commitment. But voters are unlikely to care much about the technical distinction if the practical outcome is another generation of major North Sea fossil-fuel extraction.
The project has become a test of whether Labour’s green agenda is a long-term strategy capable of surviving political pressure, or an ambition that becomes negotiable whenever fossil fuels appear temporarily convenient. This does not mean the government should simply abandon North Sea workers. In fact, doing so would be one of the fastest ways to undermine the renewable transition itself. A green economy cannot be built by telling skilled workers that their industries must disappear and hoping new employment eventually emerges.
Image Credit: Gary Bembridge via Flickr

