Review: ‘Women Talking’

By Evie Read

*Content warning: discussions of assault against women and children*

Sarah Polley’s return to directing after a ten-year hiatus has been much anticipated within the film industry. The Canadian icon, director of Stories We Tell (2012), has landed triumphantly back onto the scene with not only her newest film Women Talking (2022), but also with Run Towards the Danger: Confrontations with a Body of Memory, her newly released collection of essays detailing multiple aspects of her life including her experiences as a child actress and navigating her way through high-risk pregnancies. One of these essays describes a pivotal moment in her life when a fire hydrant fell on her head and left her with a debilitating concussion for years after. It was a therapist, who during her attempts to get her life somewhat back to normal, gave her this piece of advice: “run towards the danger”. Polley claims this has been her life mantra ever since.

It therefore seems perfectly fitting that Polley should have been drawn to Women Talking, now a Best Picture nominee, as the film holds the notion of running toward the danger at its very heart. An adaption of the novel of the same name by Canadian author Miriam Toews, the story is based on real events that took place in an Old Colony Mennonite community in Bolivia between 2005-2009. During this time, the women and girls of this colony were waking up covered with bruises, blood and all manner of other bodily fluids, and were told by the elders in the community that they were being punished by the devil. It was later discovered that groups of men in the colony were using tranquillisers for the animals on the farm to drug the women and rape them in their sleep. These men were caught and arrested, and Women Talking takes place in the days after the men have left the colony.

While they are from a highly religious and closed off community, these women ask and attempt to answer some of the biggest and most relevant questions that exist today

A group of the colony’s women, comprised of the Friesen, Loewen and Janz families, gather in a hayloft and begin the process of running towards the danger. They must decide whether they stay and do nothing, stay and fight, or leave, and what follows is some of the most powerful cinema I have ever seen. While they are from a highly religious and closed off community, these women ask and attempt to answer some of the biggest and most relevant questions that exist today. At what age do young boys become a physical threat to them? Can the perpetrators also be seen as victims of the society in which they have grown up in? By forgiving the men, would they unintentionally be giving them permission to continue the attacks?

The women asking these questions include the ethereal Ona (Rooney Mara), an unmarried rape victim who is pregnant as a result of her attack; the bitter but ultimately terrified Mariche (Jessie Buckley), a young mother of several children who has suffered years of horrific physical and sexual abuse at the hands of her brutish husband; and Salome (Claire Foy), a woman fiercely determined to avenge the rape of her 4 year-old daughter. The performances from these three powerhouse actresses are naturally brilliant, and it is unfathomable that neither Buckley nor Foy made it into Best Supporting Actress at the Academy Awards this year. These are however but three members of an extensive ensemble cast that also includes the superb Ben Whishaw, Judith Ivey, Sheila McCarthy, Michelle McLeod, Liv McNeil, Kate Hallett, August Winter, and of course Frances McDormand in a small cameo role. 

It is a fascinating discourse, and it becomes clear quite quickly that that this film could just as accurately have been called Women Listening, as it is the perfect example of what a democratic and productive debate should look like. The women have very distinct and very different views, with them all coming to the conversation with their own trauma. But they listen to each other, and are ultimately allowed to change their minds, something which is all too often seen as a major character flaw. Polley’s script and direction shines a light on all of the different women at various points in the film, but as the narrative progresses, walls are shattered and the women begin to beat as one. Women Talking shows what happens when these women make decisions for themselves, when they take that necessary leap of faith, and when they begin running towards the danger.