The Cultural Stains on Golden Fashion
By Keira Phillips
The historical location of America’s Golden Age is often contested. While historians have tried to define the American Golden Age, they cannot agree on when it occurred. It does not occupy a definitive place in time; instead, the term has been used incongruously. Scholars dispute its breadth, its multiplicity, and even whether it ever existed.
Although the term has been echoed throughout twentieth-century historiography, no dominant voice tells us where this Golden Age truly lies. Some point to the roaring ‘20s; others to the ‘30s and the ascent of Hollywood glamour; and many to the post-war period. Yet each era was underpinned by darker realities that tainted their golden image, making it impossible to establish a clear golden age. No period was as golden as it seemed.
The rapid evolution of American fashion could appear to signify economic success, as radical fashion created the illusion of prosperity. Yet the luxe fashion, largely modelled in Hollywood, often masked the social tensions rife within America. Hollywood was a technicolour paradise, and its fashion offered an escape from the bleak realities of the Great Depression. However, the opulence did not conceal as much as it hoped; these sad truths were woven into the very fabric of its clothing. Politics and fashion have always been and will always remain irrevocably tied.
Hollywood was a technicolour paradise, and its fashion offered an escape from the bleak realities of the Great Depression.
The 20s are often recognised as a period of radical change. Progressive gender ideas emerged from the Fin de Siècle, and society grew increasingly detached from the rigidity of the previous millennium. Women began to rebel against social expectations, reflected in flapper fashion. The flapper name has multiple proposed origins; one theory suggests it recycled the Victorian slang term for a young prostitute. By reclaiming a once-derogatory term and championing it, women were challenging perceived notions of womanhood. In 1922, Victor Margueritte published La Garçonne, a novel following Monique, a woman who seeks to reinvent herself after a failed marriage. She inherits the flapper ways and cuts herself a bob as a symbol of liberation. Whilst flapper culture was well established when the novel was published, the name created its own scandal. La Garçonne translated to ‘the boy’ with a feminine suffix. It revealed how flapper culture had become detached from the gender binary. It had established a space for itself which was neither expressly feminine nor masculine. Whilst flappers wore dresses, they often had boyish silhouettes that draped off the body rather than fitting to it.
Yet this fashion and the ideas it represented were not attainable for all women. The freedom was an illusion, as flappers often depended on male family earnings to sustain their lifestyles. Few had the financial means to participate in flapper culture, as the fashion was reserved for the upper middle class. What the simple silhouettes lacked, it made up for in expensive fabrics and beading, which drove up the prices. Ultimately, freedom was something only the wealthiest women could buy, existing only in appearance, not in reality.
The freedom was an illusion, as flappers often depended on male family earnings to sustain their lifestyles.
When the Great Depression hit in 1929, almost no woman could afford to project that same image of autonomy. The flapper icon slowly died, and the 1930s saw the return of form-fitting clothes. Madeline Vionnet introduced the bias cut, a construction technique whereby fabric was cut at a 45-degree angle to create figure-hugging clothing. Hollywood popularised this technique and began to promote the figure of the hyper-feminine woman.

As the economy suffered, women were being ushered back into domestic spaces to help support the working man. Fashion trends pushed this by encouraging women to retreat into an older image of femininity. In 1934, Claudette Colbert famously wore a bias-cut wedding gown for the opening scene of It Happened One Night. While the dress seemed the epitome of luxury and elegance, it actually represented social regression and economic recession.
In the very same film, Clark Gable did not wear an undershirt and was thought to have revolutionised men’s fashion as undershirt sales plummeted. This is a myth, more likely explained by the Textile Workers Strike and the lack of available cotton. While Hollywood appeared to pioneer new avant-garde fashion trends, the American economic and cultural landscape guided its hand.
While Hollywood appeared to pioneer new avant-garde fashion trends, the American economic and cultural landscape guided its hand.
Although Hollywood stars’ fashion generally promoted the status quo, some actors were anomalies. Katharine Hepburn pursued androgynous fashion long after the ‘20s, even controversially wearing trousers. She clashed with her studio, RKO, in 1938 over this fashion faux pas as they tried to confiscate her overalls. Although trousers became more normalised after WWII, they still carried stigma, revealing social anxieties surrounding women’s autonomy. Beneath fashion’s golden veneer lay some sad truths. While each age seemed to trailblaze new clothing trends, these trends were simply responding to America’s economic climate. Often, the glamour masked the harsh realities most Americans had to face.
Image Credit: The Philadelphia Story trailer via Wikimedia Commons

