Ocean Viking: time for Europe to turn the tide on treatment of migrants

By Claudia Heard

Franco-Italian diplomatic tensions reached a breaking point as France took in the 230 migrants aboard Ocean-Viking, an NGO-run ship forced to dock in the country following Italy’s refusal to accept them. While this brought to the surface the inhumane approach of Italy’s new far-right government, it highlighted that humanitarian responses like the one taken by France are all too rare.

Italy’s government is undoubtedly at fault here – Ocean-Viking had been stranded along the Italian coast, looking for a port that would take them, for over two weeks. According to SOS Méditeranée – the humanitarian organisation in charge of the ship – multiple requests to disembark had been acknowledged, but no port had been opened for them. Speaking to Euronews, Fulvio Vassallo Paleologo, former professor of asylum rights and constitutional status of foreigners at the University of Palermo, said ‘The criteria under which a state rescues migrants are not discretionary – but are set by international law – the Hamburg SAR convention, the EU Frontex regulation as well as the UNCLOS convention. Disembarkment must take place at the nearest safe port and in the shortest time possible.’ Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni defended the action, claiming Italy had already received 90,000 migrants this year. Of course, Italy’s disproportionate intake of migrants, given its position in the Mediterranean, needs to be taken into account. Already, their intake of migrants in 2022 is up more than 63% on last year’s figure. However, the time to debate this issue is not when a ship full of desperate migrants, mostly legitimate asylum seekers, is seeking refuge on Italy’s doorstep. Interior Minister Matteo Piantedosi suggested that the flag country of each ship was responsible for providing a safe port, not Italy. In the case of SOS, under a Norwegian flag, this is completely infeasible. Director General of SOS, Sophie Beau said the situation on board had reached a ‘critical stage’ with the risk of ‘loss of human life.’ Amid further reports that food and water were rationed, and respiratory and skin infections were spreading, it doesn’t seem likely that those on board would have reached Norway alive – in this case, Italy’s actions are nothing short of inhumane.

France is barely in a place to criticise

Though France did step in to accept the migrants at a port in Toulon, they are nevertheless part of the problem. As a result of their assistance, they are now freezing a previous agreement with Italy to take in 3,500 asylum seekers from them. All this does is create further uncertainty for people in need of help and treats them as nothing more than a tool for political mudslinging. It is also worth noting that Italy refused the ship on the basis that it had already taken its ‘fair share.’ Backpedalling on agreements to share the burden will only increase the possibility of such situations happening again.

Clearly, France is barely in a place to criticise. French Interior Minister Gérald Darmanïn called Italy’s inaction ‘incomprehensible’ and said they ‘lacked humanity.’ It must be asked, however, where this ‘humanity’ was when French officials left 27 migrants to die in the Channel last November. Earlier this week, newspaper Le Monde revealed damning documents from a French legal investigation. These showed that migrants sent WhatsApp messages and desperate calls for help to the French coastguard, while still in French territorial waters. Despite receiving persistent calls for over three hours, they refused to send support as they claimed that the boat was on course for British territory. Incidences like this show the devastating impacts of some European countries’ indolence and bureaucracy, as they would rather renounce responsibility than avoid a humanitarian catastrophe.

A more co-ordinated, EU-wide response is needed to prevent such scenarios from re-occurring

Sadly, however, the reactions of France and Italy are not surprising, given their increasing bases of right-wing support and the pressure to take a hard-line stance on migration. Italy’s predicament clearly shows that a more co-ordinated, EU-wide response is needed to prevent such scenarios from re-occurring. However, while pointing the finger at other countries and inflaming tensions around the issue of migration helps to maintain the fervent support of their voter base, the possibility of this looks bleak. In the meantime, the responsibility for protecting migrants will continue to fall on overstretched charities, who seem to be the only party remembering the human lives behind the figures. 

Illustration: Isobel Warwick