Plans for new private student accommodation rejected for a second time

By Elliot Burrin and Lily Gershon

Plans for a former care home to be turned into student accommodation have been rejected for a second time after an appeal was made to the Planning Inspectorate.

Unity Living submitted an appeal after their plans to convert Hallgarth Care Home, which closed last year, into a 69-bed student accommodation were rejected by Durham County Council in November 2023.

If successful, the Care Home would have been converted into 9 cluster apartments with a gym, games room, and shared living spaces for the 69 ensuite rooms.

However, the appeal was dismissed after the Planning Inspectorate recognised a need to balance the housing needs of the student and non-student population. The report noted that there was a duty to ensure “that areas of the city do not become dominated by student accommodation in the form of houses in multiple occupation (HMOs).”

We are aware of the Planning Inspectorate’s decision. The original application was refused on the grounds that the introduction of additional Houses of Multiple Occupation (HMOs) in this area could affect amenities for existing residents and contribute to increased levels of noise and disturbance

Michael Kelleher, Durham County Council’s head of planning and housing

Within Durham, the Council permits only 10% of properties in a certain area are exempt from paying council tax because they are used as student accommodation, helping to achieve this balance. However, this amount has exceeded to 27% of properties within 100m of Hallgarth Care Home, which the Inspectorate stated exceeds the “threshold beyond which […] further conversion to HMOs will not be permitted.”

The report also noted that Durham University “anticipated that the overall number of students at the University is expected to fall over the next few years” to around 21,500. Though consulted, Durham University neither opposed nor supported Unity Living’s plans for more student accommodation.

Amongst other reasons for dismissing the appeal, the Inspectorate recognised the concern of increased movement and the potential for antisocial behavior in the area at night time due to its close proximity to nightclubs. 

In response to the Planning Inspectorate’s ruling, Michael Kelleher, Durham County Council’s head of planning and housing, said: “We are aware of the Planning Inspectorate’s decision. The original application was refused on the grounds that the introduction of additional Houses of Multiple Occupation (HMOs) in this area could affect amenities for existing residents and contribute to increased levels of noise and disturbance.”

Image: James Tillotson