Why did nobody turn up to the riots in Durham?
By Avesta Afshari-Mehr
Over the past few weeks, we have seen a dramatic rise in disorganised rioting across the country – mostly orchestrated by what Starmer calls “far-right thuggery,” who sought to the streets following the incorrect assumption that the Southport attacks were committed by a Muslim refugee.
But despite concerns about widespread rioting, the actual turnout of rioters in many areas has been surprisingly low – particularly in Durham, which was expected to have two major riots on the 6th and 7th of August but despite a major police presence, attracted more counter-protestors than actual protestors. But why is this the case?
Perhaps one of the most significant factors contributing to the low turnout in these riots is the fragmented nature of far-right groups in the UK today. Unlike in previous decades, where groups such as the English Defence League (EDL) and the British National Party (BNP) provided a centralised structure and clear leadership to these sorts of protests, the current far-right landscape is much more disorganised and random. There is no longer a single organisation capable of rallying the masses of protestors and coordinating a large-scale movement. Instead, we see sporadic and mostly ineffective attempts at mobilisation that leaves the minority of individuals showing up to riot in a state of embarrassment.
There was no cohesive group to channel these sentiments into action
In Durham, this was particularly visible. Sure, hard right and anti-immigration sympathies do exist among a portion of the population, as we saw by the nearly 20% vote share for Reform UK in the last General Election – and yet there was no cohesive group to channel these sentiments into action. Without a force to organise and unify the masses, far-right demonstrators in the area thus lacked both the leadership and the logistical support necessary to turn their discontent into a significant public demonstration.
It’s critical to also establish that whilst Reform does maintain a radical anti-immigration stance and many of these rioters may most certainly be members of Reform, the party has not explicitly encouraged the rioting, merely sympathising with the movement.
Now, the strong electoral performance of Reform UK in Durham raises questions about the contrast between political support and the willingness to actually engage in street-level action. Reform UK, which positions itself as a right-wing party, has been successful in tapping into the dissatisfaction with mainstream parties, particularly around immigration issues, Brexit, and national identity/patriotism. However, their success at the ballot box was not necessarily conducive to a desire for direct action. It’s also crucial to establish that Reform, despite Nigel Farage’s alleged controversy of potentially inciting the riots, did not encourage or condone the rioting that has taken place.
There are several reasons for such a contrast. First, voting for a political party like Reform UK is a relatively low-effort way of expressing discontent, allowing voters to register their anger within the system, without requiring them to take on the risks associated with rioting or other forms of civil unrest. In contrast, participating in a riot involves significant personal risk – especially risk of arrest, injury, or disrepute.
And while some Reform UK voters may hold extreme views, many voters are moderates who are merely disillusioned with the status quo and are thus not as inclined to engage in rioting – in Durham, this variation in voting intentions within Reform UK may well contribute to the lack of enthusiasm for partaking in such riots.
These protests themselves were stirred up by misinformation; claims that the suspect of the Southport stabbings was a Muslim asylum seeker – he is in fact a British Citizen – have dented the credibility of the riots. Thus, the rioters lose all their ability to rally further support, particularly from those who do not already adhere to violent/rioting behaviours.
The city and surrounding area have a distinct social and political culture that differs from the more volatile urban centres where far-right activity has been more pronounced
Perhaps though the greatest deciding factor of why there was no proper riot in Durham itself is the demographics. Whilst polling suggests that anti-immigration sentiment has some traction in Durham, the city as a whole remains largely attached to its trade union history, with peaceful demonstrations the key way to garner attention. The city and surrounding area have a distinct social and political culture that differs from the more volatile urban centres where far-right activity has been more pronounced. Durham has a relatively strong sense of community and local identity, with deep-rooted ties to its historical and cultural heritage. This sense of local pride may act as a stabilising force, discouraging residents from engaging in actions that could harm their community.
Moreover, the local economy and social services in Durham, while facing challenges similar to many other parts of the UK, have not experienced the same level of deprivation or dislocation seen in other regions – and both economic stability and social cohesion can act as buffers against the appeal of extremist ideologies, making residents less susceptible to calls for radical action.
And finally, it is worth acknowledging the fact that Durham is equipped with one of the best police forces in the country – and as seen at both planned protests last week, Durham Constabulary were incredibly organised and well-equipped to disperse any hopes of a large protest: handing dispersal orders to anyone in the marketplace and bus station, guarding major streets, and turning away large groups suspected of being involved in the protest. Durham Constabulary arguably helped cripple any chances of a massive demonstration before it could even take place.
These instances of “far-right thuggery” have failed to appeal to anyone but the ‘thugs’ themselves. Their damage to society, as well as to the wider credible anti-immigration movement, is all that will be remembered by the population, and their fumbled message will be completely forgotten. Perhaps if rioters hadn’t based their protest off of misinformation, they would have been heard.
Image credit: mattbuck via Wikimedia Commons

