Are our university societies really building anything worthwhile?

By Avesta Afshari-Mehr

A simple scroll through Durham SU societies list and you’ll find everything from our Reform Society to the 93% Club to , from niche national groups to hyper-specific hobby collectives. We have cultural societies, political societies, sports societies, academic societies; and, yes, even a Hummus Society. On paper, it’s a triumph of pluralism. A patchwork of identities stitched together under the banner of ‘community.’ But what exactly are we building…?

Our societies are marketed as supposed ‘micro-democracies’: student-led; election-based; constitutional and grounded in freedom of speech. Promoters of each society promise employability; skill development; wellbeing; or even a ready-made social circle. Many offer taster sessions; membership for most are free. It’s a compelling pitch. Yet scratch beneath the surface and the picture becomes way more complicated.

There are some societies that are gloriously unserious. They exist to be funny, to be social, to facilitate dressing up and drinking together on a Thursday night. There is nothing inherently wrong with that. University should include levity. But let’s not pretend that all societies are equal engines of ‘professional development.’

As a former exec member of Banana Society, I can attest to this firsthand: it was, and remains, a friendship group who dress up as bananas and get drunk together. There was no real strategy; no structured outreach; no plans for anything more than social fun. It was fun. It was harmless. But it was not a profound civic organisation within Durham University.

The issue is not that such societies exist. The issue is that the SU structure often enables societies to form and receive initial monetary grants (which are often exploited), and then quietly dissolve once the founding group graduates or loses interest. It becomes less about building sustainable communities and more about formalising a pre-existing clique… with SU branding.

And then there are those academic societies at the other extreme: hyper-serious, hyper-political, hyper-strategic. Here, involvement is instantly translated into a flex on their LinkedIn profiles. Involvement with such societies are seen as training grounds for future investment bankers and parliamentarians. Elections are fought like miniature general elections, complete with slate politics and whisper campaigns.

Yes, in theory, elections are democratic. In practice, they are often popularity contests. With many memberships free, or priced low enough not to deter participation, it is easy to mobilise your friendship group to vote for you. A £10 fee is unlikely to be a barrier in a university where many students are well off. As a result of this: merit, vision and actual competence often become secondary to social capital.

And I have seen this from multiple vantage points: as the former President of the German Language & Culture Society, and a former committee member of the Durham Union. When elections become factionalised, debate shifts from ideas to personalities. Ad hominem attacks, quiet backstabbing and political polarisation become the norm, not an anomaly. The SU’s commitment to free speech is important, but too often it becomes an excuse not to intervene when internal cultures turn toxic.

Merit, vision and actual competence often become secondary to social capital.

Despite all this though, I’d say that societies can create genuine community.

Thanks to the numerous recent Durfesses, the Durham University Iranian Society, which I am the incumbent President of, has become cited as one of the most politically intense spaces in the whole of Durham. Our politics group chat can generate tens of thousands of messages during peak political events. It is polarised. It is passionate. It is sometimes exhausting. And yet, it is also open. At our last social, 40% of attendees were Britons. Minorities beyond Iranians regularly participate, and a sizable percentage don’t speak Farsi. Debate, even heated debate, does not automatically negate inclusion. 

But this is the paradox of Durham’s societies: they are messy, imperfect reflections of the student body itself. Some are little more than organised friendship groups. Some are miniature career machines. Some are deeply political. Some are glorified drinking clubs. But together they form a mosaic of modern Durham… aspirational; tribal; ambitious; occasionally absurd.

Why do we even formalise these niche hobbies in the first place? Because formal recognition brings legitimacy. A group chat becomes an official society; a friendship group an ‘exec.’ A shared joke becomes an annual ball. There is definite comfort in institutionalising identity, however trivial.

At what point does a hobby become work? Arguably when the admin, elections and branding outweigh the original joy. When running a society feels more like managing a small company than hosting a shared interest. When CV lines matter more than conversations. A quick look at the Durham Union or the Durham Diplomatic Society is enough to understand the extent of this: as some students treat their exec position as a full-time job, with their degrees as a second priority.And so, societies; cliques; CV additions… are we actually building anything worthwhile? Perhaps the answer is both yes and no. We are not constructing flawless micro-democracies or perfectly meritocratic institutions. We are building spaces that mirror us as a university community: ambitious; insecure; sociable; political; sometimes shallow; sometimes profound. The value of Durham’s societies lies not in their constitution or election results, but rather in whether they seriously leave students more connected than they found them. If they do that, even imperfectly, then perhaps the chaos is part of the point.

Image: Tim Packer via Wikimedia Commons