Review: ‘Tár’

By Evie Read

To define Todd Field’s Tár proves an impossibility. What surmises the film when watching it entirely transforms once the credits start rolling, and one is simply left to contemplate its contents through spouts of nervous laughter. The narrative operates as a grinding of genre. The film is bleak, tear-inducing, terrifying, and downright hilarious. Intentionally or not, Field has succeeded in creating perhaps the most confusing film of the year and he deserves to be praised for it. The film’s position as a front runner for Best Picture at the Academy Awards 2023 is fully justified, and I for one will be hoping for a win.

The film is bleak, tear-inducing, terrifying, and downright hilarious

Tár is a haunting narrative, tracking the precipitous downfall of composer-conductor Lydia Tár (Cate Blanchett). Her fictionality is why the film falls short of being a true biopic, but that is all. The character of Tár is a cringingly realistic creation, who’s ultimate disgrace mimics so many artists of today. Lydia is one of the greats in her industry, and she knows it. The film opens with her being interviewed on stage by Adam Gopnik and whilst most of us will have little idea as to what they are talking about, it immediately becomes clear from this conversation that as a conductor, Lydia is used to being in control. She declares: “You cannot start without me. I start the clock”, and as the film progresses it becomes clear that there is no line between her professional and personal life. The power she has over an orchestra seems to imprison her in a heightened bubble of self-importance, which in her eyes, doubles as a protective shield against cancel culture. What ensues is a story shaped around suicide, assault, self-identity and sexual harassment, leading to the protagonist’s realisation that she is perhaps not quite as shielded as she once thought herself to be. 

In this way, the film exists entirely in the world of 2022. It is only in recent years that we have seen power, money and celebrity failing to give a ‘get out of jail free card’ in the face of serious accusations, something we also see at the fore of Academy Award contender She Said, starring Carey Mulligan and Zoe Kazan. Further to these themes in Tár, the film embeds itself in the present with a jarring reference to the Covid lockdown. It is difficult to believe enough time has passed for Covid to be used as a passing reference, but perhaps it is this which makes it such an uncomfortable watch: Tár is a piece of artistic realism, not escapism. Despite this, it is an absolute joy to watch Blanchett in what has to be a career defining role. She perfectly balances Lydia’s contentious capabilities with just enough caustic wit and human fallibility to ensure we don’t entirely define her as a rude, brash, and unsympathetic being beyond redemption. We watch her as everything bubbles behind the eyes, waiting to boil over in the latter half, and when it does, it is magnificent. It would not be a surprise if Blanchett walked away from this film her with her third Oscar. A supporting cast including Nina Hoss, Noémie Merlant, Sophie Kauer and Mark Strong perfectly encircle her with just enough poignancy to leave lasting impressions, without ever pulling us away from Blanchett’s masterful performance. This is the Cate Blanchett show and it’s brilliant.

It is an absolute joy to watch Blanchett in what has to be a career defining role

As was previously noted, this is a film shaped by its final sequence, which is perhaps a notable problem for the film given its 2-hour 38-minute running time. Tár is genius, but only on account of the final scene, which many viewers may not arrive at. It is long and bleak, but if you persist you will be rewarded. The film cannot be pigeon-holed into a specific genre, but Field’s ending does give an insight into what informed his intention. By its closing, Tár becomes almost absurd, so much so that you question if you’ve entered into the realm of Yorgos Lanthiamos’ The Lobster. Suddenly a film that was suffering from repetitive prolongation is elevated, becoming one of the cleverest, funniest works of art to come out of 2022. In her interview at the beginning of the film, Lydia claims that “the reality is that from the very beginning I know precisely what time it is and the exact moment that you and I will arrive at our destination together”. In the context of the film itself, Field is the conductor, slowly carrying us towards his destination; the hilarious, absurd ending which imbues the film with its meaning. I write this having successfully arrived here. I just hope you can too.

Image: Lucas Alexander via Unsplash